1 / 10

Environmental Ethics: Balancing Ecosystem Rights & Human Duties

Explore ethical dilemmas in business and the environment. Analyze anthropocentric vs non-anthropocentric theories, stakeholder considerations, sustainability, and laws for a balanced future.

murphyk
Download Presentation

Environmental Ethics: Balancing Ecosystem Rights & Human Duties

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Business and the Environment By: Ronald F. White, Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy College of Mount St. Joseph

  2. History • Rachel Carson, Silent Spring (1962) • 1970s Environmental Movement • 1970-Environmental Protection Agency

  3. Basic Philosophical Issues • Are ecosystems “persons” or “property” • If persons…what is rights do ecosystems have and what are our duties as humans? • If property…how do we respect public property rights? • Tragedy of the Commons • Two kinds of Theories • Anthropocentric Theories • Non-Anthropocentric Theories

  4. Anthropocentric Theories • Humans are the Center of the Moral Universe • Only humans have intrinsic value • The Natural Environment has extrinsic value • Nature as Property • Private property • Public property • Problems: • Non-Scientific status of humans in evolutionary theory • Dismal track record for anthropocentric theories • Long-term v. Short-term Interests • Problem of Future Generations • Private Property v. Public Property • Tragedy of the Commons

  5. Problem of Future Generations • Root of the Problem: Moral obligations to the least advantaged. (anthropocentric) • Do present generations have duties toward future generations? • If so, what are those duties? • How far into the future do these duties extend? 1 generation or 100 generations? • What happens when those duties conflict with our duties toward the present generation, especially the least advantaged present?

  6. Non-Anthropocentric Theories • Humans are not the Center of the Moral Universe • Ecosystems have Intrinsic Value • Eastern Religions • Darwinism • Problems: • Weak Human Incentive to preserve the environment • Tendency to sacrifice poor powerless humans in the present • Weak cultural support

  7. Stockholder Theory • Stockholder Theory (Market Distribution) • “When in Rome do as the Romans do.” • Act on legality not morality • Problems: • Corrupt and/or weak governments • Weak monitoring and enforcement of environmental laws, especially in developing countries

  8. Stakeholder Theory • Stakeholder Theory (Social Distribution) • “When in Rome do what is right.” • Public Property-Private Property • Governmental Protection of the Environment • Problem of Future Generations • Tragedy of the Commons

  9. Tragedy of the Commons • “When everyone owns it nobody owns it?” • Environmental Impact • Pollution • Resource Depletion • Extinction • Solutions • Pass Environmental Protection Laws • Problem: Monitoring and Enforcement at a Global Level • Develop Global Environmental Protection Institutions • Problems: Ineffective Global Institutions, Non-Compliance by Powerful Interests • Teach humans to Respect Public Property • Problem: Weak Public Schools (Tragedy of Commons) • Expand private ownership of the environment • Problem: Imprudent Ownership • Owners Sacrifice Long-Term Sustainability for Short-Term Gain • Ownership of Common Air and Waterways. (Flow)

  10. Issues • Pollution • Air Pollution: Global Warming • Water Pollution: • Corporations • Governments • Resource Depletion • Coal • Oil • Plants and Animals • Water

More Related