1 / 40

Cloudy with a Chance of Enrollment: The effects of weather on student enrollment behavior

Kate Ralston Darin Wohlgemuth Daryl Herzmann Corey Hagruth Iowa State University November 12, 2013 AACRAO - SEM Chicago, IL. Cloudy with a Chance of Enrollment: The effects of weather on student enrollment behavior. What is Weather?.

oleg
Download Presentation

Cloudy with a Chance of Enrollment: The effects of weather on student enrollment behavior

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Kate Ralston Darin Wohlgemuth Daryl Herzmann Corey Hagruth Iowa State University November 12, 2013 AACRAO - SEM Chicago, IL Cloudy with a Chance of Enrollment: The effects of weather on student enrollment behavior

  2. What is Weather? The state of the atmosphere at a  given moment in time at a given location.

  3. What is Weather? Measures include the amount of • sunshine • clouds • rainfall • humidity • wind • temperature fluctuating on a daily basis.

  4. Weather vs. Climate Not the same as climate may include a combination of the same measures considers them in 30-year increments Climate Normals

  5. Why do we care?  Weather affects an array of human behaviors and decisions, often – without us knowing.

  6. Effects of weather on behavior • Hirshleifer, D. and Shumway, T. (2003): Sunny days  higher stock returns • Rind, B. (1996): Cloudy skies  less tips to servers • Anderson, C. (1989): Hotter weather  higher levels of aggression

  7. Weather in Higher Ed? • Baxter (2009): Rainy days  Less med school applicants accepted • Simonsohn (2007, 2009): Cloudy skies  Academic rigor of applicants matters more than extra-curricular achievements to admissions and applicants

  8. Then, the question is… Does weather during campus visit affect a student’s probability of enrollment?

  9. Other questions to consider? Does any particular weather element matter more? • What about element combinations? • Seasons? • Gender? • Choice of major college?

  10. Getting Data Enrollment: individual level, students Meteorology: - daily 8-hour average, town - climatology, regional Joint File: Visits, enrollment, high-school status, daily weather variables, climate averages

  11. Preparing the data Office of Admissions:  Daily visit data, 5 years  High school status – Senior/Junior  Application and admission status  Enrollment information from census  Other relevant information

  12. Preparing the data Iowa State Meteorology Department:  Daily readings from Ames  Hourly readings, averaged across regular business hours  Daily climate normal for IA  Daily climate normal, regional

  13. Preparing the data Identifying influential weather variables: • Temperature: Above/Below average • Wind-chill: Yes/No • Heat Index: Yes/No • Snow: Yes/No • Clouds: Yes/No • Rain: Yes/No What else matters?

  14. Perception of Weather Combination of objective climate normals and subjective comfort.

  15. What is Good Weather? How do you define and measure good weather?

  16. Creating a Weather Index • Can’t have wind chill and heat index • Can’t have snow and rain Index range: 0 to 4, the higher the worse Bad weather indicator: Weather index >2

  17. Recognizing seasons Cold season: November – March Warm season: June-August Demi-season: April/May, September/October Create seasons variables: Dummy codes: cold, warm, demi = 0/1 Effect codes: cold, warm, demi = -1/1 Effect switch: cold -1, warm 1, demi 0

  18. Winter vs. Summer

  19. Understanding climate normals • Understanding the norm helps adjusting expectations benchmarking weather is important for informing initial campus visit strategies

  20. Iowa weather is… • Best in early spring and fall • Sunniest: September-October • Best temperature: March/April • Extreme heat: ~ 2 months a year • Extreme cold: ~ 2 months a year • Rain: ~30% of the year

  21. Benchmarking the weather

  22. Benchmarking the elements

  23. Bad weather visits

  24. So…? Goal – satisfactory experience: Planning more visits during more favorable weather times Allocating necessary staff time and resources Creating plan B for adverse conditions

  25. Does weather truly matter? Going beyond frequencies:  correlation  t-test/chi-square  multiple regression

  26. Correlations Dichotomous variables can be correlated using Pearson’s phi or mean square contingency coefficient

  27. T-Test vs. χ2 T-Test χ2

  28. Findings

  29. Geography matters

  30. Findings

  31. More? Sensitive to elements, tend to enroll less during “element” days

  32. Regressions: Weather only

  33. Regressions: Weather/ HS Status

  34. Weather, demographic, academic

  35. Expectations matter: IA case

  36. Implications • Elements do make a difference • Not all differences are intuitive • Not all elements impact enrollment • Care matters (windchill findings) • So does timing (visiting as senior vs. junior)

  37. Comments & Questions Contact Information kroha@iastate.edu darinw@iastate.edu Thank you for attending this morning!

More Related