E N D
1. Angus Polypharmacy Initiative Douglas Lowdon
Acute / Community Geriatric Consultant, Angus
2. Is Polypharmacy a problem ??
4. Acute Medical Unit admission 101 year old lady
Lives alone with carers 4 times/day
Admitted with 2 week history of reduced oral intake, nausea, weight loss, reduced mobility and twitching
Past medical history
MI – Dec 2010. Treated conservatively.
Atrial fibrillation
Hypertension
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
5. Drug History Candesartan 8mg od
Clopidogrel 75mg od
Aspirin 75mg od
Rosuvastatin 10mg od
Spironolactone 25mg od
Furosemide 20mg od
Glipizide 5mg od
Metformin 500mg bd
Ranitidine 300mg bd
Ferrous sulphate 200mg tid
Bisoprolol 5mg od
Digoxin 125 micrograms od
Paracetamol 1g qid
Prochlorperazine 5mg bd
Recent 3/7 course of trimpethoprim for ?UTI
6. Examination findings Dehydrated
Confused – MSQ 3/10
Bradycardic – 50bpm
Hypothermic – temp 35.7
BP 180/40, RR 22, Sa02 100% (air)
Globally reduced muscle power
Examination otherwise unremarkable
7. Initial investigations Bloods Na 141
K 8.7
Urea 31.5
Creatinine 222
Digoxin 2.2
LFTs normal
CK 53
Lactate 1.0
Bic 12.3
Hb 11.1
WCC 12.9 (neutrophilia)
Platelets 228 ABG – partially compensated metabolic acidosis ECG –
sinus bradycardia 50bpm
Deep anterior Q waves and poor R wave progression in chest leads
Digoxin effect V5-6
8. Diagnosis and Management Acute kidney injury with severe hyperkalaemia
Digoxin toxicity
Management
Nephrotoxics stopped
IV fluids
IV Calcium gluconate
Insulin/dextrose infusions
Salbutamol
Medication review
9. Medication Review 11 medications discontinued:
Nephrotoxics & diuretics stopped due to AKI/hyperkalaemia
Digoxin & bisoprolol stopped to bradycardia
Metformin stopped due to acidosis
Rosuvastatin & Clopidogrel – no evidence in age group
Ranitidine
Ferrous sulphate
Prochlorperazine
Discharge medications – aspirin, glipizide, domperidone
10. Medication Review 11 medications discontinued:
Nephrotoxics & diuretics stopped due to AKI/hyperkalaemia
Digoxin & bisoprolol stopped to bradycardia
Metformin stopped due to acidosis
Rosuvastatin & Clopidogrel – no evidence in age group
Ranitidine
Ferrous sulphate
Prochlorperazine
Discharge medications – aspirin, glipizide, domperidone
BUT re-admission 10 days later with Cardiac Failure, so diuretic and candersartan re-introduced
11. Why is Polypharamcy so common in the elderly?
12. Why is Polypharamcy so common in the elderly?
13.
“Doctors are men who prescribe medicines of which they know little, to cure diseases of which they know less, in human beings of whom they know nothing”
?- Voltaire
14. South Angus Polypharmacy Initiative
15. Angus Polypharmacy Initiative
1. Care Home annual joint medication reviews
2. Polypharmacy reviews of patients aged older than 75 years and on 12 or more medications
16. How to do Community Polypharmacy review Gold standard would be in conjunction with patients own Practitioner and Practise pharmacist:
GP buy-in to allow optimal drug changes
Helps Practise Pharmacists in future to influence GP prescribing behaviour
Educational element – three way
Additional information
Increase patient trust and satisfaction
Community / locality Geriatrics
17. How to do Community Polypharmacy review In conjunction with patients own Practitioner and ideally Practise pharmacist:
GP buy-in to allow optimal drug changes
Helps Practise Pharmacists in future to influence GP prescribing behaviour
Educational element – three way
Additional information
Increase patient trust and satisfaction
Community / locality Geriatrics
Patient in attendance and ideally with relative
18. How to do Polypharmacy review In conjunction with patients own Practitioner and ideally Practise pharmacist:
GP buy-in to allow optimal drug changes
Helps Practise Pharmacists in future to influence GP prescribing behaviour
Educational element – three way
Additional information
Increase patient trust and satisfaction
Community / locality Geriatrics
Patient in attendance and ideally with relative
Secondary care notes in attendance
Patient drugs in attendance too !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
19. How to do Polypharamcy review in older people STOPP (Screening Tool of Older Peoples’ Potentially In-appropriate Prescriptions)
Age and Ageing 2008, Gallagher P, O Mahoney D
NSAIDS, especially heart failure, renal disease and previous peptic ulcer disease
Alpha blockers, especially in heart failure
Anti-muscarinics
Sedatives, in particular benzodiazepines
Opiate analgesia
Warfarin and anti-platelet combinations
PPIs and C diff ??
………………………………
20. How to do Polypharamcy review in older people START
ACE inhibitors and BBlockers in left ventricular dysfunction
Warfarin in Atrial fibrillation
Bisphosphonates for osteoporosis
Ensure patients in Calcium and Vitamin D adjunct therapy also
Clopidogrel post stroke (stop aspirin and dipyridamole)
………………………..
21. How to do Polypharamcy review in older people Preventative medication
Patients choice
Side effects
Drug load
Compliance
Life expectancy and co-morbidity
22. How to do Polypharamcy review in older people Preventative medication
Patients choice
Side effects
Drug load
Compliance
Life expectancy and co-morbidity
Efficiency savings
Atorvostatin change
Risedronate change
Tramadol MR change
Lormetazepam change
Ferrous sulphate change etc
23. How to do Polypharamcy review in older people Compliance
Minimal numbers medications
Minimal timings of medications
Assess drug administartion
i.e “How do you take your weekly tablet for osteoporosis ?”
24. South Angus Polypharmacy Initiative
1. Care Home annual joint medication reviews
2. Polypharmacy reviews of patients aged older than 75 years and on 12 or more medications
Integrated review with Practise Pharmacist, General Practitioner and South Angus locality Medicine for the Elderly Geriatric Consultant
25. 1. Outcomes of Annual Care Home medication reviews Data from 34 reviews
1. Number medications stopped = 46 (1.4 medictions per patient)
Started, or changed = 11
26. Outcomes of Annual Care Home medication reviews Data from 34 reviews
1. Number medications stopped = 46 (1.4 medictions per patient)
Started, or changed = 11
i) 41 % (19/46) Preventative medications no longer appropriate
Statin 8/19
7/19 Aspirin
Osteoporosis treatment 4/19
ii) 22% (10/46) Antidepressants/ Antipsychotics / Sedatives
iii) 15% (7/46) Analgesia, usually codeine based
27. Outcomes of Annual Care Home medication reviews Data from 34 reviews
1. Number medications stopped = 46 (1.4 medictions per patient)
Started, or changed = 11
i) 41 % (19/46) Preventative medications no longer appropriate
Statin 8/19
7/19 Aspirin
Osteoporosis treatment 4/19
ii) 22% (10/46) Antidepressants/ Antipsychotics / Sedatives
iii) 15% (7/46) Analgesia, usually codeine based
28. Outcomes of Annual Care Home medication reviews Data from 34 reviews
1. Number medications stopped = 46 (1.4 per patient)
Started, or changed = 11
2. Nursing time saved from drug administration = 50 minutes per day (1.5 mins per day, per patient reviewed)
29. Outcomes of Annual Care Home medication reviews Data from 34 reviews
1. Number medications stopped = 46 (1.4 per patient)
Started, or changed = 11
2. Nursing time saved from drug administration = 50 minutes per day (1.5 mins per day, per patient reviewed)
3. Cost savings: Ł 3740 per annum (Ł110 per patient per year)
30. Care Homes visited so far Joint reviews:
Roughly South Angus locality Care Home >200 patients :
Antiquarry house (SpringWest NH LES patients with Ledlie) x 2 years
Camus House (Carnoustie MC patients with Dr Webster)
Kendale, Tarriebank and Monkbarns (SpringWest patients with Dr Ledlie)
Cairnie Lodge (SpringEast LES patients with Dr Meachan and Dr Veitch)
Lunan Court and Cairnie Lodge (SpringWest patients with Dr Ledlie)
South Grange (Monifieth HC LES patients with Dr Whyte)
Cairnie Lodge (SpringEast LES patients with Dr Riaz)
Lunan court (SpringEast LES patients with Dr Raitt)
31. National and Tayside direction British Geriatric society Meet
2nd June 2011
Development of Scottish Community Geriatric Services
Recommendation that Geriatrician be involved in ALL Care Home annual Polypharmacy review.
Meeting about Future of Tayside Nursing HomeLES
9th June 2011
Recommendation that ALL Care Home annual medication reviews have Geriatrician input.
32. Angus Polypharmacy Initiative
1. Care Home annual joint medication reviews
2. Polypharmacy reviews of patients aged older than 75 years and on 12 or more medications
Integrated review with Practise Pharmacist, General Practitioner and South Angus locality Medicine for the Elderly Geriatric Consultant
33. 2. Springfield West medications reviews Patients aged over 75 years
12 or more repeat medications
96 patients
Weekly Clinics in practise, 8 patients per clinic (30 minute slots)
GP, Geriatrician and Practise Pharmacist
Patient and relative
34. 2. Springfield West medications reviews Patients aged over 75 years
12 or more repeat medications
96 patients = 1000-1500 patients per 100,000 population !!!
Weekly Clinics in practise, 8 patients per clinic (30 minute slots)
GP, Geriatrician and Practise Pharmacist
Patient and relative
35. 2. Springfield West medications reviews.Outcomes: August 2010; 96 patients aged over 75 years on 12 or more medications
May 2011; 56 patients over 75 years on 12 or more medications
42 % reduction
8 / 96 patients had no drug reductions (<10% patients)
36. 2. Springfield West medications reviews.Outcomes: Outcomes from 10 Clinics:
Patients reviewed jointly = 77 (7.7 per clinic)
Medication stopped = 181 (2.3 per patients)
Medication initiated = 33 (0.4 per patient)
Dose changes = 49 (0.6 per patient)
·
37. 2. Springfield West medications reviews.Outcomes: Outcomes from 10 Clinics:
Patients reviewed jointly = 77 (7.7 per clinic)
Medication stopped = 181 (2.3 per patients)
Medication initiated = 33 (0.4 per patient)
Dose changes = 49 (0.6 per patient)
· Co-codamol Atorvostatin
· Felodipine Quinine
· Alendronic acid Simvastatin
· Aspirin Dipyridamole
· Calcichew Omeprazole
· Amlodipine
· Lactulose
· Clopidogrel
· Contour biosensor strips
· Isosorbide mononitrate
38. 2. Springfield West medications reviewsOutcomes
Patient satisfaction survey
40 patients:
‘It was helpful to discuss my mother-in-laws attitude towards her medication’
‘It was good to be able to air my health concerns’
‘I found that an interest was being taken in my long term medication’
‘Felt the process was very worthwhile. Changing circumstances has allowed a more streamlines approach to medication’
‘I feel as if the doctors care’
‘ I feel less lethargic and more energetic’
‘I am feeling more stable with my tablets I am now on’
39. 2. Springfield West medications reviewsOutcomes
Patient satisfaction survey:
40 patients:
90 % felt appointment was helpful
79% felt they understood their medications better
26 % subjectively felt better after 6 weeks
40. 2. Springfield West medications reviewsOutcomes
Financial
Cost per clinic (including 1 session MFE) = Ł550
Prescribing savings per patient = Ł132 x 8 patients x 6-7 years = Ł6864
Savings per clinic = Ł6314
41. 2. Springfield West medications reviews
Financial
Cost per clinic (including 1 session MFE) = Ł550
Prescribing savings per patient = Ł132 x 8 patients x 6-7 years = Ł6864
Savings per clinic = Ł6314
1500 patients older than 75 years, on 12 or more medication in Angus
Potential of nearly 200 such clinics ……
42. 2. Springfield West medications reviews
Additional Benefits
Education - Staff learning from each other i.e. GPs being educated how to prescribe like their locality Geriatrician. Geriatrician thinking and understanding like GP
Trust – staff and patients spend time together and so eases relationships for future cases
Non-medication assessment – Almost every patient during consultation had additional assessment : Blood pressure, examination, MFE, Osteoporosis, diabetes, update GP registers (dementia, cancer) etc….
43. 2. Springfield West medications reviews
Additional Benefits
Education - Staff learning from each other i.e. GPs being educated how to prescribe like their locality Geriatrician. Geriatrician thinking and understanding GP
Trust – staff and patients spend time together and so eases relationships for future cases
Non-medication assessment – Almost every patient during consultation had additional assessment : Blood pressure, examination, MFE, Osteoporosis, diabetes, update GP registers (dementia, cancer) etc….
Integration – Primary and Secondary Care staff working together in-order to deliver integrated care for complex older patient in their own home
44. 2. Springfield West medications reviews
Additional Benefits
Education - Staff learning from each other i.e. GPs being educated how to prescribe like their locality Geriatrician. Geriatrician thinking and understanding GP
Trust – staff and patients spend time together and so eases relationships for future cases
Non-medication assessment – Almost every patient during consultation had additional assessment : Blood pressure, examination, MFE, Osteoporosis, diabetes, update GP registers (dementia, cancer) etc….
Integration – Primary and Secondary Care staff working together in-order to deliver integrated care for complex older patient in their own home
COMMUNITY GERIATRICS
45. Polypharmacy Pan-Tayside