550 likes | 676 Views
Doubly charmed mesons from hadronic molecules. KEK S. Yasui. Future Prospects of Hadron Physics at J-PARC and Large Scale Computational Physics @Ibaraki Quantum Beam Research Center 9-11 Feb. 2012. Contents. Introduction 2 . Doubly charmed mesons ( Tcc )
E N D
Doubly charmed mesons from hadronic molecules KEK S. Yasui Future Prospects of Hadron Physics at J-PARC and Large Scale Computational Physics @Ibaraki Quantum Beam Research Center 9-11 Feb. 2012
Contents • Introduction • 2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) • S. H. Lee, S.Y., W. Liu, C. M. Ko, Eur. Phys. C54, 259 (2008) • S. H. Lee, S.Y., Eur. Phys. C64, 283 (2009) • S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 3.Otherexoticheavyhadrons (→ poster session) • S.Y., K. Sudoh, Phys. Rev. D80, 034008 (2009) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, Phys. Rev. D84, 014032 (2011) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, arXiv:111.2691 (appear in PRD) • S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1111.2921 4. Summary
1. Introduction Manynewccstatesabovethreshold quarkoniumcc + exoticstates quarkoniumcc Eichten in QWG 2008 Nara
1. Introduction • Whyaretheyexotic? • unusualdecaywidths and branchingratios • unexpectedstates different fromccquarkmodel X(3872), X(3940), Y(4260), Z(4430)+, ... Yb , Zb+, ... c c c c X(3872) Y(4260) Z(4430)+ (Zb+) Tcc1 g d c d c c c ccud reallytetraquark ccud (bbud) reallytetraquark DD* (ccuu) molecule Tornqvist (1991) ccg hybrid S. L. Zhu (2005) Cornel potential Coulomb 1/r + confinementkr u u c DD* threshold ? gluondynamics ? isospincorrelation ? diquarkcorrelation ? u c u
1. Introduction Mass scales and Symmetries 1500 [MeV] 4700 3 5 150 200 m b c ΛQCD ud s Chiral Symmetry SU(3)L x SU(3)R π, K as Nambu-Goldstone bosons Chiralmultiplets (ρ-a1, N-N*, ...) Nuclei formed by tensor force Λ(1405) and K nuclei ...
1. Introduction Mass scales and Symmetries 1500 [MeV] 4700 3 5 150 200 m b c ΛQCD ud s Chiral Symmetry SU(3)L x SU(3)R π, K as Nambu-Goldstone bosons Chiralmultiplets (ρ-a1, N-N*, ...) Nuclei formed by tensor force Λ(1405) and K nuclei ...
1. Introduction Mass scales and Symmetries 1500 [MeV] 4700 3 5 150 200 m b c ΛQCD ud s ??? Chiral Symmetry Chiral Symmetry SU(3)L x SU(3)R SU(4)L x SU(4)R π, K as Nambu-Goldstone bosons Chiralmultiplets (ρ-a1, N-N*, ...) Nuclei formed by tensor force Λ(1405) and K nuclei ...
1. Introduction Mass scales and Symmetries 1500 [MeV] 4700 3 5 150 200 m b c ΛQCD ud s Heavy Quark Symmetry Chiral Symmetry SU(3)L x SU(3)R SU(2)spin xSU(Nh) π, K as Nambu-Goldstone bosons Chiralmultiplets (ρ-a1, N-N*, ...) Nuclei formed by tensor force Λ(1405) and K nuclei ...
1. Introduction Mass scales and Symmetries 1500 [MeV] 4700 3 5 150 200 m b c ΛQCD ud s Heavy Quark Symmetry Chiral Symmetry SU(3)L x SU(3)R SU(2)spin xSU(Nh) π, K as Nambu-Goldstone bosons D-D* (Σc-Σc*, Ξcc-Ξcc*) mass degeneracy (heavy quark sym.) Chiralmultiplets (ρ-a1, N-N*, ...) X, Y, Z, … Nuclei formed by tensor force More exotics? (like Tcc) Λ(1405) and K nuclei Charmed/Bottomed nuclei ? ...
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c ✓ no strong annihilation ✓ no strong annihilation tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1 ✓ no strong annihilation
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c ✓ no strong annihilation ✓ no strong annihilation tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1 ✓ no strong annihilation
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Carlson, Heller, Tjon (1988) Silvestre-Brac and Semay (1993) Lee, SY, Liu and Ko (2008) Lee and SY (2009) „explicitly“ exotic tetraquark Tcc1 D0 ✓ no annihilation Tcc1 D*- ? u c c + I(JP)=0(1+) c d Spin-color int. sBa(a=1,..,8) induces d c furthersuppressed 1/mQ2 cc pair u suppressed 1/mQ1 cu pair 1/mQ0 dominant attraction (3c, I=0, s=0) ud pair
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Carlson, Heller, Tjon (1988) Silvestre-Brac and Semay (1993) Lee, SY, Liu and Ko (2008) Lee and SY (2009) „explicitly“ exotic tetraquark Tcc1 D0 ✓ no annihilation Tcc1 D*- ? u c c + I(JP)=0(1+) c d Spin-color int. sBa(a=1,..,8) induces d c furthersuppressed 1/mQ2 cc pair u suppressed 1/mQ1 cu pair 1/mQ0 dominant attraction (3c, I=0, s=0) ud pair
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Carlson, Heller, Tjon (1988) Silvestre-Brac and Semay (1993) Lee, SY, Liu and Ko (2008) Lee and SY (2009) „explicitly“ exotic tetraquark Tcc1 D0 ✓ no annihilation Tcc1 D*- u c c + I(JP)=0(1+) c No strongdecay d Spin-color int. sBa(a=1,..,8) induces d c furthersuppressed 1/mQ2 cc pair u suppressed 1/mQ1 cu pair 1/mQ0 dominant attraction (3c, I=0, s=0) ud pair
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Carlson, Heller, Tjon (1988) Silvestre-Brac and Semay (1993) Lee, SY, Liu and Ko (2008) Lee and SY (2009) „explicitly“ exotic tetraquark Tcc1 D D0 ✓ no annihilation Tcc1 D*- u c c + I(JP)=0(1+) c No strongdecay d d c D* threshold (3880 MeV) ~ 75 MeV u Stable bound state (decay only weakly) Tcc1
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Manohar, Wise (1993) Tornqvist, (1994) Ding, Liu, Yan (2009) Ohkoda, Yamaguchi, Y, Sudoh, Hosaka (2011) tetraquark vs. hadronic molecule? D tetraquark hadronic molecule D* u c c c meson exchange d d c (di)quark D, D* meson d.o.f color isospin gluon-exchange (color-spin) meson-exchange (OPEP) int. u mass deeply bound? shallow bound/resonance?
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Manohar, Wise (1993) Tornqvist, (1994) Ding, Liu, Yan (2009) Ohkoda, Yamaguchi, Y, Sudoh, Hosaka (2011) tetraquark vs. hadronic molecule? D tetraquark hadronic molecule D* u c c c meson exchange d d c (di)quark D, D* meson d.o.f color isospin gluon-exchange (color-spin) meson-exchange (OPEP) int. u mass deeply bound? shallow bound/resonance?
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Strangeness, Charm, Bottom, ... K K D D B B ? ?? K K D D B B SU(3) SU(4) SU(5) Weinberg-Tomozawa
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Strangeness, Charm, Bottom, ... K* K* is almost irrelevant in dynamics... vector But D* and B* are new ingredients! 400 MeV D* B* 140 MeV pseudo- scalar 45 MeV D B K 500 MeV 1870 MeV 5280 MeV Chiral Symmetry Heavy Quark Symmetry
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Strangeness, Charm, Bottom, ... K D(*) B(*) D(*) K B(*) p, ω, ρ p, ω, ρ p, ω, ρ K D(*) B(*) K D(*) B(*) One pion is absent. (short range force) One pion is present. (long range force) Weinberg-Tomozawa One pion exchange potential (OPEP) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 D(*) D(*) potential Heavy Quark Symmetry G. Burdman and J.F. Donoghue (1992) M.B. Wise (1992) T.-M. Yan, H.-Y. Cheng, C.-Y. Cheung, G.-L. Lin, Y.C. Lin and H.-L. Yu (1997) D(*) D(*) D(*)D(*)π vertex p, ω, ρ with P=D, B vector + pseudoscalar D(*)D(*)ω and D(*)D(*)ρ vertex D(*) D(*) R. Casalbuoni et al, Phys. Rep. 281, 145 (1997) Cf. NNπ, NNω, NNρ vertex from Bonn potential R. Machleidt et al, Phys. Rep. 149, 1 (1987)
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 D(*) D(*) potential Heavy Quark Symmetry G. Burdman and J.F. Donoghue (1992) M.B. Wise (1992) T.-M. Yan, H.-Y. Cheng, C.-Y. Cheung, G.-L. Lin, Y.C. Lin and H.-L. Yu (1997) D(*) D(*) D(*)D(*)π vertex from Γ(D*→Dπ) p, ω, ρ with P=D, B vector + pseudoscalar D(*)D(*)ω and D(*)D(*)ρ vertex fromleptonic and radiativedecay of B D(*) D(*) R. Casalbuoni et al, Phys. Rep. 281, 145 (1997) Cf. NNπ, NNω, NNρ vertex from Bonn potential R. Machleidt et al, Phys. Rep. 149, 1 (1987)
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 D(*) D(*) potential Heavy Quark Symmetry G. Burdman and J.F. Donoghue (1992) M.B. Wise (1992) T.-M. Yan, H.-Y. Cheng, C.-Y. Cheung, G.-L. Lin, Y.C. Lin and H.-L. Yu (1997) D(*) D(*) D(*)D(*)π vertex from Γ(D*→Dπ) p, ω, ρ with P=D, B vector + pseudoscalar D(*)D(*)ω and D(*)D(*)ρ vertex fromleptonic and radiativedecay of B D(*) D(*) R. Casalbuoni et al, Phys. Rep. 281, 145 (1997) Cf. NNπ, NNω, NNρ vertex from Bonn potential R. Machleidt et al, Phys. Rep. 149, 1 (1987)
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 D(*) D(*) potential Form factor at eachvetex D(*) D(*) p, ω, ρ ΛD,B/ΛN = (rD,B/rN)-1 rD,B,N : hadronsizefromquarkmodel D(*) D(*) ΛNfor NNπ(ρ,ω) vertexisfixed to reproduce a deuteron. SY and Sudoh, PRD80, 034008 (2009) Yamaguchi, Ohkoda, SY, Hosaka, PRD84, 014032 (2011) Yamaguchi, Ohkoda, SY, Hosaka, arXiv:1112691 (appear in PRD)
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 D(*) D(*) potential Form factor at eachvetex D(*) D(*) p, ω, ρ ΛD,B/ΛN = (rD,B/rN)-1 rD,B,N : hadronsizefromquarkmodel D(*) D(*) ΛNfor NNπ(ρ,ω) vertexisfixed to reproduce a deuteron. All parameters (coupling constants, cut-offs) are fixed. SY and Sudoh, PRD80, 034008 (2009) Yamaguchi, Ohkoda, SY, Hosaka, PRD84, 014032 (2011) Yamaguchi, Ohkoda, SY, Hosaka, arXiv:1112691 (appear in PRD)
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 I(JP) (J≤2) in D(*)D(*) states
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 I(JP) (J≤2) in D(*)D(*) states
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 I(JP) (J≤2) in D(*)D(*) states Tcc1
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 I(JP) (J≤2) in D(*)D(*) states Tcc1 D D* S-wave (1) DD, DD*, D*D* mixing D* D-wave D* (2) Tensor mixing (OPEP) S-wave D D*
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 tetraquark vs. D(*)D(*) molecule tetraquark Tcc1 D(*)D(*) molecule tetraquark
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 tetraquark vs. D(*)D(*) molecule D(*)D(*) tetraquark Tcc1 D(*)D(*) molecule tetraquark
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 tetraquark vs. D(*)D(*) molecule D(*)D(*) tetraquark Tcc1 D(*)D(*) molecule tetraquark
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1202.0760 tetraquark vs. D(*)D(*) molecule Energy spectrum is very different !! (a) g.s. is negative parity. (b) many resonant states can exist. (c) I=1 state can exist. D(*)D(*) tetraquark Tcc1 D(*)D(*) molecule tetraquark
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons Belle, arXiv:1105.4583 Zb(10608) M1=10608.4±2.0 MeV, Γ1=15.6±2.5 MeV I(JPC)=1(1+-) Zb(10653) M2=10653.2±1.5 MeV, Γ2=14.4±3.2 MeV exp. exp. Ourprediction I=1 I=0, exotic JPC S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1111.2921
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons Belle, arXiv:1105.4583 Zb(10608) M1=10608.4±2.0 MeV, Γ1=15.6±2.5 MeV I(JPC)=1(1+-) Zb(10653) M2=10653.2±1.5 MeV, Γ2=14.4±3.2 MeV exp. exp. Ourprediction I=1 I=0, exotic JPC S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1111.2921
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons Belle, arXiv:1105.4583 Zb(10608) M1=10608.4±2.0 MeV, Γ1=15.6±2.5 MeV I(JPC)=1(1+-) Zb(10653) M2=10653.2±1.5 MeV, Γ2=14.4±3.2 MeV exp. exp. Ourprediction I=1 I=0, exotic JPC Υπ, hbπ loop effect (rough estimate) S. Ohkoda, Y. Yamaguchi, S.Y., K. Sudoh, A. Hosaka, arXiv:1111.2921
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D bound nuclei D D c N d c tetraquark Tcc1 Zb (isospin 1) B B u I=1
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D and nucleon D*+N (2947 MeV) D*+N (2947 MeV) No other channels → Only DN and D*N D+N (2803 MeV) D+N (2803 MeV) Σc(2800) 1(??) π+Σc* (2658 MeV) Λc(2625) 0(3/2-) Λc(2595) 0(1/2-) π+Σc (2593 MeV) `Pentaquark-channel‘ `Λ*-channel‘ • S.Y., K. Sudoh, Phys. Rev. D80, 034008 (2009) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, Phys. Rev. D84, 014032 (2011) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, arXiv:111.2691 (appear in PRD)
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D*+N (2947 MeV) No other channels → Only DN and D*N D+N (2803 MeV) D N S-wave D* D-wave N S-wave D N `Pentaquark-channel‘ • S.Y., K. Sudoh, Phys. Rev. D80, 034008 (2009) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, Phys. Rev. D84, 014032 (2011) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, arXiv:111.2691 (appear in PRD)
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons D and nucleon D*+N (2947 MeV) D*+N D+N No other channels → Only DN and D*N D+N (2803 MeV) D N S-wave D* D-wave N S-wave D N `Pentaquark-channel‘ • S.Y., K. Sudoh, Phys. Rev. D80, 034008 (2009) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, Phys. Rev. D84, 014032 (2011) • Y. Yamaguchi, S. Ohkoda, S.Y., A. Hosaka, arXiv:111.2691 (appear in PRD)
3. Otherexoticheavyhadrons BN state DN state 6263 MeV 2946 MeV B*N D*N Λ(1405) 6217 MeV BN 1433 MeV KN B nuclei H dibaryon 2807 MeV 2255 MeV DN ΞN πΣ D nuclei 1330 MeV ΛΛ 2230MeV Hypernuclei Knuclei
4. Summary ・ Heavy quarks have new symmetry and dynamics. Heavy quark symmetry D-D* mixing ... ・ Many exotic heavy hadrons and nuclei. Tcc1 and other DD states Zb (I=1) and other BB states (→ Ohkoda’s poster) DN bound/resonance states (→ Yamaguchi’s poster) D bound nuclei ・ Lattice QCD analysis? ・ Searches in e+e-, pp (pp) and heavy ion collisions should be performed.
ExHIC (Exotics from Heavy Ion Collisions) collaboration S. Cho (Yonsei U.),T. Furumoto(YITP and RIKEN), T. Hyodo (Tokyo Inst. Technology),D. Jido (YITP), C.-M. Ko (Texas A&M U.), S. H. Lee (Yonsei U. and YITP), M. Nielsen (U. de Paulo), A. Ohnishi (YITP), T. Sekihara (YITP and Kyoto U.), K. Yazaki (YITP and RIKEN), S. Y. (KEK) PRL106, 212001 (2011); PRC84, 06491 (2011) Hadronmolecule 1 Normal hadron 0.2 Multi-quark
2. Doublycharmedmesons (Tcc) Carlson, Heller, Tjon (1988) Silvestre-Brac and Semay (1993) Lee, SY, Liu and Ko (2008) Lee and SY (2009) „explicitly“ exotic tetraquark Tcc1 D0 ✓ no annihilation Tcc1 D*- u c c + I(JP)=0(1+) c No strongdecay d d c Binding energy of Tcc(bb)1 [MeV] u → Tcc(bb)1 are stable as 3fmultiplet of SU(3)f.