1 / 19

MAA MathFest 2019 David Taylor , Roanoke College

Discover effective teaching practices that promote collaboration and self-reflection in mathematics classes. Explore peer review, student-created rubrics, aligning assessments, and reflecting on learning outcomes.

kmadison
Download Presentation

MAA MathFest 2019 David Taylor , Roanoke College

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. No Student Is an Island: A Plethora of Pedagogical Practices for Collaborative Mathematics Classrooms MAA MathFest 2019 David Taylor, Roanoke College

  2. Background • I have been teaching at Roanoke College for 12 years. • For academic year 2018-2019, I participated, along with 25 colleagues from all disciplines across campus, in an online course offered through the Association of College and University Educators (ACUE). • “Effective Teaching Practices: Career Guidance and Readiness”

  3. Today • Focus on four ideas to use in mathematics classes that encourage collaboration or self-reflection and align courses with course objectives: • Peer Review • Student-Created Rubrics • Aligning Assessments • Reflecting on Learning Outcomes

  4. Peer Review • Course: Calculus II (MATH 122) • Assessment: Mastery-Based Testing • Method: • Students are given a practice mastery topic to try on their own for five minutes. • In pairs, students review each other’s work, determine whether or not the topic would have been mastered, and discuss what went well and what needed improvement. • As a class, we discuss what they saw and learned, see an instructor solution, and have a discussion about what it truly means to master a topic.

  5. Peer Review • Course: Calculus II (MATH 122) • Assessment: Mastery-Based Testing

  6. Peer Review • Course: Calculus II (MATH 122) • Assessment: Mastery-Based Testing • Outcome: • Observationally, the rate at which students achieved mastery increased most after the first peer review session, and less so after additional peer review sessions. • Takeaway: • Peer review sessions are helpful for learning content, but even more helpful for promoting discussion about what mastery means.

  7. Student-Created Rubrics • Course: Introductory Statistics (INQ 240) • Assessment: Course Project • Method: • After doing one project and receiving feedback, students are tasked to create a rubric for the second (and third) projects. • In groups of two or three, students are asked to reflect on what went well on the first project and what could use improvement. • Then groups are asked to write down two or three categories for the rubric, followed by achievement level descriptions. • As a class we select about five categories for the rubric and refine the achievement level descriptions.

  8. Student-Created Rubrics • Course: Introductory Statistics (INQ 240) • Assessment: Course Project

  9. Student-Created Rubrics • Course: Introductory Statistics (INQ 240) • Assessment: Course Project • Outcome: • Students appear more invested in the project and show more improvement between projects than in the past. • Takeaways: • A bit of prompting and questioning during the process helps a lot, since students aren’t experts in rubric creation and there are items instructors know need to be included in some way. • Grading felt “better” knowing that the rubric was a collaborative effort.

  10. Aligning Assessments • Course: All • Assessment: Choosing Them • Method: • Nilson (2010) extended Bloom’s taxonomy in an effort to help instructors write powerful learning outcomes and determine the cognitive level of those outcomes. • Using those cognitive levels, use best practices to choose assessment techniques that are capable of measuring how well students are meeting the course-level learning outcomes.

  11. Aligning Assessments

  12. Aligning Assessments

  13. Aligning Assessments

  14. Aligning Assessments • Course: All • Assessment: Choosing Them • Takeaways: • This doesn’t require a wholesale course change; most of what I was doing already mapped well. • Learning more about mapping assessments to learning outcomes made me rethink and rewrite my learning outcomes. • The learning outcomes are now worth time discussing them on “syllabus day” and throughout the semester, rather than a required item on the syllabus.

  15. Reflecting on Learning Outcomes • Course: Real Analysis (MATH 381) • Assessment: Reflection on Learning Outcomes • Method: • Research shows that students appreciate a class more when its learning outcomes and goals can directly relate to future courses or potential careers. • I wanted students in Real Analysis to reflect on the learning outcome “students will be able to demonstrate an understanding of mathematical language and techniques of mathematical proof.” • I gave them a take-home quiz on the second day of class.

  16. Reflecting on Learning Outcomes

  17. Reflecting on Learning Outcomes • Course: Real Analysis (MATH 381) • Assessment: Reflection on Learning Outcomes • Takeaways: • It was a great assignment to learn more about my students and to get a sense of what they wanted to do after graduating. • Their reflections on the learning outcome and how they would talk to a future employer were amazing, but all over the place as a class. • I will modify this learning outcome in the future by breaking it into two, each that are more specific and following best practices.

  18. Final Thoughts • I was the only mathematics professor in our cohort of about 25 faculty taking the ACUE course. • Several “ideas” didn’t seem to map well to mathematics classes at first, but elements of those ideas can map extremely well (for example, peer review). • Paying more attention to the syllabus and learning outcomes throughout the entire semester can really help students appreciate the course itself and see how it maps into a larger program and can help with future careers.

  19. Questions? • I’d be happy to answer questions and/or engage in pedagogical discussion! • Contact: taylor@roanoke.edu

More Related