1 / 22

Thomas R. Bane P.E. 605 Suwannee Street Mail-station 32 Tallahassee Florida 32399 (850) 414-4379 thomas.bane@dot.state.

Roadside - Benefit – Cost assessment See credit below: Thomas Bane. Thomas R. Bane P.E. 605 Suwannee Street Mail-station 32 Tallahassee Florida 32399 (850) 414-4379 thomas.bane@dot.state.fl.us. Benefit / Cost Ratio. Reduction in Accident Costs. R (b/c) =. Increase in Construction

tricia
Download Presentation

Thomas R. Bane P.E. 605 Suwannee Street Mail-station 32 Tallahassee Florida 32399 (850) 414-4379 thomas.bane@dot.state.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Roadside - Benefit – Cost assessment See credit below: Thomas Bane Thomas R. Bane P.E. 605 Suwannee Street Mail-station 32 Tallahassee Florida 32399 (850) 414-4379 thomas.bane@dot.state.fl.us

  2. Benefit / Cost Ratio Reduction in Accident Costs R(b/c) = Increase in Construction & Maintenance Costs

  3. Roadside Guide Roadside Guide Design Design NCHRP RSAP Technical Advisory RS 5.0 Non-Restricted Roadways

  4. Technical Advisory ROADSIDE 5.0 Societal Costs/Severity Level

  5. C:> _ roadside.exe Roadside Program is a DOS based program – Get acquainted with this Type of message! DO YOU WISH TO ENABLE THE PRINTER (Y/N)? Y

  6. Technical Advisory GLOBAL PARAMETER VALUES 1. FATAL ACCIDENT COST = $ 1,000,000 2. SEVERE INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 200,000 3. MODERATE INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 12,500 4. SLIGHT INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 3,750 5. PDO LEVEL 2 ACCIDENT COST = $ 3,125 6. PDO LEVEL 1 ACCIDENT COST = $ 625 7. ENCROACHMENT RATE = 0.0003000 ENCROACHMENTS/km/YR/VPD 8. 50 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 13.0 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 24000 VPD/LANE 9. 60 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.8 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23900 VPD/LANE 10. 70 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23700 VPD/LANE 11. 80 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.0 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23300 VPD/LANE 12. 90 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 11.6 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 22800 VPD/LANE 13. 100 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 11.1 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 22000 VPD/LANE 14. 110 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 10.7 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 21000 VPD/LANE 15. 120 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 10.3 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 20000 VPD/LANE 16. SWATH WIDTH = 3.600 m 17. RESET ALL GLOBALS TO DEFAULT STARTUP VALUES. DO YOU WISH TO CHANGE A PARAMETER VALUE (Y/N)? Y

  7. GLOBAL PARAMETER VALUES 1. FATAL ACCIDENT COST = $ 2,600,000 2. SEVERE INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 505,000 3. MODERATE INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 165,000 4. SLIGHT INJURY ACCIDENT COST = $ 36,167 5. PDO LEVEL 2 ACCIDENT COST = $ 10,469 6. PDO LEVEL 1 ACCIDENT COST = $ 2,000 7. ENCROACHMENT RATE = 0.0003000 ENCROACHMENTS/km/YR/VPD 8. 50 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 13.0 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 24000 VPD/LANE 9. 60 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.8 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23900 VPD/LANE 10. 70 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23700 VPD/LANE 11. 80 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 12.0 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 23300 VPD/LANE 12. 90 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 11.6 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 22800 VPD/LANE 13. 100 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 11.1 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 22000 VPD/LANE 14. 110 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 10.7 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 21000 VPD/LANE 15. 120 km/h DES SPEED ENC ANGLE = 10.3 DEG AND TRAF VOL CAP = 20000 VPD/LANE 16. SWATH WIDTH = 3.600 m 17. RESET ALL GLOBALS TO DEFAULT STARTUP VALUES. DO YOU WISH TO CHANGE A PARAMETER VALUE (Y/N)? N

  8. CURRENT SEVERITY INDEX versus COST RELATIONSHIP SEVERITY INDEX COST 0.0 $ 0 0.5 $ 2,000 1.0 $ 10,250 2.0 $ 26,940 3.0 $ 82,498 4.0 $ 170,041 5.0 $ 342,277 6.0 $ 639,870 7.0 $ 981,526 8.0 $ 1,469,147 9.0 $ 2,052,450 10.0 $ 2,600,000 PRESS ENTER TO CONTINUE

  9. Societal Costs $981,562.00 SI=7.0

  10. Property Damage Only Non-Fatal Injuries % Accidents Fatalities

  11. PRINT STORE RECALL HELP GLOBAL SI v $ DIR SI DEF GRAPH QUIT 1. TITLE: 2. TRAFFIC VOLUME = 38,900 VPD - TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE = 0.650 % PER YEAR 3. DIVIDED HIGHWAY TOTAL LANE(S) = 6 LANE WIDTH = 3.300 m 4. CURVATURE (RADIUS IN METERS) = %999,999 GRADE (PERCENT) = 0.0 5. EFFECTIVE BASELINE CURVATURE GRADE USER TOTAL TRAFFIC VPD ENC/km/YR FACTOR FACTOR FACTOR ENC/km/YR ADJACENT 19,450 5.8350 1.00 1.00 1.00 5.8350 OPPOSING 19,450 0.0000 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.0000 6. DESIGN SPEED = 70 km/h ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG ADT CAP = 23,700 VPD/LANE 7. OFFSET (A) = 3.020 m LENGTH (L) = 0.500 m WIDTH (W) = 0.500 m 8. INITIAL COLLISION FREQUENCY = 0.02615 IMPACTS/YEAR ADJACENT CFTA = 0.0261 CFSU = 0.0018 CFCU = 0.0233 CFFA = 0.0011 OPPOSING CFTO = 0.0000 CFSD = 0.0000 CFCD = 0.0000 CFFO = 0.0000 9. SEVERITY INDEX = SU= 4.40 SD= 2.00 CU= 4.40 CD= 1.00 FACE= 2.20 ACCIDENT COST $ 238,935 $ 26,940 $ 238,935 $ 10,250 $ 38,051 0. PROJECT LIFE = 13 YR DISCOUNT RATE = 7.000 %/YR TRAFFIC CUTOFF YR = 200 CRF = 0.11965 KC = 8.66693 KT = 8.35765 KJ = 0.41496 1. INSTALLATION COST = $ 35,000 SALVAGE VALUE = $ 0 2. REPAIR COST/ACC $ SU= 2000 SD= 1000 CU= 2000 CD= 1000 F= 1000 3. MAINTENANCE COST/YR = $ 100 4. PRESENT WORTH = $ 88,590 ANNUALIZED $ 10,600 ACCIDENT COST = $ 52,310 ANNUALIZED $ 6,259 HIGHWAY DEPT. COST = $ 36,280 ANNUALIZED $ 4,341 O CHANGE OR ACCESS: INPUT ITEM NUM. OR FUNCTION KEY (SEE BELOW) PLUS ENTER.

  12. Actual Horizontal Offset

  13. Efficiency Factors: Slope => Es = 1+ slope/0.4 Vaulting => Frnd = 1+ D slope Dslope-brake = -17.34 m (Dslope) Effective Offset Actual Horizontal Offset

  14. 1. TITLE: 2. TRAFFIC VOLUME = 38,900 VPD - TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE = 0.650 % PER YEAR 3. DIVIDED HIGHWAY TOTAL LANE(S) = 6 LANE WIDTH = 3.300 m 4. CURVATURE (RADIUS IN METERS) = %999,999 GRADE (PERCENT) = 0.0 5. EFFECTIVE BASELINE CURVATURE GRADE USER TOTAL TRAFFIC VPD ENC/km/YR FACTOR FACTOR FACTOR ENC/km/YR ADJACENT 19,450 5.8350 1.00 1.00 1.00 5.8350 OPPOSING 19,450 0.0000 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.0000 6. DESIGN SPEED = 70 km/h ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG ADT CAP = 23,700 VPD/LANE 7. OFFSET (A) = 3.020 m LENGTH (L) = 0.500 m WIDTH (W) = 0.500 m 8. INITIAL COLLISION FREQUENCY = 0.02615 IMPACTS/YEAR ADJACENT CFTA = 0.0261 CFSU = 0.0018 CFCU = 0.0233 CFFA = 0.0011 OPPOSING CFTO = 0.0000 CFSD = 0.0000 CFCD = 0.0000 CFFO = 0.0000 9. SEVERITY INDEX = SU= 4.40 SD= 2.00 CU= 4.40 CD= 1.00 FACE= 2.20 ACCIDENT COST $ 238,935 $ 26,940 $ 238,935 $ 10,250 $ 38,051 0. PROJECT LIFE = 13 YR DISCOUNT RATE = 7.000 %/YR TRAFFIC CUTOFF YR = 200 CRF = 0.11965 KC = 8.66693 KT = 8.35765 KJ = 0.41496 1. INSTALLATION COST = $ 35,000 SALVAGE VALUE = $ 0 2. REPAIR COST/ACC $ SU= 2000 SD= 1000 CU= 2000 CD= 1000 F= 1000 3. MAINTENANCE COST/YR = $ 100 4. PRESENT WORTH = $ 88,590 ANNUALIZED $ 10,600 ACCIDENT COST = $ 52,310 ANNUALIZED $ 6,259 HIGHWAY DEPT. COST = $ 36,280 ANNUALIZED $ 4,341 O CHANGE OR ACCESS: INPUT ITEM NUM. OR FUNCTION KEY (SEE BELOW) PLUS ENTER. PRINT STORE RECALL HELP GLOBAL SI v $ DIR SI DEF GRAPH QUIT

  15. 1. TITLE: 2. TRAFFIC VOLUME = 38,900 VPD - TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE = 0.650 % PER YEAR 3. DIVIDED HIGHWAY TOTAL LANE(S) = 6 LANE WIDTH = 3.300 m 4. CURVATURE (RADIUS IN METERS) = %999,999 GRADE (PERCENT) = 0.0 5. EFFECTIVE BASELINE CURVATURE GRADE USER TOTAL TRAFFIC VPD ENC/km/YR FACTOR FACTOR FACTOR ENC/km/YR ADJACENT 19,450 5.8350 1.00 1.00 1.00 5.8350 OPPOSING 19,450 0.0000 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.0000 6. DESIGN SPEED = 70 km/h ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG ADT CAP = 23,700 VPD/LANE 7. OFFSET (A) = 3.020 m LENGTH (L) = 0.500 m WIDTH (W) = 0.500 m 8. INITIAL COLLISION FREQUENCY = 0.02615 IMPACTS/YEAR ADJACENT CFTA = 0.0261 CFSU = 0.0018 CFCU = 0.0233 CFFA = 0.0011 OPPOSING CFTO = 0.0000 CFSD = 0.0000 CFCD = 0.0000 CFFO = 0.0000 9. SEVERITY INDEX = SU= 4.40 SD= 2.00 CU= 4.40 CD= 1.00 FACE= 2.20 ACCIDENT COST $ 238,935 $ 26,940 $ 238,935 $ 10,250 $ 38,051 0. PROJECT LIFE = 13 YR DISCOUNT RATE = 7.000 %/YR TRAFFIC CUTOFF YR = 200 CRF = 0.11965 KC = 8.66693 KT = 8.35765 KJ = 0.41496 1. INSTALLATION COST = $ 35,000 SALVAGE VALUE = $ 0 2. REPAIR COST/ACC $ SU= 2000 SD= 1000 CU= 2000 CD= 1000 F= 1000 3. MAINTENANCE COST/YR = $ 100 4. PRESENT WORTH = $ 88,590 ANNUALIZED $ 10,600 ACCIDENT COST = $ 52,310 ANNUALIZED $ 6,259 HIGHWAY DEPT. COST = $ 36,280 ANNUALIZED $ 4,341 O CHANGE OR ACCESS: INPUT ITEM NUM. OR FUNCTION KEY (SEE BELOW) PLUS ENTER. PRINT STORE RECALL HELP GLOBAL SI v $ DIR SI DEF GRAPH QUIT

  16. 1. TITLE: 2. TRAFFIC VOLUME = 38,900 VPD - TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE = 0.650 % PER YEAR 3. DIVIDED HIGHWAY TOTAL LANE(S) = 6 LANE WIDTH = 3.300 m 4. CURVATURE (RADIUS IN METERS) = %999,999 GRADE (PERCENT) = 0.0 5. EFFECTIVE BASELINE CURVATURE GRADE USER TOTAL TRAFFIC VPD ENC/km/YR FACTOR FACTOR FACTOR ENC/km/YR ADJACENT 19,450 5.8350 1.00 1.00 1.00 5.8350 OPPOSING 19,450 0.0000 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.0000 6. DESIGN SPEED = 70 km/h ENC ANGLE = 12.4 DEG ADT CAP = 23,700 VPD/LANE 7. OFFSET (A) = 3.020 m LENGTH (L) = 0.500 m WIDTH (W) = 0.500 m 8. INITIAL COLLISION FREQUENCY = 0.02615 IMPACTS/YEAR ADJACENT CFTA = 0.0261 CFSU = 0.0018 CFCU = 0.0233 CFFA = 0.0011 OPPOSING CFTO = 0.0000 CFSD = 0.0000 CFCD = 0.0000 CFFO = 0.0000 9. SEVERITY INDEX = SU= 4.40 SD= 2.00 CU= 4.40 CD= 1.00 FACE= 2.20 ACCIDENT COST $ 238,935 $ 26,940 $ 238,935 $ 10,250 $ 38,051 0. PROJECT LIFE = 13 YR DISCOUNT RATE = 7.000 %/YR TRAFFIC CUTOFF YR = 200 CRF = 0.11965 KC = 8.66693 KT = 8.35765 KJ = 0.41496 1. INSTALLATION COST = $ 35,000 SALVAGE VALUE = $ 0 2. REPAIR COST/ACC $ SU= 2000 SD= 1000 CU= 2000 CD= 1000 F= 1000 3. MAINTENANCE COST/YR = $ 100 4. PRESENT WORTH = $ 88,590 ANNUALIZED $ 10,600 ACCIDENT COST = $ 52,310 ANNUALIZED $ 6,259 HIGHWAY DEPT. COST = $ 36,280 ANNUALIZED $ 4,341 O CHANGE OR ACCESS: INPUT ITEM NUM. OR FUNCTION KEY (SEE BELOW) PLUS ENTER. PRINT STORE RECALL HELP GLOBAL SI v $ DIR SI DEF GRAPH QUIT

  17. Reduction in Accident Costs ROADSIDE 5.0 Condition 1 Acc. Costs 1 Condition 2 Acc. Costs 2 Reduction in Accident Costs

  18. Questions ?

More Related