Draft Program Comments to Northwest Power and Conservation Council November 18, 2008

1. Draft Program Comments to Northwest Power and Conservation Council November 18, 2008

2. http://www.cbfwa.org/sotr/

3. Plan Adaptive Management Framework Implement Evaluate 2000 Fish and Wildlife Program • Regional goals not linked to SBP goals • Recovery goals not developed • Undefined management coordination • Undefined BPA obligations Output Input • Missing F&W Priorities • Inadequate funding level • Non-explicit coordination strategy • Confusing complicated decision making process

4. Essential Adaptive Management Linkages Subbasin Objectives Strategies Limiting Factors Species Trawl and haul Reservoirs=poor reproduction Harvest = 5 kg/hectare Mid-level Bio Obj Subbasin Objectives Regional Objectives Establish measurable biologic objectives that define BPA’s mitigation obligations

5. Using Local Level Linkages Status Objectives Gap Status & Trends Limiting Factors Coor RM&E Threats Strategies Action Effectiveness Measures TargetedSolicitation

6. Anticipated Outcome: Draft Program And Public Process Final Program A+T’s Recs Implementation • Basinwide • Objectives • Strategies • M&E measures • Reporting • Basinwide Provisions • Objectives • Strategies • Exp Outcomes • M&E Plan • Systemwide measures • Subbasin • Objectives • Status • Limiting Factors • Strategies • Measures • Individual A+T’s actions (projects) • Exp Outcomes • M&E • Long Term Work Plans • Basinwide Provisions • Province Provisions • Mainstem Plan • Subbasin Provisions • Local Review • Regional Cohesion 5 Years Focused Implementation Continued work on optimization 2013 Adaptive Management review • Subbasin • Objectives • Status • Limiting Factors • Strategies • Measures Individual A&Ts measures Other’s recomend

7. Councils Draft Program: Draft Program A+T’s Recs Implementation • Basinwide • Objectives • Strategies • M&E measures • Reporting Basinwide framework Mainstem Plan M&E Guidance Reference to measures Rely on Accords 3-year rolling review process to set other priorities No budget certainty • Subbasin • Objectives • Status • Limiting Factors • Strategies • Measures 2-year Process to determine usefulness of basinwide/province level objectives General guidance for M&E with no specific measures Undefined Process to Develop MYIPs Individual A&Ts measures 3-year Process to Update SBPs

8. Proposed Process: Proposed Appendix In final Program A+T’s Amendment Recommendations Section 3 + 4 • Objectives • Status • Limiting Factors • Strategies • Measures • Strategies • Measures • Individual A+T’s actions Feb09 Council Action to Adopt Multi-year Work Plans Updated SB Mgmt Plans • Objectives • Status • Limiting Factors • Strategies • Measures • Individual A+T’s actions (projects) • Exp Outcomes • M&E including Multi-year Work Plans and a Mainstem Plan (complete and adopted by June 2009) SB Mgmt Plans Council Process to Evolve Current SB Mgmt Plans (Complete by March 2009) Jun09

9. Submit recommendations Final Prog & Findings NPCC Draft Prog Comment Hearings & Consultation Public review Process to reach final Program 2007 2008 2009 2010 Jan Jan Oct Jan Jul Jul Jul Final Prog & Findings Submit recommendations NPCC Draft Prog Comment Hearings & Consultation Public review Submit recommendations Final Prog & Findings NPCC Draft Prog Comment Hearings & Consultation Public review Vet Mgmt Plans NPCC Draft Prog Final Prog & Findings Reccomen- dations Public review