310 likes | 322 Views
Explore key competitors in the art industry, analyze their strengths & weaknesses, and learn strategies to reduce competition's impact on your business. Detailed profiles of Art To Remember, Display My Art, Artware By You, Square 1 Art, and Artsonia.
E N D
COMPETITION Lori Cotillo & Dave Morrissey July/August 2008
TRAINING OUTLINEWhat we want to accomplish… • Introduce key regional and national competitors • Outline their backgrounds • Discuss strengths and weaknesses • Review Original Works strengths and unique selling proposition • Present methods of reducing competition impact on your business
Competitive Profile:Art To Remember • They have been in business now for approximately 10 years • Based in Indianapolis, IN. They have a strong presence in the mid-west and have also begun to expand their geographic reach • They have developed a program that is an exact knockoff of our program, offering both an OP & SBYB Program • Extensive Product Line – 28 products. • Sales Model: Direct mail, telemarketing & trade shows www.arttoremember.com
Art To Remember: Strengths • Established player • Regional presence in the mid-west • Expanding nationwide • Good product variety – free S/H • Good merchandising & program promotion
Art To Remember: Weaknesses • Product Quality • Magnet is not laminated • Tile is not full bleed • Placemat is simply laminated artwork • Lower Profit Margin • No high margin (40%-50%) products • Average program profit is 25% vs. 33% for Original Works • They don’t have you! • Limited field sales, service or support. This is a tremendous competitive advantage for us.
Competitive Profile: Display My Art • A relatively new regional competitor since 2007 in New Jersey • Small sales force; 2 account executives in NJ, 1 in MA • Similar product line as the other small competitors that includes wooden keepsakes, stickers, t-shirts www.DisplayMyArt.com
Display My Art: Strengths • Broad product line • Free preview magnet (appears to be business card size with child’s artwork, class, and advertises for company) • Introducing an online ordering system where student’s artwork can be viewed on products prior to orders
Display My Art: Weaknesses • Inexperience - very new regional player • Very small sales force – 3 account executives • No school recognition program • Lower profit margin – 30% • S/H charge of $1.50/order and $5.00 charge on late orders • High retail prices on many products • These items combined reduce overall value proposition • Appears to have manufacturing limitations: 8” square paper limits creativity, no layered paper, no stickers, no small details… • Orders must be submitted to school in numeric order
Competitive Profile: Artware By You • Based in Montclair, New Jersey • In business for approximately 8-9 years • Recently expanded program and product line offerings. Current programs include: • Artwork Program (OP) • Spirit Line Program • Tile Wall Program • Community Service Program • Sales Model: Direct mail, e-mail, telemarketing, trade shows. No current sales force of any significance, though attempting to move in that direction. www.Artwarebyyou.com
Artware By You: Strengths • Experienced Player • Will run custom tailored programs • Accept various artwork sizes (Up to 9” x 12”) • Provide product samples for free • Offer personalization on their products (for extra charge) • Extensive product line – 30 products
Artware By You: Weaknesses • Limited staff/manufacturing capability • Broad offerings make focus & execution difficult • 30% profit margin • Limited field sales force • No lesson plans or recognition programs • Customer service & support more limited, minimal field support, no Customer Care Center, etc. • Require up-front payment of 50% with order
Competitive Profile: Square 1 Art • Based in Atlanta, GA, this competitor was formed in 1999 by two former Original Works employees. Their current programs include: • Artwork program with free magnet • Tile Wall Program • Their sales model is direct mail, telemarketing, trade shows. Limited sales force, though attempting to expand. www.Square1art.com
Square 1 Art: Strengths • Market knowledge & experience • Well developed selling proposition: • Free preview magnet • Free personalization on select products • Free product samples provided on request • Broad product line of 30+ products • Offer 33% profit margins on all products
Square 1 Art: Weaknesses • Free magnet may actually hurt overall program participation & profits • No art recognition programs • Paper size (8” x 8”) limits creativity • The customer pays all freight charges • Recent price increases have reduced their overall value proposition • Require deposit payment with order • Limited field representation and customer service support
Competitive Profile: Artsonia • Based in Chicago, IL, this competitor has been in business for 5-6 years. The company was founded as an internet-based business. • Sales Model: Direct mail, trade shows, e-commerce www.artsonia.com
Artsonia: Strengths • High tech appeal • Good product variety • Student and school recognition through award programs and online art gallery • Lesson plans • Broad market reach: • Children, parents, relatives can view artwork on line • Easy process for anyone to order that has access to that artwork
Artsonia: Weaknesses • School must either scan artwork and submit electronically or pay to have artwork uploaded to their site • Very low profit margin – 15% • Each participant must pay shipping and handling. Depending on order size this could increase cost by 30%-50% or more • Long time-frame for ordering • Open ended timeframe does not create a sense of urgency for ordering. This can reduce participation level and in turn profit earned by the school on the program
Competitive Profile: Silver Graphics • Silver Graphics is a regional competitor based in upstate New York. They started very small working with just a few local schools each year, but within the last three years they have significantly increased their selling efforts in the school marketplace. • Currently owned by two women and a handful of employees. www.silvergraphics.com
Silver Graphics: Strengths • Large product line – approximately 30 products in all. Combines all of the common products offered by Square One, Art To Remember and Original Works • Current profit margin is 33% • Provides free shipping • Accept artwork in sizes up to 11” x 14 ½” • Offers school two free 4” x 5” prints of each child’s artwork – one for the child to keep and one for the art teacher
Silver Graphics: Weaknesses • Due to the high number of products, product quality is an issue • No local sales representation • Limited customer service staff • If they grow, we would anticipate difficulty working with artwork of different sizes while providing free prints and managing a very large product line
Competitive Profile: First ArtWorks • Based in Alpharetta, Georgia, this regional company established in 2007, is quite new to the market and deals with one product only - a child’s artwork framed. The company creates a gallery style presentation of the child’s framed artwork at the school. • Company promotes on their website that they are growing by providing increased numbers of participating students for the upcoming school year, in the State of Georgia alone. www.firstartworks.com
First ArtWorks: Strengths • School only has to produce artwork; the rest of the program is run by the company • Gallery style presentation allows artwork to be displayed completed; also provides student recognition • Artwork paper provided is preprinted with school name, county, homeroom teacher name, and grade • Lesson plans are available • Artwork can be viewed online prior to show with access code; option of purchasing ahead so parents do not need to attend show • Unpurchased artwork is unframed and sent back to school • Website provides program promotion tips and incentives
First ArtWorks: Weaknesses • Limited product line - Only deals with one product risking less attractiveness to fundraising efforts for a school • Low profit margin – website advertises 20% • Original art is only available for purchase for 2 wks following show; then it is unframed and returned to school • One product may make expanding into other products difficult with regard to manufacturing
Original Works Competitive Advantages • Leadership Position • Most experienced • Largest provider • Proven track record • First rate customer service • High level of product quality • Seasoned team of sales, marketing, customer service, manufacturing and finance professionals • Product satisfaction guarantee
Original WorksCompetitive Advantages • Large scale manufacturing capability in two locations totaling 20,000+ square feet • Competitive profit margins • School recognition programs • Free materials, paper, lesson plans, shipping • No up-front payment required
BEATING THE COMPETITION STARTS WITH YOU • Appreciate your schools • A note, a phone call, $5 gift card • Follow-up • Email, newsletter, what’s new • Sign repeat schools quickly • Sign early, secure your business! • Stay in touch • Don’t let the competition get there first!
KNOW YOUR CUSTOMER and WHAT MAKES THEM BUY • What is going on in their school? • You are on the front lines • Who are the current contacts? • Keep in touch, follow-up, district/in-service meetings • What are their needs? Have they changed? Pay attention to clues! • Price • Product mix • Profit • The competition • Just a little bit of effort! • Reveals changes, needs, competitors that have surfaced
LEVERAGE THE COMPETITION • Competition is a marketplace reality • Key buying signal - Presence of a competitor • Step up, don’t give up • Use the competition to help you sell • Improve on the competitive selling proposition and seal the deal
LEARN YOUR BUSINESS WELL • Knowledge is a competitive edge • Know your products and programs • Understand how they apply to your prospect’s needs • Collect as much information as you can on your competition: - Programs - Products - Service - Price - Location - Promotion
SUMMARY • Competition is part of our business. It justifies the market and makes us stronger • You have more control over competition than you think. Know your customer and understand what makes them buy • Leverage the competition and make the presence of competition work for you • Understand your competitor’s strengths and weaknesses. Look at them objectively – through the eyes of a customer • Exploit weakness in a strategic fashion
Thank you for you for joining us today! Have a Wonderful Day!