120 likes | 196 Views
Genetically modified foods by Tim Harding B.Sc. 1. What are they? 2. Are they safe to eat? 3. Are public concerns rational?. Brief history of DNA research. 1850s: natural selection and sexual selection (Darwin) 1860s-90s: basic rules of genetics (Mendel)
E N D
Genetically modified foodsby Tim Harding B.Sc. 1. What are they? 2. Are they safe to eat? 3. Are public concerns rational?
Brief history of DNA research • 1850s: natural selection and sexual selection (Darwin) • 1860s-90s: basic rules of genetics (Mendel) • 1910-13: genes arranged linearly on the chromosome (Morgan and Sturtevant) • 1944: DNA identified as gene carrier • 1953: discovery of the chemical structure of DNA (Watson and Crick)
Genetic modification • evolution: natural selection and sexual selection • human intervention: artificial selection
Artificial selection • plant and animal breeding (long-term) • mutagenesis (hit or miss) • genetic engineering (short-term) End result is the same = modification of genetic code
All DNA is safe to eat • DNA is DNA – no ‘natural’ vs ‘artificial’ DNA • biochemically and nutritionally the same • only difference is in the genetic code i.e. sequence of the bases G, C, T and A.
Current food regulations in Australia • Australia has one of the most rigorous food safety testing regimes in the world • GE foods are tested even more rigorously than non‐GE foods • principle of ‘substantial equivalence’ • foods certified as organic or biodynamic should not contain any GE ingredients (according to voluntary organic food industry guidelines)
GM foods • all farmed foods • all meats except for wild game and kangaroo • farmed fish e.g. salmon • all plant foods except bush tucker • all cultivated mushrooms
GE foods • cisgenesis (within the same species) or • transgenesis (from different species) • early 1990s: transgenic plant products (soybean, corn, canola, and cotton seed oil) • no GE whole foods available in Australia – why?
Objections to GE foods • the appeal to nature fallacy • alleged but unproven safety issues • ideological concerns • ecological concerns
Benefits of GE foods • sturdy plants able to withstand weather extremes • better quality food crops • higher nutritional yields in crops • inexpensive and nutritious food • foods with a greater shelf life • food with medicinal (nutraceutical) benefits • crops resistant to disease and insects • produce that requires less chemical application