180 likes | 304 Views
The Objective Knowledge Growth Framework in [and] Principal ’ s Decision Making: A proposed. International Professional Development Association 2010 Conference Birmingham, UK. Stephanie Chitpin Paul Newton Don Klinger Peter Grimmett Claire IsaBelle November, 2010.
E N D
The Objective Knowledge Growth Framework in [and] Principal’s Decision Making: A proposed International Professional Development Association 2010 Conference Birmingham, UK Stephanie Chitpin Paul Newton Don Klinger Peter Grimmett Claire IsaBelle November, 2010
Purpose of this activity • To use a reflective decision-making approach to solve difficult problems and issues in organizational settings; • To increase awareness of own problem solving skills. steph.chitpin
Identification of Problem (P1) Tentative Theory (TT1) Error Elimination (EE1) OKGF cycle Figure 1. Schematic representation of the OKGF. steph.chitpin
A1 – Identification of Problem Definition of Problem (P1): • the problem(s) you face in your school or organization • What are difficult problems? • What makes them problematic? steph.chitpin
What is a problem? • Elements of problems • -Complexity; • -Competing solutions; • -Nature of problems steph.chitpin
A1 – Examples of problems • How to improve EQAO scores? • ? steph.chitpin
Activity 1: Identification of a problem • Work in a team (4 or 5 ). • Identify a problem that you had to deal with. • Write the problem on the blank template provided. • Be prepared to solve the issue. steph.chitpin
TT1 – Tentative Theory Definition of ‘TT1’: • a statement that helps you solve the identified problem. • synonyms for policies, standards, guidelines, steps, criteria. steph.chitpin
Activity 2: Identification of Tentative Theory • In your team or group, find one theory to solve the identified problem in Activity 1. • You may make reference to policy, guidelines etc. • Write the selected theory on the blank template. steph.chitpin
Activity 3: Application of theory • In team, test the effectiveness of the theory using the following criteria: • Feasible given time period • Useful • Clear • Relevant • Focused • Describe on the blank template under TT1 your reasoning behind the effectiveness of the theory. steph.chitpin
EE1 – Error Elimination • Definition of ‘EE1’: • the detection of weaknesses and limitations when applying the theory to solve the problem; • one or more of the criteria are not met. steph.chitpin
Activity 4: Error elimination • In team, decide on one of the two possibilities: • whether to revise the theory or discard it and find a new one; • 2. Write your decision on the blank template under (EE1). steph.chitpin
(A2): Identification of new problem Definition of ‘P2’ : refers to the problem that is being reconsidered. steph.chitpin
Completed template • See next slide steph.chitpin
Blank template • See next slide steph.chitpin
Reflection • Does this framework help you to understand the problem and solution(s)? • What did you learn about the problem through this process? • What did you learn about your own knowledge and theories? steph.chitpin