1 / 38

INSTITUTE OF PSYCHOLOGY Group of Personality and Developmental Psychology

INSTITUTE OF PSYCHOLOGY Group of Personality and Developmental Psychology. DARMSTADT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY. Effects of Parenting and Parent-Adolescent Relationship Quality on Deviance and Their Mediation by Depression and Social Skills J. Gowert Masche.

lavender
Download Presentation

INSTITUTE OF PSYCHOLOGY Group of Personality and Developmental Psychology

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. INSTITUTE OF PSYCHOLOGY Group of Personality and Developmental Psychology DARMSTADT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Effects of Parenting and Parent-Adolescent Relationship Quality on Deviance and Their Mediation by Depression and Social Skills J. Gowert Masche Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  2. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Question Question • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Effects on deviance attributed to behavioral control • (e.g., Barber, 1996; Steinberg, 2001). • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Effects on deviance attributed to behavioral control • (e.g., Barber, 1996; Steinberg, 2001). • But: Behavior control is not what it seemed to! • “Monitoring” actually is an aspect of open communication. • Behavior control much less important (Stattin & Kerr, 2000). • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Effects on deviance attributed to behavioral control • (e.g., Barber, 1996; Steinberg, 2001). • But: Behavior control is not what it seemed to! • “Monitoring” actually is an aspect of open communication. • Behavior control much less important (Stattin & Kerr, 2000). •  How does authoritative parenting work? • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Effects on deviance attributed to behavioral control • (e.g., Barber, 1996; Steinberg, 2001). • But: Behavior control is not what it seemed to! • “Monitoring” actually is an aspect of open communication. • Behavior control much less important (Stattin & Kerr, 2000). •  How does authoritative parenting work? • Test of mediation model. • Authoritative parenting  low depression and deviance • (Steinberg, 2001). • Effects on deviance attributed to behavioral control • (e.g., Barber, 1996; Steinberg, 2001). • But: Behavior control is not what it seemed to! • “Monitoring” actually is an aspect of open communication. • Behavior control much less important (Stattin & Kerr, 2000). •  How does authoritative parenting work? • Test of mediation model. • Not just authoritative parenting, but integrated factors of • parenting/relationship quality (Masche, 2004). Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  3. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Gender SES Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Theoretical Model Theoretical Model Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  4. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Methods > Sample Sample Darmstadt Student Survey 2000, part of C-NAP (Barber) N = 968 students at West-German city (135,000 citizen) Age 13 (grade 7) + age 16 (grade 10) Different school tracks 76 % German, others ethnically diverse 50.3 % girls, 49.7 % boys Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  5. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Out of N = 968 lived with... Age 13: 484 Age 16: 394 Age 13: 366 Age 16: 329 Mother 878 Father 695 673 Methods > Sample Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  6. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance .00 .00 gender Gender SES 1.00 SES • Index of • Ethnicity • School Track • Residential Area • Neighborhood Disorganization • ( = .74, 6 items,  Sampson & • Raudenbush, 1999) 1.00 Methods > Measurement Measurement Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  7. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Methods > Measurement > Parenting/Relationship Development of Parenting/Relationship Measures (Masche, 2004): 1. PCA of parenting (C-NAP) and relationship items (Masche), separately for mother/father and grades 7/10. 2. Construction of scales within each subsample. 3. Comparison, construction of scales for all subsamples. 4. PCAs separately for each subsample. 5. For the present study, highest loading scales selected. Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  8. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance 1.00 warmth ( = .92-.93, 15 parenting items) Positive Climate closeness ( = .92-.94, 15 relationship items) 1.00 emotional disengagement ( = .53-.63, 3 relationship items) Negative Climate .00 Low Control .00 1.00 ( = .66-.82, 5 parenting, 1 relationship items) no curfew rules Methods > Measurement > Parenting/Relationship Factor 1: Positive vs. Negative Climate Factor 2: Low Control Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  9. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Children’s Depression Inventory ( = .78, 10 items, Kovacs, 1992) 1.00 Child Behavior Check-List ( = .77, 5 items, Achenbach & Edelbrock, 1987) Depression Social Skills ( = .65, 7 items, Davis, 1980) 1.00 empathy social initiative ( = .77, 12 items, C-NAP) Methods > Measurement > Depression/Social Skills Depression Social Skills Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  10. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance aggression ( = .70, 5 items) 1.00 Both scales from the CBCL, Achenbach & Edelbrock, 1987 Deviance delinquency ( = .73, 8 items) Methods > Measurement > Deviance Deviance Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  11. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Age 13 Age 16 Positive Climate Positive Climate .81 .89 warmth warmth closeness closeness .94 .94 Results > Measurement Model Measurement Model Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  12. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance .68 CDI .76 CDI CBCL .54 CBCL .85 Depression Depression Empathy Social Initiative Social Skills 1.00 .52 empathy empathy social initiative social initiative .53 1.00 Results > Measurement Model Age 13 Age 16 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  13. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance .76 .86 aggression aggression delinquency delinquency .96 .76 Deviance Deviance Results > Measurement Model Age 13 Age 16 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  14. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Gender SES Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model Structural Model Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  15. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Mothers Age 13, Mothers -.37** .14* male male ses -.63** -.31** .14* .56** .43** -.62** -.50** -.10† .63** .35** .17* -.24** -.28** -.43** .18† ses ses -.30** male male .10† .32** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=253, df=30): .00 108.08 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  16. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Mothers Age 13, Mothers -.37** .14* male male ses -.63** -.31** .14* .56** .43** -.62** -.50** -.10† .63** .35** .17* -.24** -.28** -.43** .18† ses ses -.30** male male .10† .32** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=253, df=30): .00 108.08 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  17. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Mothers Age 13, Mothers .06 .14* male male ses -.63* -.25* .14* .67 -.62** -.10† .63** .17* -.22* ses -.38** male male .32** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=253, df=30): .00 108.08 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  18. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Mothers Age 13, Mothers .14* male male ses -.57** -.29** .14* .90† -.62** -.10† .67** .17* -.22† ses -.39** male male .32** AGFI: AIC: .97 90.00 RMSEA: 2(n=253, df=33): .00 111.22 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  19. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Fathers Age 13, Fathers -.43** .24** male male ses -.51** -.36** .18* .56** .51** -.62** -.42** .60** .27** -.27** -.41* .24* ses ses -.31** male male .37** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=172, df=30): .00 64.94 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  20. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Fathers Age 13, Fathers -.43** .24** male male ses -.51** -.36** .18* .56** .51** -.62** -.42** .60** .27** -.27** -.41* .24* ses ses -.31** male male .37** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=172, df=30): .00 64.94 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  21. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Fathers Age 13, Fathers -.60 .24** male male ses -.35 -.30* .18* .72 -.62** .64† -.50** male male .37** AGFI: AIC: .96 96.00 RMSEA: 2(n=172, df=30): .00 64.94 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  22. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Skills Results > Structural Model > Age 13, Fathers Age 13, Fathers .23** male male ses -.53* -.27* .19* .80* -.62** .53† -.22† ses -.43** male male .36** AGFI: AIC: .96 90.00 RMSEA: 2(n=172, df=33): .00 68.51 Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  23. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Mothers Age 16, Mothers -.21** male .26** ses ses -.35** -.33** -.17** .31* .24** -.59** ses .19* -.23** .14† male -.18* -.42** -.37** .13* ses -.12* male .29** AGFI: AIC: .95 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=292, df=24): .00 122.56  male/ses: -.16** Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  24. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Mothers Age 16, Mothers -.21** male .26** ses ses -.35** -.33** -.17** .31* .24** -.59** ses .19* -.23** .14† male -.18* -.42** -.37** .13* ses -.12* male .29** AGFI: AIC: .95 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=292, df=24): .00 122.56  male/ses: -.16** Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  25. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Mothers Age 16, Mothers -.11 male .26** ses -.35* -.31** .40** -.59** ses .21** -.23** male -.16** -.40** -.29** .21* .12† ses -.14* male .29** AGFI: AIC: .95 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=292, df=24): .00 122.56  male/ses: -.16** Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  26. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Mothers Age 16, Mothers male .27** ses -.39** -.33** .49** -.59** ses .23** -.23** -.21† male .21* -.16** -.40** -.30** .22** .13† ses male -.14* male .29** AGFI: AIC: .96 102.00 RMSEA: 2(n=292, df=27): .00 120.31  male/ses: -.16** Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  27. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Fathers Age 16, Fathers -.29** .14** male male .19** ses ses -.32** -.41** -.14† .30** .23* -.54** .21* .12* male -.12† -.44** -.46** .19* .15* ses ses -.13† .13† male .41** AGFI: AIC: .98 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=236, df=24): .00 88.31  male/ses: -.17* Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  28. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Fathers Age 16, Fathers -.29** .14** male male .19** ses ses -.32** -.41** -.14† .30** .23* -.54** .21* .12* male -.12† -.44** -.46** .19* .15* ses ses -.13† .13† male .41** AGFI: AIC: .98 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=236, df=24): .00 88.31  male/ses: -.17* Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  29. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Fathers Age 16, Fathers -.27† .14** male male .19** ses -.30* -.31** .31* -.54** .21* male -.44** -.36** .25* .15* ses ses .13† male .41** AGFI: AIC: .98 108.00 RMSEA: 2(n=236, df=24): .00 88.31  male/ses: -.17* Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  30. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Positive Climate Depression Empathy Negative Climate Deviance Low Control Social Initiative Results > Structural Model > Age 16, Fathers Age 16, Fathers .13** male male .22** ses -.40** -.33** .60** -.54** .24** male .29† -.13† -.44** -.42** .32** .16* ses male ses -.16† .15† male .40** AGFI: AIC: .97 102.00 RMSEA: 2(n=236, df=27): .00 104.39  male/ses: -.17* Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  31. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Integration of parenting/relationship and depression. • Differentiation of social skills measures. • Deviance somewhat more closely related to delinquency • at age 13, to aggression at age 16. Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  32. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Integration of parenting/relationship and depression. • Differentiation of social skills measures. • Deviance somewhat more closely related to delinquency • at age 13, to aggression at age 16. • Virtually no effect of parental control on deviance. Specific control measure Replication of Stattin & Kerr (2000) Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  33. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Integration of parenting/relationship and depression. • Differentiation of social skills measures. • Deviance somewhat more closely related to delinquency • at age 13, to aggression at age 16. • Virtually no effect of parental control on deviance. • No effect of empathy on deviance. Perhaps, empathic within own group only Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  34. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Integration of parenting/relationship and depression. • Differentiation of social skills measures. • Deviance somewhat more closely related to delinquency • at age 13, to aggression at age 16. • Virtually no effect of parental control on deviance. • No effect of empathy on deviance. • At age 16, weak path: control  social initiative  deviance, • but no direct effect of control. Different aspects: Control  teacher & school affiliation peer affiliation  deviance Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  35. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Integration of parenting/relationship and depression. • Differentiation of social skills measures. • Deviance somewhat more closely related to delinquency • at age 13, to aggression at age 16. • Virtually no effect of parental control on deviance. • No effect of empathy on deviance. • At age 16, weak path control  social initiative  deviance, • but no direct effect of control. • Positive Climate with parents  low level of deviance. • For mothers, effect of climate mediated by depression. • Sobel test mother/father: z = 2.85/3.19, p = .004/.001. Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  36. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Summary & Discussion Summary and Discussion • Positive Climate with parents  low level of deviance. • For mothers, effect of climate mediated by depression. 1 mechanism of authoritative parenting found: Warmth/closeness needed for healthy self-esteem; If lacking, either compensation by deviance or less resistant against peer-pressure. Limitation: Cross-sectional data allow for alternative causal paths. Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  37. Masche: Parenting/Relationship  Depression  Deviance Thank you! Paper: http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

  38. http://www.tu-darmstadt.de/ fb/fb3/psy/diffpsy/04issbd.ppt

More Related