350 likes | 500 Views
Know Thyself?. Lesson 3: What is the Nature of Man?. Whether or not the proper study of mankind is man, it is the only study in which the knower and the known are one, in which the object of science is the nature of the scientist!. Should We????. cogito ergo sum.
E N D
Know Thyself? Lesson 3: What is the Nature of Man?
Whether or not the proper study of mankind is man, it is the only study in which the knower and the known are one, in which the object of science is the nature of the scientist! Should We????
Is man a rational animal, and does that definition imply that only man has reason, and not animals in general? Does man have freewill, and is he alone in that capacity? Does man differ from animals is essence or in kind from the rest of creation, or does man differ in degree in the properties from animals? What is Man’s nature?
Man is simply a better animal. Charles Darwin
Man is obviously different Reasonable Governs the rest of nature Self-knowing “Magnanimous to correspond to Heaven” John Milton
Language which describes abstract ideas makes man unique Evil Brutish Short-lived Tom Hobbes
Man can think of ideas, but no freewill • Basically • Good • Once educated John Locke
Man is simply an animal that can make free choices from alternatives present Rousseau
Man is the only animal that can remain on friendly terms with the victims he intends to eat until he eats them. • Samuel Butler Lunch!!
It is even harder for the average ape to believe that he has descended from apes. • H.L. Mencken Apes???
Man is different because he is both mind and body, while animals are merely body, both must be nurtured Descartes
What is man, when you come to think upon him, but a minutely set, ingenious machine for turning, with infinite artfulness, the red wine of Shiraz into urine? • Isak Dinesen Usefulness of Man
Man is basically good, rational, and capable of satisfying his own dissatisfaction with available resources, but not perfect Ludwig von Mises
All things are classifiable (Linnaeus) • All higher classes have characteristics of the lower • All things have two traits: accidental and essential • Accidental: sex, space, weight, race, hair, color • Essential: all things have “nature” which make them unique from other things Classification of Man
All physical things take up space and have weight All living things eat, grow and reproduce Animals think, learn, have intelligence Classification of Man
Things Ideas Physical Things Living Non-living Minerals Animals Plants Elements Composite Man
Political Animal Rational Freewill (Moral virtue) Governs nature (Video) Knows ego Both Mind and Body Thinks ideas and abstracts MAN
Capacity for Virtue Desires to be virtuous Desires knowledge Nearly always acts with an end in view Plays philosophical games MAN
Productive • Maker of Beauty • Practical • Doer of Good • Speculative • Thinker of Truth Real humans have three dimensions
Act with a purpose • Act towards our desires • Wanting only what is needed (which is always good) • Wanting only what is good • Wants v Needs • There is only one need: to live fully • Wants are individual desires in different people to satisfy the desire of happiness Happiness: the ultimate good, end in life: a good life well-lived
Goods v “The Good” Goods are the things that lead to The Good Some goods seem essential Others not, yet still wanted (That’s Okay) Goods vs. Good
Life • being (Eat, grow, produce, reproduce) • interacting (Politically, socially, economically) • learning How to pursue: the only human purpose
Changing or adapting • Material (out of which) • Efficient (by which) • Formal (into which) • Final (for the sake of which) • Leading a purposeful life How to pursue: the only human purpose
Is there a difference? • Yet plants and animals do all those • The Good life, only human • Good habits and goods morals • The examined life
#1: Real goods (Can have too much, or led astray by them) • Health, vitality, vigor, pleasure • Food, drink, clothing, shelter, sleep, leisure • Knowledge (skills, know-how, facts) • Association, love • Pleasure of art • Making, acquiring knowledge • Honor (if deserved) and self-esteem Four tools needed
#2: Moral Virtue: the Skill of making right choices, moderation • Vice is making bad choices • Can never have too much virtue • Only one not actually external to a person • Can’t be given or taken away, but can be practiced, or modeled Four tools
Temperance: Seeking only the amount of real goods needed • Resist the lure of pleasure • Know limit of apparent goods • Courage: Accepting the pain involved in doing what we ought to do for a good life • Cowardice is avoiding the “good” pain • Justice: Assisting in the pursuit of others’ happiness Three parts to Virtue
So then, What is Morality? • Honesty • Humility • Responsibility • Self-discipline • Courage • Self-reliance • Long-term Thinking
#3: Liberty • Government resting on Justice, serving the common good Four tools
#4: Good Luck!!???!! Four tools
The Nature of Man and Society To Play the Video
The following are a few more of my beliefs: I believe that El Niño is an international conspiracy perpetrated by evil roofing contractors. I believe it's high time The Beatles came clean on that whole "Paul is dead" thing. I believe that anyone who can read and speak clearly can be a network news anchorperson -- but not necessarily a weatherman. I believe that if I rid myself of insatiable cravings, lusts, paranoia, deep-seated anger and ill-will towards others, I'll be a much better person. I believe that TV is the cause of all the violence and immorality in our society -- ha! just kidding. I believe there's no business like show business, although if you're over-paid for feeding a big, scary monster, then that might be sort of like it. That's all for now, gottago. Nope, also, that lasagna is life’s support.