390 likes | 524 Views
Space Projects. Risk Management is the Key to Success Presented to the. AIMS. To create an awareness of some of the techniques that can be employed to complete a successful Project Risk Analysis. Today’s Agenda. Background to the Problem A Process to address the Problem
E N D
Space Projects Risk Management is the Key to Success Presented to the 1 UNCLASSIFIED
AIMS To create an awareness of some of the techniques that can be employed to complete a successful Project Risk Analysis 2 UNCLASSIFIED
Today’s Agenda • Background to the Problem • A Process to address the Problem • An Example of a Project Risk Network • Summary and Questions 3 UNCLASSIFIED
PROJECT SUCCESS = on time, on cost, to spec 4 UNCLASSIFIED
BACKGROUND • NAO audits MoD’s Major Projects • Yearly monitor of Costs and Timescales • Benefits of SMART Acquisition • Moving towards a more informed forecast 5 UNCLASSIFIED
Defence Journal of the DPA - 2003 6 UNCLASSIFIED
Initial Process Risk Maturity Assessment • WHAT IS A RISK MATURITY ASSESSMENT? • to independently assess maturity of the risk management process • to produce prioritised action plans for improvement 7 UNCLASSIFIED
8 UNCLASSIFIED
MoD’s Risk Management Process 9 UNCLASSIFIED
Identify • Use prompts, list and characterise elements • Include risk source, event consequences & context of the risk • Opportunities may also be revealed • Think out of the box • Engage all stakeholders - IMPORTANT 10 UNCLASSIFIED
Analyse 11 UNCLASSIFIED
Analyse • Two stage assessment process • Qualitative against agreed criteria • Probability of risk occurring • Impact on time, cost and performance • Display as a PIG • Ownership of risk • Where and when it could occur • Quantitative 12 UNCLASSIFIED
Quantitative stage • Define the measure of PROBABILITY e.g. • High >50%, Medium 20%- 50%, Low <20% • Define IMPACT on COST e.g. • High >30%, Medium 10 - 30%, Low <10% or • High >£250k, Medium £50k- £250k, Low <£50K • Define IMPACT on TIME e.g. • High >30%, Medium 10 - 30%, Low <10% or • High >6 months, Med 3m - 6 m, Low <3m 13 UNCLASSIFIED
Risk Register Serial No. Sample summary Sheet Risk Title Activities Affected Probability Impact Perf. Cost Sched. Risk Reduction Ownership Risk Questionnaire Level 1 14 UNCLASSIFIED
Plan 15 UNCLASSIFIED
Plan • Classify • Tolerate - No action but reassess • Reject - i.e. not valid at this stage • Handle - require action • Risk Handling • Mitigation Strategies - risk reduction • Fallback Plans - an alternative 16 UNCLASSIFIED
Risk Handling • Mitigation Strategies • Terminate • Treat • Transfer • Tolerate • Fallback or Contingency Plans • an alternative taken up if a risk occurs • trigger point set to allow sufficient time to be effective 17 UNCLASSIFIED
Manage 18 UNCLASSIFIED
Proactive/Reactive • Implement • by the Risk Manager, Stakeholders, using the Risk Plan • Monitor • Maintain Risk Records/Register, easy access • Review • Use results of Qualitative/Quantitative analysis • Report • Relevant & Concise analysed data 19 UNCLASSIFIED
Managing a Project Why Plan? What do we need to know about the schedule? • Duration of the project • Milestones • Chances of achieving target? • By how much? • What part of project needs special attention? 20 UNCLASSIFIED
Point Estimates Conventional single point estimate 0 95 Time 21 UNCLASSIFIED
May Jun Jul Aug Sep Element Description • Project Total • Design • Design Approval • Purchase L/ L Items • Produce Drags • Purchase Raw Matls • Make Piece parts • Purchase B/O Items • Purchase Sub-Con • Inspect Sub-Con • Prepare Tech Docs • Typeset, print & bind • Assemble • Test • Pack & Despatch Sample Network Dur 95 22 5 40 20 25 18 20 20 10 5 35 10 5 3 22 UNCLASSIFIED
Could be as low as this Could be as high as this Reality ! 0 90 95 105 Time 23 UNCLASSIFIED
Time 20 30 50 Risks Time 20 35 65 Cycling to Work Uncertainty: Most likely - 30 mins Minimum - 20 mins Maximum - 50 mins Risks: Puncture? 3PE & Prob Accident? 3PE & Prob 24 UNCLASSIFIED
Combining Risk with Uncertainty • Achieved via Monte Carlo Simulation • Works by simulating the project many times using the estimated distributions and plotting the outcomes • Can be used for time or cost • Achieved using a Computer Based Tool such as Predict, @Risk, Crystal Ball, ARM 25 UNCLASSIFIED
Risk Register 3 Point Estimates Cost 3 Point Estimates Schedule 3 Point Estimates * Modelling Schedule 10%-50%-90% Confidence levels Cost 10%-50%-90% Confidence levels The Estimate Process 26 UNCLASSIFIED
3 Point Estimates 27 UNCLASSIFIED
Roll the dice !! 28 UNCLASSIFIED
Monte Carlo Simulation Combined distribution = 29 UNCLASSIFIED
Time Probability of outcomes 100 80 60 42% Probability % 40 20 95 Days 0 85 90 95 100 Days 30 UNCLASSIFIED
Target here? Target here? Target here? ManageableProblems Expected SeriousProblems Expected No Problems Expected Target Outcome 100% % Confidence 0% Range of Project Outcomes 31 UNCLASSIFIED
Understanding the results • ‘Serious Problem’ targets are likely to be unachievable. • ‘No problem’ targets are likely to be inefficient and contain contingency • Targets within the range of possible outcomes are likely to be achievable and efficient 32 UNCLASSIFIED
Criticality - Single Point 30 Critical Path 90 60 120 130 140 70 10 20 40 FINISH START 100 80 110 50 33 UNCLASSIFIED
Criticality - 3 point 30 90 60 120 130 140 70 10 20 40 START FINISH 100 80 Critical Path 110 50 34 UNCLASSIFIED
Criticality Index 35 UNCLASSIFIED
High Medium Low Low Medium High Schedule Summary • Identify Risks • Prioritise Risks • Quantify Risks • Understand Results 36 UNCLASSIFIED
Summary 1 • Risk Identification • Break down the task, identify the risks and their responses • Analysis • Model the individual elements and combine them to form an overall result • Planning • Plan for corrective actions, risk reduction options and fall-back plan • Management • Carry out and monitor the plans 37 UNCLASSIFIED
Summary 2 • GIGO • Stakeholder involvement • Take it seriously • Mandated Process in MoD 38 UNCLASSIFIED
ANY QUESTIONS ? • More information ?? • DAWN Knowledge Base • PFG WEB Site PFG “Professional Services that Count” • PFG Risk-1 (Dave Burgin) • PFG Risk-8 (Paul Woodward) Mail Point # 2104 LARCH level 1a MoD Abbey Wood , Bristol • Tel No 0117-91-34382 • FAX 0117-91-33970 • E-mail - • PFG-Risk-Analysis-Team@dpa.mod.uk 39 UNCLASSIFIED