1 / 18

By Menachem Berry and Ephraim Rosen

Siman H a’asoi L i’dareis. By Menachem Berry and Ephraim Rosen. RABBA. Lo Hava Siman Halacha is Shelo. RAVA. Havai SimanHalachah is: public property: Chayuv Lehachrez private property: Shelo Below is public property on the right and private property on the left. MAKOM.

vonda
Download Presentation

By Menachem Berry and Ephraim Rosen

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. SimanHa’asoiLi’dareis By Menachem Berry and Ephraim Rosen

  2. RABBA • Lo HavaSiman • Halacha is Shelo

  3. RAVA • HavaiSimanHalachah is: public property: ChayuvLehachrez private property: Shelo • Below is public property on the right and private property on the left

  4. MAKOM • A place

  5. RABBAH • Lo Havai Simon • Halachah is Shelo

  6. RAVA • Havaisiman • Halachah is chayuvlehachriz

  7. ALUMOS • Big bundles

  8. RABBAH • ChayavLehachriz because it’s big and won’t get trampled • So there's a Siman • There’s no Ha’asoiLidarais • So it’s ChayuvLehachriz • Bundle is tall so it won’t get trampled

  9. RAVVA • ChayuvLehachrizbecause it’s heavy and it won’t get moved then you use simanofmakom 10,000 pounds

  10. CrichosBir’shusHayuchid

  11. Rabbah

  12. Rava

  13. Leimacatonoi • how can Rabbi meir hold sheloh and mavirin when the halachah is chayuvlehachriz? He can’t say he argues because we learn it out from his indirect!!

  14. Icahdiamri • Rabbah and ravvah argue by ma’avirin not by simanha’asoilidareis

  15. Rabbah

  16. Ravva

  17. HALACHA • We follow like Rava • RavZevid teaches us we follow like Rava because you learn it from the halacha

More Related