280 likes | 377 Views
Peering Agreements. Quilt Peering Workshop St. Louis October 11, 2006 Paul Schopis. Covered Today. Motivations Components/Comparison. Motivations. Set expectations In some case money changes hands Understand how to address difficulties. Components/Comparisons.
E N D
Peering Agreements Quilt Peering Workshop St. Louis October 11, 2006 Paul Schopis
Covered Today • Motivations • Components/Comparison
Motivations • Set expectations • In some case money changes hands • Understand how to address difficulties
Components/Comparisons • Three MoU/MoAs will examined • I did not secure permission, so all are anonymous • Comparisons can get difficult • Different approaches • Different expectations • Similar issues addressed in particular ways
Components/Comparisons • GigaPOP A - Serving Universities & Federal Projects • GigaPOP B - Primarily Higher Ed • GigaPOP C - Consortia in nature
Uniform Issues • Parties and effect upon signature • POC • Liability - None direct or indirect • Indemnification • Relationship - Independent Contractors • Governing Law - Physical location or where corporation is created • Survival - Certain sections are in effect forever • Entire Agreement
Recitals • Basically explains the why • Where as blah blah blah…. • GigaPOP B had it • GigaPOP A & C did not (more in a moment)
Definitions • Defines what you mean i.e. Clinton like “What do you mean by “is”? • GigaPOP A • Defines peering and transit; defines purpose here ie replaces Recitals • GigaPOP B • Defines Backbone, ISP, Interconnection Point, Internet Network • GigaPOP C • None
Arrangement • GigaPOPs A & B are settlement free • GigaPOP C is settlement free per se but does charge an MRC for a port and an NRC for certain types • FE and 1 Gb no install but MRC • 10 Gb Install and MRC apply
Location • GigaPOP A - Yes • GigaPOP B - No • GigaPOP C - Gives multiple locations
Local Loop • GigaPOPs A & C - Peering Partner is responsible for all costs • GigaPOP C - Will provide cross connect • GigaPOP B - Undefined
Interface Specification • GigaPOP A - ATM or 1 Gb • GigaPOP B - Interconnect speed must be no more than Backbone capacity • GigaPOP C - FE, Gb & 10 Gb
Technical Operations • GigaPOP A - None per se • GigaPOP B- One AS number • Must use Route Registry • Route aggregation • 24 Hour Noc • Maintenance Notification
Technical OperationsGigaPOP C • Mostly in attachment ie MoU legalize • GigaPOP will provide • fiber cross connect • 24 Hour Monitoring • DNS for Participants Ports • Provide IP addresses each VLAN
Technical OperationsGigaPOP C • Partner will provide • No Broadcast other than ARP • One MAC per VLAN • No Spanning Tree BPDU • Inter-site VLAN backup only • No ARP response for unassigned IPs • Non-transit Route • Announced Routes must be in Global Route Registry
Specified Protocols • GigaPOP A - BGP4 • GigaPOP B - IPv4, IPv6, IP/TCP, BGP4 • GigaPOP C - IPv4, IPv6, Multicast, BGP4
SLA • GigaPOP A - Undefined • GigaPOP B - 4 hour repair time • If utilization is 40% or must renegotiate connection speed • GigaPOP C - Must not impact GigaPOP • Reasonable Level • Must Notify for non-emergency reset or termination
Wire Tapping • GigaPOP A - Not allowed • GigaPOP B - Not allowed except for lawful purpose • Must not allow 3rd party • GigaPOP C - Undefined
Statistics • GigaPOP A - undefined • GigaPOP B - May collect and use internally or as required by law • May restrict flows on one’s own customer • GigaPOP C - May collect and use for publicity but must be anonymously
Term • GigaPOP A - End of Fiscal Year • GigaPOP B - One Year • GigaPOP C - FE & Gb 1 year, 10 Gb 2 years • All are automatically renewing unless intention to terminate is in writing; A & B are 30 days notice; C is 60 days notice
Warranty • GigaPOP A - AS-IS • GigaPOP B - Standard • GigaPOP C - Standard + Best Effort
Insurance • GigaPOP A - While on GigaPOP A premises • GigaPOP B - Must access own needs and act accordingly • GigaPOP C - Each party is responsible for self
NDA • GigaPOPs A & B - all information is proprietary and must get written permission to use • GigaPOP C - Can use relationship for publicity and publish URL, Contact info and can be used to promote peering
Other • Non-exclusive - GigaPOP B • Reassignment - GigaPOPs B & C • Invalidity - if law prohibits, all other sections still apply GigaPOPs B & C • Force Majeure - GigaPOP B • No Wavier - per incident - GigaPOP C
MOU Check List • Parties • Recitals - Optional • Definitions - Optional • Scope of Work - what you do what they do • Term and Termination • Disclaimer of Warranties
MOU Check List • Limitations of Liability - Indemnification • Confidentiality - Optional • Publicity • Insurance • Independent Contractor Status • Notices
MOU Check ListGeneral Provisions • Modifications • Governing Law • Entire Agreement • Survival • Change in Law • Waiver • Assignment • Venue
Questions? Contact Information Paul Schopis pschopis@oar.net