1 / 30

Mass Media Effects: The Scientific Approach

Mass Media Effects: The Scientific Approach. COM 226, Summer 2011 PPT #1 Includes chapters 2-3 of DeFleur textbook. First, some terminology: What do we mean by MASS MEDIA?. What is MASS? What is a MEDIUM?. What do we mean by MASS MEDIA?. What is MASS?

noonane
Download Presentation

Mass Media Effects: The Scientific Approach

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Mass Media Effects: The Scientific Approach COM 226, Summer 2011 PPT #1 Includes chapters 2-3 of DeFleur textbook

  2. First, some terminology:What do we mean by MASS MEDIA? • What is MASS? • What is a MEDIUM?

  3. What do we mean by MASS MEDIA? • What is MASS? • Large, undifferentiated audience? • The large, general group is often defined by a certain demographic or other common characteristic(s) • A relatively recent phenomenon in history

  4. What do we mean by MASS MEDIA? • What is MASS? • Large, undifferentiated audience? • The large, general group is often defined by a certain demographic or other common characteristic(s) • A relatively recent phenomenon in history • What is a MEDIUM? • Device interposed between source and receiver?

  5. What do we mean by MASS MEDIA? • What is MASS? • Large, undifferentiated audience? • The large, general group is often defined by a certain demographic or other common characteristic(s) • A relatively recent phenomenon in history • What is a MEDIUM? • Device interposed between source and receiver? • HOW have these notions necessarily changed in recent years?

  6. The Basic Communication Process

  7. Traditional Mass Communication Model: NBC A single professional source  A large, undifferentiated audience (set of receivers)

  8. Traditional Interpersonal Communication Model: Individual non-professional sources  Individual, specified receivers, with immediate feedback

  9. UGC (User Generated Content)Mass Media Model: Individual non-professional acts as source  A large, undifferentiated audience

  10. UGC (User Generated Content)Mass Media Model: Individual non-professional acts as source  A large, undifferentiated audience. . . WITH FEEDBACK

  11. UGC (User Generated Content)Mass Media Model: Individual non-professional acts as source  A large, undifferentiated audience. . . WITH FEEDBACK. . . AND COMMUNICATION AMONG AUDIENCE MEMBERS

  12. Mass and Interpersonal Communication • What is the dividing line? • DISCUSS

  13. Basic Issues of Philosophy (textbook) • Being: The existence of reality • Knowing: Human understanding of reality • Doing: Responding to reality

  14. Obtaining Valid Knowledge (textbook) • Sensory Experience as a strategy • Plato’s distrust of this—man in the cave • Metaphysical Reasoning as a strategy • Xeno’s paradox of Achilles and the tortoise • Modern Philosophy of Science as a strategy • Francis Bacon & Inductive Strategy • Rene Descartes & Deductive Strategy

  15. Epistemologies:Four ways of knowing • 1) Personal experience—good, but… • …some things that are true for oneself may not be true for others. • …may not be able to detect effects. • 2) Intuition—usually works, but… • …sometimes reasoning may be faulty.

  16. Epistemologies:Four ways of knowing • 3) Authority—can be important, but… • …authorities may be WRONG—hard to separate from biases, preconceptions, etc. • 4) Science—relies on systematic observation (vs. casual observation). • As a way of knowing, science works. • Best defined by its characteristics.

  17. Characteristics of Science • 1. Objectivity—science strives to be free from biases and preconceptions. • 2. Empirical—science is based on observation. • 3. Probabilistic—based on regularities that have exceptions; looks for general patterns (vs. individual case studies). • 4. Systematic and cumulative—research builds on other research, thereby building knowledge.

  18. Characteristics of Science • 5. Public—Methods and results must be fully disclosed and shared. • 6. Limited—cannot answer certain types of questions—but it can help answer them.

  19. Types of questions science can answer: • 1) How much violence is there on TV? • 2) Do children watch violent TV shows? • 3) Does media violence cause children to become desensitized to violence in real life?

  20. Types of questions science is NOT equipped to answer • 1) Given that TV violence causes kids to behave aggressively, what should be done about it? • 2) Should media do something more than merely distribute whatever content will earn them the greatest profits in the shortest time? • 3) Should media become more involved in educating children?

  21. Goals of Science • 1. Describe empirical regularities and relationships. • 2. Predict future outcomes. • 3. Explain regularities and relationships. • 4. Control future outcomes.

  22. Theory • Textbook: A theory is “a description of how something works.” • Others: “There is nothing so practical as a good theory.” • DISCUSS

  23. Theory • 1) Consists of a set of related statements • 2) These statements specify the relationships among concepts • 3) These concepts must have observable counterparts (i.e., be measurable) • 4) The theory will yield hypotheses (i.e., predictive statements of how variables relate) testable through observation.

  24. Theory—Let’s apply Gerbner’s Cultivation Theory(from VIDEO—The Mean World Syndrome) • 1) Consists of a set of related statements • ???? • 2) These statements specify the relationships among concepts • ????

  25. Theory—Let’s apply Gerbner’s Cultivation Theory(from VIDEO—The Mean World Syndrome) • 3) These concepts must have observable counterparts (i.e., be measurable) • ???? • 4) The theory will yield hypotheses (i.e., predictive statements of how variables relate) testable through observation • ?????

  26. Empirical Methods for Testing Hypotheses Derived from Theory Experiment: At least one IV (independent variable) is manipulated; unit of data collection is often (but not always) in a controlled (e.g., laboratory) setting (if not, it may be called a field experiment)

  27. Empirical Methods for Testing Hypotheses Derived from Theory Experiment: At least one IV (independent variable) is manipulated; unit of data collection is often (but not always) in a controlled (e.g., laboratory) setting (if not, it may be called a field experiment) Survey: Variables are measured as they “naturally” occur; unit of data collection is typically situated in its (his/her) natural environment; no variables are manipulated

  28. Empirical Methods for Testing Hypotheses Derived from Theory Content Analysis: Really, a type of Survey in which the units to be studied are messages, not people (Neuendorf, 2002: “a summarizing, quantitative analysis of messages that relies on the scientific method (including attention to objectivity/intersubjectivity, a priori design, reliability, validity, generalizability, replicability, and hypothesis testing)”)

  29. Empirical Methods for Testing Hypotheses Derived from Theory Content Analysis: Really, a type of Survey in which the units to be studied are messages, not people (Neuendorf, 2002: “a summarizing, quantitative analysis of messages that relies on the scientific method (including attention to objectivity/intersubjectivity, a priori design, reliability, validity, generalizability, replicability, and hypothesis testing)”) Qualitative Methods: Includes such variants as ethnography, narratology, focus groups, and participant observation; the researcher, and their knowledge and skills, are an integral part of the measurement process

  30. Typical Methods Used for Examining Parts of the Communication Model

More Related