210 likes | 337 Views
Interface Redesign of Flight Reservation Systems. Nicholas R. Jones Chris S. T. Fernandes Computer Science Union College. Human Computer Interaction Usability Analysis Flight Reservation System. Outline. Motivation Existing Solutions Goals Evaluation Process Results Conclusion.
E N D
Interface Redesign of Flight Reservation Systems Nicholas R. Jones Chris S. T. Fernandes Computer Science Union College
Human Computer Interaction • Usability Analysis • Flight Reservation System Nicholas R. Jones
Outline • Motivation • Existing Solutions • Goals • Evaluation Process • Results • Conclusion Nicholas R. Jones
Motivation • Easy for anyone to make an interface • Some are not intended for human consumption • Interfaces that are not tested Nicholas R. Jones
Existing Solutions • Travel Sites: • Travelocity • Orbitz • Expedia • Focusing on Flight Reservations Nicholas R. Jones
Goals • 1.) Time to learn • 2.) Speed of performance • 3.) Rate of errors by users • 4.) Retention over time • 5.) Satisfaction • Shneiderman, Ben. Designing the User Interface. Third Edition. Reading, MA: Addison Wesley, 1998. p 15 Nicholas R. Jones
Evaluation Process • Test on Users • Analyze data to find where problems occur • Suggest multiple ways to fix problems • Test for best solutions • Incorporate solutions in redesign • Run user evaluation again Nicholas R. Jones
Methods • Usability Analysis • Scenarios • Timing and Noting • “Thinking-Aloud Protocol” • Surveys • Automated Testing • Collect various information remotely Nicholas R. Jones
User Test 1 • 6 participants tested • Each participant – 3 scenarios • Frustrating Issues • Waiting and re-entering data • Distinguishing between different flight • Date and time inputs Nicholas R. Jones
User Test 2 • Entering in Dates • Calendar Input • Pull-Down Menus • Text in MM/DD/YY format • Re-entering in Data • Left, Right, or Bottom Nicholas R. Jones
Test 2 results • Pull down menus were significantly faster than calendar input • Inputting into the Left and the Bottom was significantly faster and more satisfying than on the Right • N=49 participants Nicholas R. Jones
User Test 3 • Nine students tested several interfaces using three scenarios. • Fictional FlightGuide.com site • Travelocity, and Orbitz used for comparisons Nicholas R. Jones
Input Screen • Round trip /one way needs to be clearer • before/after/around helpful if noticed • A method to see flight duration before results • Results Screen • Sort by flight length, start time, price • Total flight duration • Results kept together and not separated Nicholas R. Jones
User Test 4 • 5 students participated • Used fictional FlightGuide.com site Nicholas R. Jones
Input Screen • missed one way/round trip still, did not like in middle • liked trip duration • Half used before/around/after • Results Screen • Did not notice sort by fields • Would like an overview of results • Easier way to track results. (color code) Nicholas R. Jones
Conclusions • Information Visualization • Search • Overview • Zoom and Filter • Details on Demand • Asking users is not enough Nicholas R. Jones
5 users is enough http://www.useit.com/alertbox/20000319.html Nicholas R. Jones