50 likes | 168 Views
CEER Workshop J VERSEILLE Director System Development 13th February 2007. Spain France Interconnection. Expected Benefits of the Interconnection for the French system. Increased security of supply main factor of risk in France :
E N D
CEER Workshop J VERSEILLE Director System Development 13th February 2007 Spain France Interconnection
Expected Benefits of the Interconnection for the French system • Increased security of supply • main factor of risk in France : • cold periods in Winter (+ 1800 MW/°C) due to anticyclonic conditions • often affect at the same time the Northern part of Europe • Spain can experience milder conditions at this time Support from the spanish system to the french system expected in such situations (ex : winter 2005) • Market opportunities • High sensitivity of Spanish system to climatic conditions • Large variations of hydro generation on a yearly or seasonal basis • Large variations of wind generation on a weekly daily basis • High level of consumption in Summer in Spain Market opportunities for increased imports /exports
Administrative procedures in France • Project endorsed by the Ministry • Public debate (expression of public opinion on the project) 18 – 24 Months • Determination of general route 30 – 42 months • Prior consultation • identifying study area • progressively define less impact area • produce the impact study • Declaration of public interest (DUP) • Consultation of mayors and departments • Public inquiry => Obtaining DUP • Determining the precise line route in details 12 – 18 months • Approval of technical drawing • Planning permission • Amicable agreements and easements • Construction work 12 – 24 Months
France – Spain Interconnection : present situation • Public debate held in march – june 2003 • local opposition against the proposed route • Ministry asked to propose new options • Three main options to cross the border prepared by RTE / REE • compromise to be found between • environmental aspects • efficiency for the power system • local acceptance No decision taken yet
Origin of the difficulties • History of the project : a previous project in another area stopped in 1996… • Crossing the border needs a high level political agreement • Agreement between national and regional/local authorities is a prerequisite • Acceptable compromises on one side of the border can be contradictory with the objectives of the other party • At the local level no clear and obvious advantages • Rejection of the usefulness of the line • Ideologic opposition • Landscape preservation • Nimby or Banana… • Interconnection : two countries, twice as many stakeholders with various objectives…