310 likes | 471 Views
This research, funded by The ADOPT Fund of Saskatchewan Agriculture and Food and The Saskatchewan Vegetable Growers Association, aims to compare pre-emergence herbicides in onions for efficacy and crop safety. Herbicides such as Goal, Chateau, Buctril, Dual, and Prowl were tested on Norstar and Copra cultivars. Results show the importance of weed control in maximizing onion yields and the potential impact of herbicides on crop health.
E N D
Onion Weed Control Funding Provided By: The ADOPT Fund of Saskatchewan Agriculture and Food and The Saskatchewan Vegetable Growers Association
Onion Weed Control Objectives (2011 + 2012) - to demonstrate and compare efficacy and crop safety of pre-emergence herbicides in onions
Onion Weed Control Products demonstrated - Goal (oxyfluorfen) - Chateau (flumioxazin) - Buctril (bromoxynil) - Dual (metolachlor) - Prowl (pendimethalin)
Onion Weed Control Cultivars – Norstar and Copra Field - U of S Field Station - “standard” spectrum of weeds - field rotovated week ahead of seeding - direct seed crop in rows 0.5 m apart - just prior to crop emergence – burn off emerged weeds with glyphosate -
Onion Weed Control Maintenance - Overhead irrigated as required - 50 #/a N top-dressed in early July - sprayed with Quadris for botrytis
Onion Weed Control Sprayed - at 2 true leaf stage (mid-June) - repeat at 4-6 leaf stage (mid-July) - all stages and rates according to product label - applied with standard spray gear
Onion Weed Control Data collected - crop toxicity - weed counts/weights - onion yields Herbicides compared against an untreated Control
Onion Weed Control Results - high water table in both years - 2010 crop generally healthy … but grew slowly - 2011 crop struggled with disease and flooding through August – then took off - significant weed pressure throughout both growing seasons
Onion Weed Control Results 2011 - no obvious crop toxicity for any product 2012 - Chateau seemed to stunt/weaken plants - More disease on Chateau treated rows
Onion Weed Control Results - weeds change with season/plot 2011 - Early = stinkweed, RRPW, - Later = mallow, dandelion and curled dock
Onion Weed Control Results - weeds change with season/plot 2012 - Early = stinkweed, portulaca - Later = portulaca, pigweed and groundsel
Check Check Chateau
Check Goal
Onion Herbicides Conclusion - several effective pre-emergent herbicides available - Chateau and Goal provide outstanding control of wide range of broadleaf weeds.
Onion Herbicides Conclusion - weed control is crucial in onions - there are some highly effective herbicides available for use in onions - watch for “hidden” costs of weed control - potential for damage to the crop … while tilling/pulling weeds … by herbicides