100 likes | 299 Views
What is Innovation?. Adoption of new patterns of behaviorIdeas incorporated into actionTypes:StrategicTacticalOrganizationalDistinguishing the original from the derivative. Explaining Innovation and Adaptation. Problem solving and analogical reasoningNew logical connectionsProblems redefine
E N D
1. Innovation in Terrorist Behavior Martha Crenshaw
Wesleyan University
2. What is Innovation? Adoption of new patterns of behavior
Ideas incorporated into action
Types:
Strategic
Tactical
Organizational
Distinguishing the original from the derivative
3. Explaining Innovation and Adaptation Problem solving and analogical reasoning
New logical connections
Problems redefined and routines stretched
New solution
New association of familiar methods
Modification of the known to fit the new
Result of learning not inspiration
Not necessarily due to failure of other methods
Role of entrepreneurs & intrinsic motivation
Stimuli:
Government’s innovation
New opportunities and resources
New constituencies
Intra-movement rivalries
4. Strategic Innovation Shifts that transform nature of terrorist challenge
Exceptional and rare
Requires new conception of strategic effectiveness
New goal
New way of relating operations to goal
5. Tactical and Organizational Innovation Tactics
Change in method, not strategic conceptualization
New weapons and targets
More frequent than strategic innovations
Organizations
Change in group structure (e.g., hierarchy vs. “flat” or leaderless)
“Open underground” vs. clandestinity
Alliances
6. Diffusion of Innovation How?
Direct contact
Imitation
Observation
Media transmission (television, internet)
Which innovations?
Appearance of success
Ease of use
Salience and publicity
To whom?
Identification processes
Reference groups and role models
7. Example: “Suicide Terrorism” Origins in Iran-Iraq War, 1980-1988
Hezbollah as revolutionary model, 1983-2000
Religious sanction by Shi’ite clerics
Aided by Iran
Targets
Embassies (American, Israeli)
Military headquarters/barracks (American, French, Israeli)
Israeli army convoys
Transnational reach (Argentina 1992 & 1994)
Primarily vehicle bombs
Imitated by secular political parties
Participation by women
Videotaping
8. “Suicide Terrorism”: The Diffusion and Adaptation of Innovation LTTE in Sri Lanka 1987-
Assassinations of prominent leaders, including Tamils
Economic, transportation, military, & religious targets
“Human bombs”
Specialized “suicide” units including women
Hamas & Palestinian Islamic Jihad 1993-
Aim mass civilian casualties
Attacks on urban centers within Green Line
Culture of martyrdom in Sunni community
Imitation by PFLP and Fatah (Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade)
“Human bombs”
No US targets
9. Evolution of “suicide terrorism”: Al Qaeda Al Qaeda 1988-
Relationship to Egyptian Islamic Jihad
Shift to anti-US 1996
9/11
Global reach
Pre 9/11 (Kenya, Tanzania, Yemen, Afghanistan, Italy, US, Jordan. . . .)
Post 9/11(Tunisia, Indonesia, Kenya, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Turkey, Pakistan, Egypt, England, Bangladesh. . . .)
Combination of organizations
Underground conspiracy
Social movement/volunteers
Business enterprise
Transnational
Forced decentralization post 9/11
Variety of targets (diplomatic, military, economic, civilian, religious)
Narrow focus
10. “Suicide terrorism” in Iraq 2003- Organizations
Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia 2004-
Mujahideen Shura Council 2006-
Ansar al Sunna
“Unknowns”
Sectarian dimension
Pakistan as model?
Multiple targeting of civilians, police, military, coalition forces, local authorities
Frequency
Palestinians 1993-2005, estimated 142 attacks
Iraq 2004-2005, 544 car bombs alone
Context of insurgency
External reach (Jordan)