90 likes | 260 Views
Federal Limitations on Military Consumer Credit Hilary B. Miller, Esq. Jeremy T. Rosenblum, Esq. 2006 Defense Appropriations Bill Restricts Military Credit Terms. Who is burdened:
E N D
Federal Limitations on Military Consumer CreditHilary B. Miller, Esq.Jeremy T. Rosenblum, Esq.
2006 Defense Appropriations Bill Restricts Military Credit Terms • Who is burdened: • “Creditor”: a person [as defined in regulations to be promulgated by the SecDef] who extends “consumer credit [defined to exclude mortgages and purchase-money loans for cars and personal property]” to: • Who is protected: • “A covered member [defined as “active duty”] of the armed forces or a dependent of such member [defined as spouse, child or person for whom > ½ support]” • Effective 10/1/07 unless SecDef regs provide for earlier effective date
Limitations on Interest • A “creditor” cannot impose “an annual percentage rate of interest” > 36%. • ≠ “APR” for TILA purposes • Includes all charges, including charges permitted to be excluded for TILA (e.g., credit life insurance, recording fees, service charges, “any other charge”)
Principal Prohibited Acts • Rollovers, renewals, refinances, consolidations or refinances of loans from same creditor • Mandatory arbitration • Waivers of “legal recourse” • Check or ACH repayment; vehicle title as security for loan • Prepayment prohibitions/penalties
Required Disclosures • Statement of “APR of interest” • Disclosures required under TILA • (Note: Not the same!) • “Clear description of the payment obligations” • “Shall” be presented in accordance with TILA, but cannot be
Preemptive Effect • Preempts any inconsistent state or federal law, except does not preempt any law providing greater protection • Prevents states from authorizing or condoning unpermitted terms
SecDef Regulations SecDef to prescribe by regulation: • Disclosures required • Method for calculating “APR of interest” • Maximum allowable fees for each type of credit • Definition of “creditor” and “consumer credit” • Any other limitations the SecDef deems appropriate • May provide for earlier effective date than 10/1/07
Penalties • Violation is a misdemeanor — fine and not more than one year in prison • Entire contract containing prohibited term (not merely prohibited term) is void ab initio
Open Questions • Who, exactly, is caught in this web? What classes of “creditors” and forms of “consumer credit” will be excluded from the definitions (banks? credit unions? overdraft protection?) • May a creditor rely on a loan applicant’s representation that he is not a “covered member” or dependent? • What additional disclosures (may differ from TILA), limitations (may differ from statute), etc. will SecDef prescribe by regulation? • Are class-action waivers prohibited? • Will mainstream creditors continue to lend to military borrowers at all?