1 / 59

CORONIAL HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATHS

CORONIAL HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATHS. Dr Don Buchanan Forensic Medical Officer Queensland. PURPOSE. To help prevent deaths from similar causes happening in the future. REPORTABLE DEATHS. “Reportable Deaths” must be reported to – Coroner Police officer

shalin
Download Presentation

CORONIAL HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATHS

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. CORONIAL HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATHS Dr Don Buchanan Forensic Medical Officer Queensland

  2. PURPOSE To help prevent deaths from similar causes happening in the future

  3. REPORTABLE DEATHS • “Reportable Deaths” must be reported to – • Coroner • Police officer • Death in custody only reported to State Coroner or Deputy State Coroner • If death reported to police officer because a death certificate has not or is likely not to be issued, police officer can wait until satisfied this is or will be the case

  4. CRITERIA FOR REPORTABLE DEATHS Geographical Category of death

  5. GEOGRAPHICAL Death happened in Qld. Death happened elsewhere but • Body of deceased in Qld, or • At time of death person ordinarily lived in Qld, or • At time of death person was on a journey to or from somewhere in Qld, or • Death caused by an event that happened in Qld However death outside Qld, not reportable if it has already been reported to a non-Qld coroner. If the death occurred outside Australia, coroner not to investigate unless directed by the Minister

  6. NATURE OF DEATH • Person unknown • Violent or otherwise unnatural death • Suspicious circumstances • Death a health care related death • Death certificate not issued and not likely to be issued • Death in care • Death in custody • Police operations

  7. VIOLENT OR UNNATURAL DEATHS Violent generally clear Unnatural traditionally – accident, suicide or homicide Three broad categories of unnatural deaths • Effects of chemicals eg alcohol, drugs and poisons • Deprivation of air, food, water such as asphyxia, drowning, dehydration, starvation • Physical factors such as trauma, cold, heat, fire, electricity, radiation

  8. ?UNNATURAL DEATHS Doctrine of Double Effect • Intention/Foresight Distinction Withholding/Withdrawal of Medical Treatment • Act/Omission Distinction (Re: B; Bland’s case)

  9. SUSPICIOUS DEATHS Initial cause of death uncertain Concern about surrounding circumstances

  10. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH “Health care” means a health procedure or any care, treatment, advice, service or good provided for the benefit of human health

  11. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH “Health procedure” means a dental, surgical or other health related procedure, including for example the administration of an anaesthetic, analgesic, sedative or other drug

  12. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH Death under this category reportable if – (1) Health care likely caused or contributed to death; AND (2) Immediately before health care provided, independent person would not have reasonably expected the health care would cause/contribute to the death

  13. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH Death under this category reportable if - (1) Failure to provide health care likely caused or contributed to death; AND (2) When health care sought, independent person would not have reasonably expected the failure to provide the health care that would cause/contribute to the death

  14. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH Independent person is to have regard to all relevant matters including – • Deceased’s state of health as it was thought to be when health care begun or sought; • Clinically accepted range of risk associated with the health care; • Circumstances in which health care was provided or sought.

  15. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH Ask TWO basic questions 1. Did the health care cause or contribute to the death? 2. Was the death from the health care not reasonably expected?

  16. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH 1. Did the health care cause or contribute to the death? • Would the person have died at about the same time without the health care? Y/N • Did the death result directly from the underlying disease or injury? Y/N • Was the health care carried out with all reasonable care and skill? Y/N If all answered “yes”, then procedure did not cause or contribute to the death

  17. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH 2. Was the death not reasonably expected? • Before health care was provided, was the patient’s condition such that the death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Y/N • Was the person told that death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Y/N • Was the decision to provide the health care reasonable given the person’s condition, including their quality of life, if the health care was not provided? Y/N If all answered “yes”, then death was reasonably expected

  18. HEALTH CARE RELATED DEATH For failure cases ask two basic questions - 1. Did the failure to provide health care cause or contribute to the death? 2. Was the failure to provide health care that caused/contributed to the death not reasonably expected?

  19. CORONER CAN CEASE INVESTIGATING A REPORTABLE DEATH • If a death is reportable but coroner considers no autopsy and no further investigation required • Can authorise doctor to issue routine (non-coronial) cause of death certificate • Treating doctor must complete a Form 1A with summary of deceased’s last illness attached

  20. ROLE OF CLINICAL FORENSIC MEDICAL OFFICER Review deaths pursuant to a Form 1A and advise if reportable or not reportable; - if reportable, advise whether autopsy and further investigation is warranted (or not). Where autopsy ordered and further investigation commenced, advise on the clinical and/or toxicological aspects of the death

  21. Case 1 • 56 year old woman • Admitted for biopsy cerebral tumour • Frozen section – anaplastic malignancy (severely abnormal cells) • 6 hours post op - decreased LOC, intubated, ventilated • Urgent CT - haemorrhage into tumour • Decision in consultation with family (in view of histology) was not to operate again – brain death

  22. Case 1 Form 1A to the coroner Interim Death Certificate stated - • 1(a) Cerebral Oedema • 1(b) Right Anaplastic Cerebral Tumour Reportable or Not Reportable?

  23. Case 1 1. Did the health care cause or contribute to the death? • Would the person have died at about the same time without the health care? Ans: N • Did the death result directly from the underlying disease or injury? Ans: N • Was the health care carried out with all reasonable care and skill? Ans: Y Hence health care caused/contributed to the death

  24. Case 1 2. Was the death from the health care not reasonably expected? • Before the health care was provided, was the patient’s condition such that the death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the person told that death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the decision to provide the health care reasonable given the person’s condition, including their quality of life, if the health care was not provided? Ans: Y Hence the death was not reasonably expected.

  25. Case 1 Suggested Death Certificate • 1(a) Cerebral Oedema • 1(b) Haemorrhage into Anaplastic Cerebral Tumour • 1(c) Biopsy of Anaplastic Cerebral Tumour

  26. Case 2 • 66 year old Male • PH – COPD, AVR, carcinoma colon • Admitted for right hemicolectomy • Post op – ICU – wound infection - sepsis – settled after 10 days sufficient for discharge to ward • CVL required replacement – At 1800 hours a R subclavian approach – check CXR ordered; • 0200 hours ward call ATSP re SOB - ?CCF ?COPD – given diuretics, bronchodilators – minimal effect – then arrests and dies

  27. Case 2 Form 1A to the coroner Interim Cause of death certificate stated - • 1(a). Respiratory Failure • 1(b). Acute exacerbation COPD • 2. Carcinoma colon Reportable or Not Reportable?

  28. Case 2 • Copy of medical notes received • No documentation made at the time when central line was replaced – written in retrospect • No note made at any time that CXR was seen • CXR showed R pneumothorax • A pneumothorax not considered by doctors treating him for the acute SOB episode prior to death (supported by interim Cause of Death Certificate)

  29. Case 2 1. Did the health care cause or contribute to the death? • Would the person have died at about the same time without the health care? Ans: N • Did the death result directly from the underlying disease or injury? Ans: N • Was the health care carried out with all reasonable care and skill? Ans: ?Y Hence the health care (ie replacement of central line) caused/contributed to the death.

  30. Case 2 2. Was the death from the health care not reasonably expected? • Before the health care was provided, was the patient’s condition such that the death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the person told that death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the decision to provide the health care reasonable given the person’s condition, including their quality of life, if the health care was not provided? Ans: Y Hence the death from the health care was not reasonably expected.

  31. Case 2 Suggested Cause of Death Certificate • 1(a) Respiratory failure • 1(b) Right sided pneumothorax • 1(c) Insertion right subclavian central venous line • 2. carcinoma colon, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

  32. Case 3 • 80 year old male • PH – CCF, COPD, OA • PC – sudden onset severe epigastric pain previous 2 hours; rigid abdomen, free air in abdomen; febrile • Laparotomy – perforated DU; successfully repaired; sent to ICU • Post op – cardiogenic shock treated with inotropes, settles over 5 days; extubated; sent to ward • Next day spikes fever, AF, hypotensive episode • Resuscitated; re-admitted to ICU diagnosis sepsis; • Despite inotropic support and IV antibiotics - dies

  33. Case 3 • Form 1A to coroner • Interim death certificate states – • 1(a) Multi organ failure • 1(b) Abdominal sepsis • 1(c) Perforated duodenal ulcer • 2. Congestive Cardiac Failure, COPD Reportable or Not reportable?

  34. Case 3 1. Did the health care cause or contribute to the death? • Would the person have died at about the same time without the health care? Ans: Y • Did the death result directly from the underlying disease or injury? Ans: Y • Was the health care carried out with all reasonable care and skill? Ans: Y Hence the health care did not cause/contribute to the death.

  35. Case 4 • 59 year old man presented with chest pain to local country hospital one evening • Discharged next morning pain free • Advised to see LMO in 2 days for follow up • LMO diagnosed chest wall pain • Found dead next morning – police called • LMO prepared to complete death certificate as MI being the cause of death given his pain and past medical history

  36. Case 4 Form 1A to coroner Interim death certificate stated – 1(a) Myocardial Infarction

  37. Case 4 Hospital Medical Record • Pain came on after lifting and was 9/10 severity • Initially was sharp then dull not associated with nausea, cough, fever or palpitations • No PMH, FH recorded • Smoker, on no medication • Examination records normal heart sounds and the chest was clear • Troponin was negative • No CXR or other test

  38. Case 4 Hospital Medical Record • But CXR report done 12 months earlier documenting cardiomegaly • Discharged pain free next morning with advice for follow up with LMO • Follow up recommended exercise stress test, cholesterol test and maybe CXR

  39. Case 4 LMO Medical Notes • Seen 2 days later with history of episodic but continuing pain • Notes document patient had family history of heart disease • History of borderline hypertension, raised cholesterol, and indeed was a smoker • Examination consisted of sternal palpation - was tender - Nil other examination recorded • Chest wall pain diagnosed • Given NSAIDs

  40. Case 4 LMO Medical Notes • An entry noted he had had a CT Angiogram of thoracic aorta at a provincial hospital 18 months earlier after being struck by a car • GP was requested to provide her copy of this report • Report documented a dilated aortic root 5.5cm diameter, longstanding, and report recommended further investigation with ultrasound

  41. Case 4 1. Did the failure to provide health care cause or contribute to the death? • Would the person have likely died if the health care had been provided? Ans: N • Was the underlying disease or injury such that it was not amenable to the health care that was sought? Ans: N • Was the health care that was actually provided carried out with all reasonable care and skill? Ans: N Hence the failure to provide health care caused/contributed to the death.

  42. Case 4 2. Was the failure to provide health care that caused/contributed to the death not reasonably expected? • When the health care was sought, was the patient’s condition such that the death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the person told that death was foreseen as more likely than not to occur? Ans: N • Was the decision not to provide the health care reasonable given the person’s condition at the time? Ans: N Hence the death from the failure to provide health care was not reasonably expected.

  43. Case 4 • Reportable • Given the information provided, further examination recommended • Hence interim death certificate not accepted

  44. Case 4 Autopsy revealed a type A aortic dissection (dissecting aortic aneurysm) with cardiac tamponade (600ml)

  45. Case 4 Advice • Dangers of use of retrospectocope • Dissecting aortic aneurysm difficult to diagnose • But inadequate history taking, physical examination, investigation, limited the chance of diagnosis • And there were hints

  46. THE END

  47. Case 5 45 year old woman carcinoma rectum • Routine admission for anterior resection and loop ileostomy • No significant PMH; on no medications • Pre-op PR 84; BP 140/85; Hb 120; Plts 386 Operation • Notes do not reveal any technical issues or intra-operative bleeding • Given heparin 5000 units S/C at conclusion of procedure

  48. Case 5 Recovery • PR 90/min; BP 130/65; RR 18 • Minimal drainage • Obs stable over 2 hours • PCA morphine 1mg/1ml • RTW awake and stable after 2 hours in recovery

  49. Case 5 Ward • RTW at 1500 hours • Obs done at 1530 wnl • Next obs at 1730 wnl • Next obs at 2000 – BP 86/60 • No further obs documented • Nursing note entered at 2030 stated “drowsy but rousable during shift, hypotensive at times..”

  50. Case 5 Ward • At 0030 hours found to be in cardiac arrest • Asystole –CPR, adrenaline, ROSC but unconscious with fixed dilated pupils • Surgeon at 0100 noted no abdo distension and minimal drainage - initially considered PE, CVA

More Related