1 / 22

APNIC Fee Structure Membership Fee Structure IPv6 Fees for Confederations

APNIC Fee Structure Membership Fee Structure IPv6 Fees for Confederations. APNIC Annual Member Meeting Seoul, 3 March 2000. Membership Fee Structure. Background Proposal IPv4, IPv6 and Combined Outcome APNIC and Members Implementation Questions. Background.

siyamak-jihan
Download Presentation

APNIC Fee Structure Membership Fee Structure IPv6 Fees for Confederations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. APNIC Fee StructureMembership Fee StructureIPv6 Fees for Confederations APNIC Annual Member Meeting Seoul, 3 March 2000

  2. Membership Fee Structure • Background • Proposal • IPv4, IPv6 and Combined • Outcome • APNIC and Members • Implementation • Questions

  3. Background • Proposal presented to AMM 1999 (SG) • Decision deferred to future meeting • Updated proposal published • Wednesday 1 Dec 1999 • Membership advised of fee changes • Friday 4 Feb 2000 • Updated proposal published 15 Feb 2000

  4. Background • Current Structure - “Self-determined” • Members choose category • Small, Medium, Large, Very Large • Determines annual fee and number of votes • Problems • “Drift” from larger categories to smaller • No relationship between “size” and “cost” • Unfair distribution of funding burden • Serious concerns about future implications

  5. Background • Current Structure - “Self-determined” • Members choose category • Note: Theoretical figures • Based on current membership only

  6. New Fee Structure • Proposed Structure - “Deterministic” • Minimum category determined by total IP allocations • Design structure so that... • Minimum conceptual change from current system • Category system maintained • APNIC income is maintained • Minimum number of members affected • System is simple

  7. New Fee Structure • Proposed Structure - “Deterministic” • Considering IPv4 and IPv6 separately • Question: How to deal with members holding IPv6 and IPv4 allocations?

  8. New Fee Structure • Combined allocations - IPv4 and IPv6 • Assess as one membership • Choose larger of IPv4 and IPv6 category • Option: where equal, choose larger+1 • Assess as two separate memberships • Recognises likely changes in IPv6 policies/fees • Recommend • Assess as two separate memberships • Other suggestions?

  9. Impact - APNIC income • Outcome - IPv4 only • Based on allocations at 1 Feb 2000

  10. Impact - Members • Summary of fee change impact • 103 members have fee change (25% of total)

  11. Impact - Members • Fee increase • Members with fee increase: 44 • Total Fee increase: USD 175,000 • Fee decrease • Members with fee decrease: 59 • Total Fee decrease: USD 200,000 • Net revenue gain: USD 25,000 • 1.7% increase in total APNIC revenues

  12. Impact - IPv6 • Outcome - IPv6 • Based on allocations at 1 Feb 2000 • 8 allocations so far - all /35 • All assessed as Small members • 5 allocations to new APNIC members • 1 of these elected Medium category • 3 allocations to existing APNIC members • Impact depends on treatment of combined allocations

  13. Implementation • New members • Structure should be effective immediately • Current members • Propose to change from 1 July 2000 • All membership renewals after this date would be assessed according to total allocations • Question: Pro-rata charge for increase in category during term of membership?

  14. Summary • Benefits • Prevent “drift” to smaller categories • Members pay fees more fairly: • According to resources consumed • According to burden placed on APNIC secretariat • Fair sharing of APNIC funding • Increased security for future operations • Recommend implementation

  15. Memberships Fee Structure • Questions?

  16. APNIC Fee StructureMembership Fee StructureIPv6 Fees for Confederations APNIC Annual Member Meeting Seoul, 3 March 2000

  17. IPv6 Fee for Confederations • Background • Proposal • Implementation • Questions

  18. Background • IPv6 allocations to confederations • NIR • No ‘pool’ of addresses held by NIR • Changing policy environment • Very little global experience • Members of NIR • NIR acts as “Agent” in forwarding request • Liaise with APNIC on behalf of their member • Problem • Determination of an appropriate fee?

  19. Proposal • IPv6 address architecture • Every ‘site’ receives a /48 • Note each SLA is 65,536 /64 addresses • Each /64 address can address a whole LAN and maybe dial up users • Proposal - ‘per site’ fee under IPv6 • Same as ‘per address’ fee under IPv4 • e.g. USD 0.03 / site for Very Large members • Will apply where confederation is able to undertake allocation process

  20. Implementation Type Prefix SLAs Price (0.03) IPv4 equiv Minimum /35 8192 USD 245.76 /19 /32 65536 USD 1966.08 /16 SubTLA /29 524288 USD 15728.64 /13 • Different approach required for larger allocations • Thus explicitly cap fees at /29 level

  21. Summary • Proposed IPv6 Fees for Confederations • Mirrors existing “per-address” fee structure • Ensures fair contribution to APNIC operating costs • Far lower per-customer cost for ISP networks • Recommendation • Review pricing structure after experience • As variations in global policy occur

  22. IPv6 Fee for Confederations • Questions?

More Related