280 likes | 426 Views
Kypros-net Web Site: Learn Greek! On-line Course. SI 622 Evaluation of Systems and Services M. Elledge P. Zaphiris 4/15/00. The Project. Evaluate Learn Greek! language course Usability Functionality Quality Client: Kypros-net Originator/Administrator. The Product.
E N D
Kypros-net Web Site:Learn Greek! On-line Course SI 622 Evaluation of Systems and Services M. Elledge P. Zaphiris 4/15/00
The Project • Evaluate Learn Greek! language course • Usability • Functionality • Quality • Client: Kypros-net Originator/Administrator
The Product • Kypros-net description • Formation • Purpose
Learn Greek! Course • Course Description • Independent study course to learn Greek • 105 audio lessons, transcriptions, vocabulary, spell checker, dictionary • Objectives • Assist people in learning Greek language • Develop site using User Participation philosophy • Minimize expense (tapes from Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation (CyBC) radio; volunteers; MIT server)
Methods Used • Interviews with site creator, content contributors (2), director and administrator of U-M • Forty-three user surveys, 371 discussion board postings • Literature search of PsychInfo and Wilson databases • Comparative Evaluation with 16 web language sites • User testing of 8 tasks with 5 subjects • GTN for first two levels • Metaphor, Vocabulary analyses • Checklist/Cognitive walk-through on course • GOMS on 2 tasks
Key Client Questions • How useful is the course? • How functional is the course? • How well does it meet on-line course standards? • What can be done to improve the course?
Question #1 • How useful is the course? • Does it meet client objectives? • Does it meet user expectations? • Findings • Client objectives exceeded • User expectations met • Still, there are complaints
Findings • Client Objectives • Participatory Design: 105 lessons transcribed by 8 users; dictionary, spell checker installed by users; on-going help provided by users • Steady increase in site visits over time
Findings • User Expectations • High user satisfaction
Findings • Positive Comments: • EASY TO UNDERSTAND • Fun • It helped refresh my Greek • Finally after surfing for a long time I found that you could learn Greek from the internet • It is a very progressive course, builds up confidence as it goes • Very good method of learning • It falls into place after listening a couple of times. • Greek is the most kick-butt language on earth!!!!
Findings • Some User Complaints • Can’t download lessons • No pronunciation guide • Can’t compare text with lessons • Few instructions or information about course content
Discussion Board Postings Category/Subject#%Total % Technical Problems with needing/installing keyboard fonts 56 15.1% Problems with/wanting to download lessons 49 13.2% Problems with installing/using RealPlayer 40 10.8% 39.1% Content Postings of on-line notes 73 19.7% Questions about availability of text, CDs or including links to web sites 37 10.0% 29.7% Comprehension Questions about vocabulary 28 7.5% Questions about grammar/spelling 17 4.6% Questions about dialect 2 5.4% 17.5% Miscellaneous 69 18.6%18.6%
Question #2 • How functional is the course? • Do the operations work? • Is the architecture successful? • Findings • Site is subject to Internet vagaries • Learn Greek! architecture can be improved
Findings • Operations • ON the site generally work • Translations, lessons, etc. function • Waiting can become tedious • Web operations less dependable • Server downtime • Slow lesson downloads • Intermittent transmission
Findings • Architecture • Layout • Violates requirement for visual integrity • Inconsistent formatting • Labeling • Confusing (Greek to English in Greek?) • Incorrect (Vocabulary/notes = transcripts?) • Out-of-order (Instructions after the task?)
Findings • Architecture (cont.) • Content • Few instructions (RealPlayer, Greek fonts) • No “Help” or FAQ • Multiple translations • Navigation • Hard to find things (transcripts) • Search engine can’t target course
Question #3 • Does it meet language course standards? • Is the content appropriate? • Is the methodology appropriate? • Findings • Fairly unusual: hybrid of independent study + web-based learning • Pedagogy okay, course content can be enhanced
Findings • Lacks some features
Findings • Meets basic teaching methodologies
Conclusions • Yin/Yang: Strengths are also weaknesses • Accessibility vs. dependability • Participation vs. consistency • Frugality vs. thoroughness
Recommendations • Technical • Architecture • Content
Other Findings • Findings • Recommendations