570 likes | 799 Views
Increasing the Throughput of Challenging Assays by Automation. Malcolm Crook Process Analysis & Automation Ltd Farnborough. What is a challenging assay ?. Challenging instrument to automate Physically Software control, no automation interface Multiple PCs required. Why are we doing this.
E N D
Increasing the Throughput of Challenging Assays by Automation Malcolm Crook Process Analysis & Automation Ltd Farnborough
What is a challenging assay ? • Challenging instrument to automate • Physically • Software control, no automation interface • Multiple PCs required
Why are we doing this • Assay Development • Low/High Throughput Screening
Target Assay Hit Evaluation HTS Lead Optimisation Drug Discovery Process • Bioinformatics • Molecular biology • Expression studies • Stable cell generation • Multiple platforms • Multiple readouts • 'Big pharma' systems • Library choice • Potency • Selectivity • Functional effects • Target-related • HERG • Cytotoxicity • Apoptosis • Cell proliferation • CYP450
Requirements for an Assay • High-throughput • Low false-positive rate • Low false-negative rate • Direct measure of function • Good correlation with electrophysiology • Reliability • Reproducibility • Amenable to miniaturization • Low cost
Ion Channels by Atomic Absorption At BioFocus, Cambridge
What is an ion channel ? • assembly of proteins • circular arrangement of proteins • closely packed around water-filled pore • large-pore channels permit • passage of ions • more or less indiscriminate
What is an ion channel ? • archetypal channel pore • one or two atoms wide • conducts a specific species of ion • sodium or potassium • conveyed through membrane single file • fast • access to the pore is governed by a "gate“ • opened or closed by • chemical/electrical signals • Temperature • mechanical force
Non-radiometric ion flux Measuring Ion Channels • Redistribution voltage-dependent dyes • FRET-based technology • Radioligand binding • Automated two-electrode voltage clamp • Automated whole-cell patch clamp • Planar patch clamp • Radiometric ion flux • Non-radiometric ion flux • Radioactive • Cost • Low throughput
Chosen method • Atomic absorption spectrometry • 85Rb+ • Hollow cathode Rubidium lamp • Air/acetylene flame
Advantages of AAS • Health and Safety • Ease of handling • Cost of components • Cost of disposal • Environmental Impact • Sensitivity • No time limits to read samples • Decay or Licence constraints
Flame Monochromator Hollow cathode lamp source Photomultiplier detector Spray chamber and nebulizer Processing electronics Data processing and instrument control Manual Assay
Manual Assay Atomic Absorption Burner Autosampler
Automated Assay Ion Channel Screening • Cells processed using appropriate automation • Supernatants analysed for Ion Content • Single burner system (low throughput) • Multi burner system
SOLAAR S AAS #1 SOLAAR S AAS #2 SOLAAR S AAS #3 SOLAAR S AAS #4 AutoSampler 4 Position #1 AutoSampler 4 Position #2 AutoSampler 4 Position #3 AutoSampler 4 Position #4 Automated Platform: Reader platform initial design Linear Track Robotic arm Operating system e.g. OVERLORD™ Data Processing Activity Base 80 microplate On-line Storage All equipment “off the shelf”
Robot Schematic AA #3 AA #2 AA #4 AA #1 bc stacker
What is the challenge for this assay ? • Scheduler has to be flexible to time delays • SOLAAR software-no automation interface • Four AAs required to achieve throughput • Autosampler was not robot friendly • Safety • Data handling/data quality
1. Scheduler needs to be flexible • AA run times not the same • Throughput critical • Error trapping and recovery a necessity
Scheduler control options • Time resolved • Static • Pre-emptive • All decisions are taken before the run starts. i.e. before the “GO” button is pressed • Event driven • Real time • Dynamic • All decisions are taken during the time frame of the run, i.e. once the “GO” button is pressed • Process Analysis & Automation have both !
Time resolved • Advantages: • one or more accurate timings are guaranteed • easy to set up • Disadvantages • inflexible • decisions can not be taken during the run • error recovery more difficult
Event Driven • Advantages: • flexible • decisions can be taken during the run • error recovery easy • Disadvantages • accurate timings are more difficult to set up • two accurate timings in a run are impossible
real-time OVERLORD Workstation pre-emptive OVERLORD Scheduler either Scheduling - the Choice
Real Time Instrument Control Options • Sequential • Round robin
Site computer services Multiple port switch Main controller & Data processing OVERLORD AA#1 instrument control NetLORD node 1 AA#2 instrument control NetLORD node 2 AA#3 instrument control NetLORD node 3 AA#4 instrument control NetLORD node 4 Control system
Cycle AA #1 node Ready ? Load, unload busy, error ? Load plate Run AAS AA #2 node Ready ? Unload plate AA #3 node Ready ? Data Handling Busy AA #4 node Ready ? Error Run complete ? Instrument control – Round Robin Start Run
2. SOLAAR software • Requires automation interface • There isn’t one !!!! • Use the OVERLORD keystroke API • Emulates a user
3. Four AAs required for throughput • Use NetLORD • Remote OVERLORD nodes • Makes control structure easier • Node in 4 states • Ready for load • Ready for unload • Busy • Error state • NetLORD nodes addressed by IP address • Common folders for data transfer • Redundancy
5. Safety Hazards • AAS instrument • Locked room • Air conditioning • Acetylene gas • Only run during the day • Gas detectors • Time out on AAS flames • Robot • Hamilton SWAP stops when touched • Hamilton SWAP can be recovered
6. Data handling/data quality • Barcodes • Data file renaming for integrity • Data transfer to the server • Real time data analysis for quality check
Luminex 100 • Bead based with 100 assays per well • Small sample volume • 1000 samples a day • reproducible
Traditional ELISA 1 measurement/well xMAP technology 100 measurements/well Higher throughput
Analysis method • Beads sucked up past fluorescence source • Fluorescence detected
Microarray Q-PCR ELISA Luminex xMAP Technology Multiplex Throughput Comparison
What is the challenge for this assay ? • Luminex software - no automation interface • Luminex instrument – not robot friendly • Caliper Twister I • Lids
Luminex instrument – not robot friendly • Plate tray only suitable for fingers • Modify the tray with a hacksaw • Software • Version 1.7 no automation interface • Keyboard control possible
Caliper Twister I • Limited control system • OVERLORD has own Twister I control • Lids • Can be a problem • Relidding especially