1 / 52

I AM A FAIR PERSON.

I AM A FAIR PERSON. BUT IN A CASE INVOLVING ALCOHOL, I AM NOT “ IMPARTIAL ”. Texas Code of Criminal Procedure Article 35.16 SEC 10.

ruthjmartinez
Download Presentation

I AM A FAIR PERSON.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. I AM A FAIR PERSON.

  2. BUT IN A CASE INVOLVING ALCOHOL, I AM NOT “IMPARTIAL”.

  3. Texas Code of Criminal ProcedureArticle 35.16 SEC 10 From hearsay, or otherwise, is there established in the mind of the Juror such a conclusion as to the Guilt or Innocence of the Defendant as would influence the Juror in finding a verdict?

  4. Texas Code of Criminal ProcedureArticle 35.16 SEC 10 In the Juror’s opinion, will the conclusion so established influence the Juror’s verdict?

  5. ARE YOU A NON-DRINKER?

  6. DO YOU HAVE A LAW ENFORCEMENT BACKGROUND?

  7. DO YOU HAVE A FAMILY MEMBER OR CLOSE FRIEND WHO IS A POLICE OFFICER OR A PROSECUTOR?

  8. WHAT IS YOUR PRIOR EXPERIENCE AS A JUROR?

  9. THE LAW STATES THAT YOUR DECISION IS TO BE BASED ON THE LAW AND_________.

  10. SHOULD SYMPATHY PLAY ANY PART IN YOUR DECISION?

  11. THE LAW STATES THAT ALL PERSONS ARE PRESUMED TO BE INNOCENT. HOW DO YOU FEEL ABOUT THAT LAW?

  12. HE WOULDN’T BE HERE IF HE WASN’T GUILTY.

  13. IS THERE A “GRAND JURY” THAT HEARS A MISDEMEANOR CASE BEFORE IT IS FILED?

  14. HAS THE JUDGE REVIEWED THE FACTS OF THIS CASE?

  15. THE VERDICT IN THIS CASE WILL BE GUILTY OR _____________?

  16. IF YOU VOTE “NOT GUILTY”, DOES THAT MEAN THAT YOU DO NOT SUPPORT THE POLICE DEPARTMENT?

  17. WHAT DOES A VERDICT OF “NOT GUILTY” MEAN?

  18. I WOULD PREFER TO HAVE A TEST SCORE BUT IF INTOXICATION IS PROVEN TO ME BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT, I CAN FOLLOW THE LAW.

  19. WHY WOULD A PERSON NOT GIVE A DIRECT ANSWER TO A QUESTION?

  20. HOW MANY OF YOU HAVE HAD A JOB EVALUATION IN THE PAST FEW YEARS? 

  21. HOW MANY OF YOU HAVE RECEIVED A TRAFFIC TICKET THAT YOU DO NOT THINK YOU SHOULD HAVE RECEIVED?

  22. CAN YOU DISAGREE WITH A PERSON’S OPINION WITHOUT CALLING HIM OR HER A LIAR?

  23. WHAT IS THE LEVEL OF PROOF FOR AN OFFICER TO WRITE THE TICKET?

  24. WHAT IS PROBABLE CAUSE?

  25. NORMAL WHAT IS ANOTHER WORD FOR “NORMAL”?

  26. NORMAL TEXAS CASE LAW STATES THAT NORMAL IS THE AVERAGE NON INTOXICATED PERSON.

  27. NORMAL WHAT IS AN “AVERAGE” GRADE IN HIGH SCHOOL?

  28. WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN DWI AND DUI?

  29. 5th Amendment “IF THE DEFENDANT DOES NOT TESTIFY, YOU WILL NOT CONSIDER THE DECISION OF THE DEFENDANT TO NOT TESTIFY AS A CIRCUMSTANCE AGAINST HIM AND YOU WILL NOT IN YOUR DELIBERATIONS ALLUDE TO, COMMENT ON, OR IN ANY MANNER REFER TO THE FACT THAT THE DEFENDANT HAS NOT TESTIFIED.”

  30. AT WHAT POINT IS A PERSON IN THE UNITED STATES REQUIRED TO PROVE THEIR INNOCENCE?

  31. OTHER THAN APPEAR IN COURT, WHAT IS AN ACCUSED PERSON IN THE UNITED STATES REQUIRED TO DO IN THIS COURTROOM?

  32. “THE LAW DOES NOT REQUIRE THE DEFENDANT TO PROVE HIS INNOCENCE OR PRODUCE ANY EVIDENCE AT ALL.”

  33. IF A PERSON REFUSES A BREATH TEST, ARE THEY INFORMED BY THE POLICE THAT THEY HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A HEARING BEFORE THEIR LICENSE CAN BE SUSPENDED?

  34. THERE IS ANOTHER COURTROOM WHERE THE BURDEN OF PROOF IS “CLEAR AND CONVINCING”.

  35. WHICH REQUIRES A HIGHER LEVEL OF PROOF: “CLEAR AND CONVINCING” OR “BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT”?

  36. Burden of Proof

  37. TO YOU, WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT WORD IN THE LAW …. “BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT”

  38. WHAT DOES “BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT” MEAN TO YOU?

  39. CAN YOU CHANGE THE LAW? 

  40. AT WHAT POINT IN THE TRIAL CAN A DOUBT BASED ON REASON BE RAISED?

  41. REASONABLE DOUBT CAN BE RAISED 3 WAYS

  42. The Evidence Lack of Evidence Conflict in Evidence

  43. IF INSTRUCTED BY THE JUDGE, CAN YOU FOLLOW THE LAW REGARDING “BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT”?

  44. WHO HAS KNOWLEDGE OF BREATH TESTINGOR BLOOD TESTING? 

  45. IS THERE A PRESUMPTION THAT THE TEST SCORE IS ACCURATE? 

  46. DOES THE “BEYOND A REASONALBLE DOUBT” BURDEN OF PROOF APPLY TO THE ACCUARACY OF THE TEST SCORE?

  47. IF INSTRUCTED BY THE JUDGE … WILL YOU REQUIRE  THE PROSECUTION TO PROVE TO YOU THAT THE TEST SCORE WAS ACCURATE “BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT”?

  48. AT WHAT TIME MUST THE TEST SCORE BE .O8 OR HIGHER?

More Related