110 likes | 199 Views
EMPLOYMENT AND WAGE EFFECTS OF PRIVATISATION: EVIDENCE FROM HUNGARY, ROMANIA, RUSSIA AND UKRAINE. J. David Brown, John S. Earle and Almos Telegdy. Presented by Alex Salo. Motivation. Performance gain Productivity raise Wage cuts Job losses Tradeoff?. How?.
E N D
EMPLOYMENT AND WAGE EFFECTS OF PRIVATISATION:EVIDENCE FROM HUNGARY,ROMANIA, RUSSIA AND UKRAINE J. David Brown, John S. Earle and AlmosTelegdy Presented by Alex Salo
Motivation Performance gain Productivity raise Wage cuts Job losses Tradeoff?
How? 30 000 initially state-owned firms From immediate post-Communist period to 2006 Domestic or Foreign? Productivity-improvement effect Scale-expansion effect Cost-reduction effect Productivity-improvement effect
Data Gosgomstat Restricted to manufacturing Under-reporting of wages to avoid taxes Arrears in Ukraine and Russia
Policies and Implications Hungary – fast, foreign, block-holdings Romania – large-scale employee ownership Russia and Ukraine – managers and employees with discount, then secondary trading
Empirical Strategy Heterogeneous results Avoid industry fluctuations Politicians influence Statistical techniques to avoid errors and correct bias
Conclusion No strong negative effects on either employment or wages Minor fluctuation in domestic firms Foreign – effects steadily grow onward Less likely negative effects appear in services Overall more positive effects