60 likes | 117 Views
Learn why rubrics are essential for improving grading clarity, student work quality, and efficiency; explore holistic and analytic rubrics, parts, and flaws; understand criteria and scoring strategies for impactful assessment.
E N D
Rubrics VaNTH-PER Workshop June 2, 2004 Barbara A Austin
Why Use Rubrics? • Grading becomes more clear, concise, and fair • Quality of student work increases • Grading time is used more efficiently • Students spend time meeting expectations, not figuring them out • Clearly conveys what constitutes quality work
About Rubrics • Holistic • Pros: good for identifying summative learning • Cons: detailed feedback is limited • Analytic • Pros: student-friendly, good for communicating • Cons: focus on details rather than big picture
Parts of a rubric • Evaluative criteria • MUST be teachable • Must address essential learning outcomes of the discipline • Quality definitions • Scoring strategy
Typical flaws in rubrics • Task-specific evaluative criteria • Excessively general criteria • Dysfunctional detail • Equating the test of the skill with the skill itself
Characteristics of a good rubric: • Has 3 –5 evaluative criteria • Each criterion must represent a key attribute of what is being assessed • Each criterion must be teachable