270 likes | 502 Views
Syria and US Foreign Policy. Idean Salehyan Associate Professor of Political Science University of North Texas. Outline. Background Understanding the Syrian war US responses and policy options. Syria Background. Demography: 22.5 Million people Ethnicity: 90% Arab, 9% Kurdish
E N D
Syria and US Foreign Policy Idean Salehyan Associate Professor of Political Science University of North Texas
Outline • Background • Understanding the Syrian war • US responses and policy options
Syria Background • Demography: • 22.5 Million people • Ethnicity: 90% Arab, 9% Kurdish • Religion: 74% Sunni Islam; 16% Alawi & Shia; 10% Christian • History: • Ottoman Empire • WWI, French Mandate • Independence in 1946
Syria Background • 1963 Ba’athist coup • Hafez al-Assad rise to power, 1971 • Involvement in Lebanon • Relationship with Hezbollah • Muslim Brotherhood Challenge • 1982 Hama Massacre Hafez al-Assad
BashAr Al-Assad • Born September 11, 1965 • Studied medicine in the UK • Groomed to be president after death of brother • Assumes office, 2000 after father’s death • Remains close to Iran, Hezbollah • Shia ‘revival’
Arab spring • Peaceful “revolutions” • Tunisia, Egypt, Yemen (partial) • Successful repression • Bahrain • Violent revolution • Libya • Civil war • Syria • Sectarian nature of the conflict
Beginnings of Syrian Unrest • 15 March, 2011. Protests in Damascus, Aleppo, and Daraa. • Repression/imprisonment • Promises of some reform • Failure of Arab League and UN peace plans • 25 April, 2011, Siege of Daraa. Hundreds killed • Military desertions. • Armed clashes begin in June.
Opposition forces • Free Syrian Army. Military defectors, led by Colonel Riad al-Asaad • Estimates between 10,000-25,000 troops • Not a unified movement • Local defense groups • Al-Nusra Front • Foreign Jihadists • Kurdish Militias • Syrian National CouncilSyrian National Coalition
Sectarian conflict • Conflict has taken increasingly sectarian tone • Assad loyalists include Alawites and Christians • Fighting for survival • Opposition forces largely Sunni Arab • Secular/moderate forces • Radical Jihadists • Kurdish militias
International Spillover • 1.3 Million refugees • Jordan: 420,000 • Lebanon: 200,000 • Turkey: 300,000 • Iraq: 100,000
US response • “For the sake of the Syrian people, the time has come for President Assad to step aside.” • President Obama, August 18, 2011. • “Military intervention at this point could hinder humanitarian operations… embroil the United States in a significant, lengthy and uncertain military commitment… bringing the United States into a broader regional conflict or proxy war.” • -Chuck Hegel, US Sec of Defense. April 13, 2013
US RESPONSE • Policy debate over arming the rebels • Strategic ambivalence: “Assad must go, but…” • Humanitarian and non-lethal aid only • Working through US allies in region • No military action • Difficulties of identification • Uncertain outcome
Possible scenarios • Scenario 1 (best case) • Assad steps aside, opposition forces agree on a democratic constitution. UNLIKELY
Possible scenarios • Scenario 2 • Assad’s forces gain the upper hand, crush the insurgency. UNLIKELY
Possible scenarios • Scenario 3 (worst case) • Assad removed from power by force • Fighting between opposition militias, widespread retaliation/cleansing against Alawites • Regional forces drawn in POSSIBLE
Possible scenarios • Scenario 4 • Conflict hits a “stalemate” • Negotiated settlement including a UN force, security guarantees, eventual elections NOT ON THE AGENDA BUT SHOULD BE
US RESPONSE • Time to start thinking about peace plan. • Negotiations including Assad, opposition forces, regional actors, Russia, US. • Potential terms of a deal • Assad steps aside • Power-sharing constitution between Sunnis, Alawites, and Kurds • UN force provides security guarantees, esp for Alawites • Military reintegration