820 likes | 2.53k Views
Exercise-Induced Syncope: Diagnosis and Management. Francis G. O’Connor, MD, FACSM Primary Care Sports Medicine. Objectives. Review the epidemiology of sudden death and exercise-induced syncope in athletes Discuss the pathophysiology and differential diagnosis of exertional collapse
E N D
Exercise-Induced Syncope:Diagnosis and Management Francis G. O’Connor, MD, FACSM Primary Care Sports Medicine
Objectives • Review the epidemiology of sudden death and exercise-induced syncope in athletes • Discuss the pathophysiology and differential diagnosis of exertional collapse • Discuss the evaluation and management of the athlete with exercise-associated collapse
Definitions • Syncope: a sudden and temporary loss of consciousness, in the absence of head trauma, that is associated with a loss of postural tone with spontaneous recovery not requiring electrical or chemical cardioversion • Exercise-Induced Syncope • Exercise-Associated Collapse
Exercise-Induced Syncope • Syncopal episode during exercise or in the immediate post-exertional period; the athlete normally recovers quickly
Exercise-Associated Collapse • Athlete is unable to stand or walk unaided as a result of lightheadedness, faintness, dizziness, or syncope.
Nontraumatic Sports Death in High School and College Athletes VanCamp SP, et al: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 1996. Vol 27(5):641-7.
estimated death rates in male athletes were fivefold higher than in female athletes (7.5 vs. 1.33) • estimated death rates were twofold higher in male college athletes than in male high school athletes • noncardiac causes of death accounted for 22% of the cases • male football and basketball accounted for the majority of deaths (104/160)
Risk for Sudden Cardiac Death Associated with Marathon Running Maron BJ,et al:Journal of the American College of Cardiology 1996;28:428-431.
215,413 completed the Marine Corps and the Twin Cities Marathon • four exercise-related sudden deaths occurred; three during the race, one right after completion • risk for sudden death with marathon running: 1:50,000; this was 1/100 the risk of overall living for 1 year
Syncope in Children and Adolescents Driscoll DJ, et al: Journal of the American college of Cardiology 1997;29:1039-45.
population-based review of syncope in children and adolescents • 194 cases studied; 3% presented with exertional syncope, with one subsequent sudden death • conclusions: • electrocardiography warranted in all patients with syncope • detailed evaluation should be considered for patients with syncope with exercise, a family history of syncope, premature sudden death or arrhythmias
Screening for Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy in Young Athletes Corrado D, et al: The New England Journal of Medicine 1998;339:364-9.
prospective study of sudden death events among athletes and nonathletes • the incidence of sudden death from HCM was decreased in the athletes who had PPE screens • most common cause of sudden death in athletes was arrhythmogenic right ventricular dysplasia • 7 of the 28 athletes who died had complained of syncope; none of the victims complained about exertional chest pain
Exertional Sudden Death in Soldiers Drory Y et al: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 1991. Vol 23(2) 147-151.
All exercise-related sudden unexpected deaths of soldiers 18-29 in the IDF during 1974-1986 were reviewed • twenty male soldiers died suddenly within 24hr of strenuous exercise • 70% of the victims had prodromal symptoms within one month of their demise with syncope being the most common complaint (40%) • syncope was associated with HCM, myocarditis, intracranial hemorrhage, and heat stroke
Clinical and Biochemical Characteristics of Collapsed Ultramarathon Runners Holtzhausen LM, Noakes TD et al: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 1994. Vol 26(9):1095-1101.
56 km race; 65 controls; 46 runners with exertional collapse • most cases of EAC occurred at the finish line (85%); correlation with cutoff for medals and race closure • 15 % collapsing during the event had readily identifiable medical diagnoses: asthma; angina; hypoglycemia; gastroenteritis • states of dehydration, plasma renin and vasopressin concentrations were comparable in controls and EAC victims
Multifactorial • Cardiovascular changes with exercise • “Second Heart” • Orthostatic intolerance in Athletes
Cardiovascular Regulation with Exercise • aerobic exercise results in dramatic shifts in blood distribution • cardiac ouput increases to accommodate an increase in peripheral oxygen demand • there is a preferential redistribution of blood flow to the working muscles and away from non-exercising areas
The “Second Heart” • During exercise the skeletal muscle functions as a “second heart” as the pumping action of skeletal muscle maintains venous return • During muscle contraction, the veins are emptied and the driving pressure back to the heart is substantially increased • If the the pumping action of skeletal muscle is lost despite a persistent vasodilation, syncope may ensue
Orthostatic Intolerance in Athletes • Endurance trained athletes have a reduced capacity to compensate for any acute hypotensive stress • Luft et al report that the incidence of syncope during lower body negative pressure is greater in trained than in untrained controls • Smith et al postulate training induced alterations in the autonomic nervous system with attenuated sympathetic activity to hypotensive stress in athletes
The Prevalence and Significance of Post-Exercise Hypotension in Ultramarathon Runners Holtzhausen LM, Noakes TD, et al: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 1995;27(12):1595-1601.
Study involving 31/240 runners in an 80k ultramarathon (mean age 38.9 years) • Pre- and Post-race weights, supine and erect blood pressures, and blood samples: • osmolality • chemistries • glucose
Average weight loss was 3.5 kg (4.6%) • Large increase in supine-erect blood pressure differences after the race • 81% of runners demonstrated a posture-related difference in systolic blood pressure in excess of 20mmHg • No significant correlation was found with weight loss, or plasma volume with systolic blood pressure differences
Systolic and diastolic BP were decreased after exercise, but to a much greater extent in the erect versus supine position • Level of dehydration was unrelated to the degree of postural hypotension • EAC should initially be treated with pelvic and lower limb elevation, not IV rehydration
Exercise Associated Collapse • Postulated Mechanism for EAC • redistribution of blood flow to working muscle and skin • reliance of skeletal muscle pump to maintain atrial filling pressure • sudden cessation of exercise of exercise promotes peripheral pooling
Exercise Associated Collapse • Postulated Mechanism for EAC • contractions of empty ventricle stimulate mecchanoreceptors • afferent vagal C-fibers transmit these signals to the CNS with efferent reflexes result in vasodilatation and bradycardia with syncope
Exercise Associated Collapse • In summary, syncope after exercise is multifactorial but can usually be explained by predictable hemodynamic responses: • heat stress • extraordinary effort • standing quietly in an upright position
Differential Diagnosis of Syncope Mean Arterial Pressure Cerebral Metabolism • Heart Rate • Stroke Volume • Peripheral Resistance • Tissue Oxygen • Substrate Delivery
Differential Diagnosis • Cerebral Metabolism • seizure • hypocapnia • hypoxia • hypoglycemia • hyperthermia
Differential Diagnosis • Heart Rate too Slow • bradyarrhythmia • cardioinhibitory reflex (neurocardiogenic) • conduction abnormality
Differential Diagnosis • Heart Rate too Fast • supraventricular • pre-excitation • atrial fibrillation • ventricular • ventricular tachycardia • ventricular fibrillation
Differential Diagnosis • LVEDV too Low • pulmonary hypertension • pulmonic stenosis • dehydration • hemorrhage
Differential Diagnosis • LVESV too High • aortic stenosis • hypertrophic cardiomyopathy • ischemia
Differential Diagnosis • TPR too Low • vasodepressor reflex • anaphylaxis • functional sympatholysis
Evaluation and Management of the Athlete with a History of Exertional Syncope
Assessment • History and Physical Examination • Electrocardiogram • Special Tests: • Echocardiography • Exercise Stress Testing • Putting it All Together
History • “True syncope” versus “exercise associated collapse” • During versus immediately after exercise • Prodromal symptoms • Post-event state • Medications • High risk behaviors • Family history
Physical Examination • Vital signs supine and upright (at least 5 minutes standing) • BP in arms/legs • Body habitus • Cardiac murmurs at rest and during Valsalva or rise from squatting position
Electrocardiogram • QTc • Pre-excitation • ST-T wave abnormalities • Ischemic changes • T wave inversion v1 -v3 • Ectopy, inparticular with LBBB
Echocardiogram • LV and RV size and function • Valve structure • Left main coronary ostial position • Aortic annulus size • Pulmonary systolic pressure
Exercise Stress Test • Designed to reproduce conditions which provoked the event e.g. • start-stop • prolonged high intensity • Appropriate QT shortening