180 likes | 665 Views
Need for Deen ( Mazhab ki Zaroorat ) INSAN KA MANSB-E- KHILAFAT (Status of Man as vicegerent). By: Muhammad Ali Khan. Difference b/w Deen and Mazhab. Concept Frame of Reference Canvas In religious connotation Nature (Individual and Collective). Religion is. Gods Allah Shiva Budhh
E N D
Need for Deen(MazhabkiZaroorat)INSAN KA MANSB-E- KHILAFAT(Status of Man as vicegerent) By: Muhammad Ali Khan
Difference b/w Deen and Mazhab • Concept • Frame of Reference • Canvas • In religious connotation • Nature (Individual and Collective)
Religion is Gods • Allah • Shiva • Budhh • Zeus • Aherman • Yazdan Practices(rituals) • Prayers • Meditation • Fasting • Alms • Youga • Experiences • Love/Ecstasy • Nothingness • Hell/Heaven • Tranquility • Sanctified • Sacrifice • Beliefs • Death • Life • Immortality • Atonement • Fate • Prayer Spirits : Demons, Ancestors, Ghosts
DEENLots of Ins and Outs and What-Have-Yours Deen is neither a single phenomenon, nor a “thing”; rather, it is a divine and dynamic collection of institutions, practices, and beliefs and social order
Attempts at a Definition • Edward Tylor • “The belief in spiritual beings.” • Clifford Geertz • “A religion is a system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivations in men by formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that the moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic.” • Emile Durkheim • “A religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, that is to say, things set apart and forbidden—beliefs and practices which unite into one single moral community called a Church, all those who adhere to them.”
Attempts at a Definition • Melford Spiro • “Religion is an institution consisting of culturally patterned interaction with culturally postulated superhuman beings.” • Peter Berger • “Religion is the human attitude towards a sacred order that includes within it all being—human or otherwise—i.e., belief in a cosmos, the meaning of which both includes and transcends man.” • Max Weber • Refused to attempt a definition of religion. [Smart Man?]
Concept • Spirituality- • EB Taylor ( Social) • Emotion Ethics • Mathew Arnold (Literature) • Emotional Appeal to accept Almighty • Freud (Psychology) • Only Rituals ? • Humanity
Need of Religion/Deen Pascal Boyer’s Religion Explained (2001) • Religion Provides Explanations • People created religion to explain puzzling natural phenomena • Religion explains puzzling experiences: dreams, prescience, etc • Religion explains the origins of things • Religion explains why there is evil and suffering
Need of Religion/Deen • Religion provides comfort • Religious explanations make mortality less unbearable • Religion allays anxiety and makes for a comfortable world
Need of Religion/Deen • Religion provides social order • Religion holds society together • Religion perpetuates a particular social order • Religion supports morality
Need of Religion • All civilizations have its Religions • Great civilizations are not died, they attempt suicide • Any social system requires religion • Science and Religion • Good & Bad given by Religion • Guidance to Wisdom • Religion as Change Agent for Natural, Spiritual, social needs
Cont… • Universal peace v/s materialistic development (survival of the fittest is questioned) • Life after death – possibility only in religion • Accountability here and in life after death • Religion for Social Correction • Religion as Panacea
Liberal Arguments for need of Deen /Religion • August Comte • Theological (Religion) • Metaphysical (Philosophy and Psychology) • Positive Stage (Science) • Napoleon says “It has kept the poor murdering the rich” • Supernatural hope in dooms hopes (Imam Jaffar RA) • When humans are unknowing and confused they make theories in order to solve things. theories are usually proven false and it takes generations to believe the proof • Heaven and utopia are buckets in a well if one goes up other goes down • Religion Rich in Miracle system and myths is needed
Cont… Religion is a cognitive approach • People are superstitious; they will believe anything • Religious concepts are irrefutable and Refutation is more difficult than belief
Epilogue • Even rationalism w/o religion will be blunder • As long as there is poverty these will be gods • Evolution. Nature -law of nature • First force. If events are due to natural cause then what is super natural cause • God is a beautiful idealization of human wishes
A thought ! • Is religion possible without GOD ? • Is religion a cause to recognize the GOD • Will religion end when human beings will reach at Heaven or Hell • Hazrat Ali (RA) said “Mein nyapnyKhudakoapnyeradon k totnysypahchana” ( I recognized my God , when my intentions doomed)