E N D
1. Another look at PSRs:Intermediate Structure Starting X-bar theory
2. Flat Structure NP?(D) (AP+) N (PP+)
3. Flat Structure I bought the big [book of poems] with the red cover not the small [one] with the blue cover.
4. Flat Structure I bought the big [book of poems with the blue cover] not the small [one].
5. Flat Structure I bought this [big book of poems with the red cover] not that [one].
6. N Structure
7. N rules NP ? (D) N
N ? (AP) N or N (PP)
N ? N (PP)
8. One-Replacement
9. One replacement
10. Flat Structure in VPs VP? (AP+) V (NP) (AP+) (PP+)
11. John often sings opera loudly at church and Mary [does so too].
12. John often sings opera loudly at church and Mary frequently [does so too].
13. John often sings opera loudly at church but Mary rarely [does so] in the library.
14. John often sings opera loudly at church but Mary rarely [does so] quietly in the library.
15. V Structure
16. V rules VP ? V (a vacuous rule)
V ? (AP) V or V ({AP/PP})
V ? V (NP)
17. Do so replacement
19. Further Evidence for V
20. Flat Structure in APs AP? (AP) A
Tara is proud of Colleen
Susan is angry about the presidents politics
AP ?(AP) A (PP)
21. Flat Structure in APs AP? (AP) A (PP)
22. Bob is very angry about school violence but less [so] than he used to be.
23. Bob is very angry about school violence but less [so] about gun control.
24. A rules AP ? A (a vacuous rule)
A ? (AP) A
A ? A (PP)
25. A Structure
26. Flat Structure in PPs P ? P (NP)
Tara is very in love with her boss
PP ?(AP) P (NP) (PP)
27. Flat Structure in PPs PP? (AP) P (NP) (PP)
28. Mary was very in love with her boss, Susanna was less [so] PP? (AP) P (NP) (PP)
29. Mary was very in love with her boss, Susanna was less [so] with her husband. PP? (AP) P (NP) (PP)
30. P rules PP ? P (a vacuous rule)
P ? (AP) P or P (PP)
P ? P (NP)
31. P Structure
32. The New Rules (dont memorize these, we have a ways to go yet) NP ? (D) N
N ? (AP) N or N (PP)
N ? N (PP)
VP ? V
V ? (AP) V or V ({AP/PP})
V ? V (NP)
AP ? A
A ? (AP) A
A ? A (PP)
PP ? P
P ? (AP) P or P (PP)
P ? P (NP)
33. Generalization 1: 3 types of rules For each major category there are 3 types of rules:
A rule that generates the phrase NP ?(D) N
A rule that iterates: N ? (AP) N
A rule that introduces the head N ? N (PP)
34. Generalization 2: Headedness In each rule the only item that is obligatory is the item that gives its category to the node that dominates it:
NP ?(D) N
N ? (AP) N
N ? N (PP)
There are no rules of the form NP ? V AP. (this is called endocentricity)
35. Generalization 3: Optionality With the exception of determiners (more on that in chapter 6), all non-head material is both phrasal and optional
NP ?(D) N
N ? (AP) N
N ? N (PP)
36. Goals of X-bar theory Simplify the system of rules
Capture intermediate structure
Capture the cross-categorial generalizations.
We will use VARIABLES to do this. A variable is a category that can stand for any other category.
X, Y, W, Z are variables that can stand for ANY of N,V,A,P
37. The X-bar Rules Specifier Rule: XP ?(YP) X
Adjunct Rule: X ?(ZP) X or X ? X (ZP)
Complement Rule: X ? X (WP)
38. X-bar Structures
39. X-bar Structures
40. X-bar Structures
41. X-bar Structures
42. X-bar Structures
43. Summary Constituency tests show us there is intermediate structure in phrases. (evidence varies in strength)
There are Cross-Categorial generalizations to be made:
3 rules: Specifier, adjunct, complement
Headedness & Endocentricity
Optionality of modifiers
44. Summary X-bar rules:
Specifier Rule: XP ?(YP) X
Adjunct Rule: X ?(ZP) X or X ? X (ZP)
Complement Rule: X ? X (WP)
To do:
discuss the differences between the specifier/complement/adjunct rules
Account for crosslinguistic variation
tidy up some ugly loose ends (like the lack of motivation for the specifier rule, The fact that determiners arent phrases etc.)