240 likes | 254 Views
Delve into the significance of the 1st Amendment, freedom of religion, speech, press, and assembly, exploring landmark cases & limits on government power to ensure our civil liberties. Discuss privacy rights, freedom of the press, and rights of the accused in a clear and concise manner.
E N D
Civil Liberties Chapter 4
1st Amendment Rights • Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances
Bill of Rights • Importance of bill of rights - ratification of constitution (1788) - limits nat’l gov’t / fear of tyranny - ensure our civil liberties
Freedom of Religion • Congress cannot respect or prohibit religion • establishment clause - “wall of separation” - gov’t must remain neutral • Can we have prayer in school? - Engel v Vitale (1962) - Court ruled prayer in public school is a violation of 1st amendment
Ten Commandments in the Public sector- Constitutional? • A. Stone v Graham (1980) B. “Hang Ten” movement • Constitutional Ten Commandments
Freedom of Religion • Free Exercise Clause - worship of any or no religion - Gov’t can intervene if harm is present
Freedom of Speech • Can we criticize public officials? • What speech is prohibited? - “clear & present danger” test • Gitlow v. New York - speech may be curtailed if such expression might lead to some “evil”
Prohibited areas of Speech • Can you say anything you want about someone else? • You are protected from defamation of character • Slander • Hate speech - speeches that can lead to violence
Freedom of Expression • How do we express ourselves? • symbolic speech • Protection of Symbolic Speech - Texas v. Johnson (1989)
Flag burning protest • Congress passed Flag protection Act of 1989 - ruled unconstitutional (1990) • What do you think?
Prohibited areas of expression • Prohibited symbolic speech: “intent to intimidate” - burning a cross
Prohibited areas of expression • campus banning of certain clothing
Prohibited areas of Expression • Obscenity • What is obscenity? • Miller v. California
Freedom of the Press • What is the press? • Does the press have freedom? • unless harm is present - Libel
Freedom of the Press (continue) • What about libel against public officials? - N.Y. Times v. Sullivan(1964) - malice must be present
Privacy Rights and Abortion • Do we have a right to privacy? • Roe v. Wade (1973) • Court’s recent view of Roe - Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) - court upheld law requiring preabortion counseling, waiting period, & consent
Other Privacy Rights • Do we have a right to die? • “living wills” - treatment can be withdrawn at the request of a family member
Other Privacy Rights • physician-assisted suicide - Court left issue to states / Oregon
Rights of the accused (p 91-2) Have the courts done too much to protect the rights of the accused, or not enough?
Extending rights of the accused • Gideon v Wainwright(1963) • Miranda v Arizona (1966) • Exclusionary Rule
Death penalty • Since 1973, 100+ prisoners have been freed from death row after new evidence (DNA) has indicated their innocence or wrongful conviction • Is capital punishment a Barbaric act or is it a deterrent to crime? Or does it satisfy society’s need for justice & fair play? • Violation of 8th amendment?
Death penalty • 37 states & Federal Gov’t have capital punishment