680 likes | 746 Views
September 29, 2014 – Murfreesboro October 2, 2014 – Knoxville October 8, 2014 – Jackson. Tennessee Tobacco Prevention Training. Policy Change Works—Grassroots policy change National Partners: ACS, ALA, AHA QuitLine update Community Project Sharing Mini Grant announcement. Agenda.
E N D
September 29, 2014 – Murfreesboro October 2, 2014 – Knoxville October 8, 2014 – Jackson Tennessee Tobacco Prevention Training
Policy Change Works—Grassroots policy change • National Partners: ACS, ALA, AHA • QuitLine update • Community Project Sharing • Mini Grant announcement Agenda
Funded by Tennessee Department of Health • Website www.tnantitobacco.org • Annual Training • Advocacy • Public Relations Campaign • Promoting the TN QuitLine 1-800-QUITNOW • Technical assistance Services
Dr. Jo Edwards - Director • Gail Hardin, MS, MCHES– Program Manager • Regina Hendon, CPS—West TN • Emmalene Palmer, BS – Middle TN • Keith Shultz, BS, CPS – East TN Staff
Describe the steps in developing a strategy for policy change • Apply the steps to create a plan for policy change • Identify some key national partners for tobacco control • Describe how the TN Tobacco QuitLine works • List some examples of successful local tobacco prevention and cessation projects Learning Objectives
We know what works Sustained funding of comprehensive programs Excise tax increases 100% smoke-free policies Aggressive media campaigns Cessation access Comprehensive advertising restrictions We know what works Source: CDC “Tobacco Control: A Winnable Battle”
When cigarette prices increase, cigarette sales decrease Source: ImpacTeenChartbook: Cigarette Smoking Prevalence and Policies in the 50 States.
Increasing excise taxes increasesprice • 10% increase in cigarette prices 4% drop in adult cigarette consumption • Youth much less likely to start smoking when prices are high • Adjust taxes to offset inflation and tobacco industry attempts to control retail prices • E.g., promotional discounts for retailers who reduce cigarette prices • Tobacco taxes are the single most effective component of a comprehensive tobacco control program Source: CDC “Tobacco Control: A Winnable Battle”
CDC: Smoke-free Policies Save Lives • Prevent heart attacks • Help motivate smokers to quit • Worker safety issue – not “personal nuisance” • All workers deserve equal protection • Only way to protect non-smokers from secondhand smoke • Smoke-free workplace laws don’t hurt business • No trade-off between health and economics Why policy change? Source: CDC “Tobacco Control: A Winnable Battle”
“We are continually faced with great opportunities which are brilliantly disguised as unsolvable problems.” ― Margaret Mead
Policy: any plan or course of action adopted by a government, political party, business, business organization , non-govt org, private group, etc. • Is designed to guide, influence and determine decisions and actions. • Policy Advocacy: the act of generating, influencing, and implementing policy Policy Advocacy vs. Lobbying Source: http://learningcenter.ttac.org/learning/comp02/02_comp.asp
Direct Lobbying happens when you communicate with legislators or government officials involved in legislation and you try to have an impact of the way they act with regards to a specific piece of legislation or ballot initiative • Indirect Lobbying, also called grassroots lobbying is any attempt to influence legislation or impact the results of a ballot initiative by affecting public opinion and calling people to action. Policy Advocacy vs. Lobbying Source: http://learningcenter.ttac.org/learning/comp02/02_comp.asp
Voluntary Policy • Regulatory Policy • Administrative Policy • Legislative Policy Policy
Ask local grocery store and gas station owners to voluntarily remove self-service tobacco machines. • Advocating? • Lobbying? Call community members to ask the to vote “yes” on a new clean indoor policy act recently placed on the ballot. • Advocating? • Lobbying? Advocating or Lobbying? Source: http://learningcenter.ttac.org/learning/comp02/02_comp.asp
Place an ad on a local newspaper’s online site informing the public about the dangers of secondhand smoke • Advocating? • Lobbying? Contact legislators or other government employees to influence votes on pending clean air ordinance. • Advocating? • Lobbying? Advocating or Lobbying? Source: http://learningcenter.ttac.org/learning/comp02/02_comp.asp
Make presentations to community organizations to garner support and endorsements for smoke-free public places. • Advocating? • Lobbying? Send a newsletter on anti-tobacco issues to community members, city councils members & local restaurant owners. • Advocating? • Lobbying? Advocating or Lobbying? Source: http://learningcenter.ttac.org/learning/comp02/02_comp.asp
Midwest Academy www.midwestacademy.com All information that follows is taken from this resource Direct Action Organizing
Based on Self Interest & Relationships • Win real, immediate concrete improvement • Give people a sense of their own power • Alter the relations of power The Basics of DAO
Caring about others • Treating everyone respectfully regardless of status or lack thereof. • Judging not—refuse to talk negatively about others (except for target of your campaign!) Relationships
Forms of Community Organizing Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy Accepts Existing Power Relationship Challenges Existing Power Relationship Direct Service Self-Help Education Advocacy Direct Action
Win real, immediate concrete improvement • Give people a sense of their own power • Alter the relations of power Three Principles of DAO Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
To win a victory on a specific issue • Issue = specific solution to a problem • Power: • Deprive the other side of something it wants • Give the other side something it wants • Elect someone who supports your issues Issue Campaign Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
Often people believe they will win because: • They are right • Truth is on their side • They have the moral high ground • They have the best info & it is spelled correctly • They speak for large numbers of people Illusions about Power Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
“Let’s negotiate” • Invitation to “Stakeholders Meeting” • “I can get you on the Expert Panel” • “Just work it out among yourselves” • “I’m the wrong person” • “This could affect your funding” • “You’re reasonable, but your allies aren’t, can’t we just work with you?” • “I agree with you, but there just isn’t any $” Tricks the other side uses Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
Choose issue and develop strategy • Open communication with the Decision Maker • Announce the campaign • Begin Outreach Activities • Stage Direct encounters with Decision Makers • Build your organization Stages of an Issue Campaign Source: Organizing for Social Change by Midwest Academy
Problem= broad area of concern • Issue = define a solution or partial solution to the problem Analyze the Problem
Result in a real improvement in people’s lives • Make people aware of their own organized power • Alter the relations of power • Be worthwhile • Be winnable • Be widely felt A good issue should…
Be easy to understand • Have a clear decision maker • Have a clear time frame that works for you • Be non-divisive • Build leadership within your organization • Set up your organization for the next campaign • Pocketbook Angle (get people $, save people $) • Be consistent with your org’s values & vision A good issue should… Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
“The best thing you can do is the right thing; the next best thing you can do is the wrong thing; the worst thing you can do is nothing.” - Theodore Roosevelt
Strategy • A method of gaining enough power to make a government or corporate official do something in the public’s interest that he or she does not otherwise wish to do Developing a Strategy Source: Organizing for Social Change, p. 30
It’s always better if the decision-maker voluntarily agrees • Therefore, start with • A contact by phone, email, letter • Meeting & conversation • Explain the facts on your side, how much people need the change, how the change will advance the target’s career Strategy
Long-Term Goals—a vision of what can be accomplished • Intermediate Issue Goals—what you hope to win in this campaign—a solution to the problem • Short-Term Issue Goals—steps toward your Intermediate goals Goals
What resources can your organization contribute? Staff time, Money, etc. • What do you want to get out of the campaign in addition to winning the issue • Visibility? • More partners? • Fundraising? • An organization should come out stronger than before the campaign even if it loses the issue Organizational Considerations Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
Who cares about this? • What could they win or lose? • What power do they have? • How are they organized? Constituents & Allies
Groups, individuals, institutions that stand to lose or be upset if you win • What will your victory cost them? • How actively will they oppose you? • Avoid engaging opponents during the campaign • Don’t hold debates with them unless you expect to win over larger numbers of their base • Put more emphasis on researching opponents’ weaknesses and developing strategies that maximize your strengths Opponents
Always a PERSON • Who can make the decision or strongly influence it? • List all possible people who can give you what you want • List reasons each target has to oppose you as well as to agree with you Targets Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
This column always filled out LAST • Always be connected to the larger strategy • Should be fun! • Should be within the experience of your members, but outside the experience of your targets Tactics
Media Events • Meetings with Elected Officials • Public Hearings • Accountability Sessions • Elections • Negotiations Tactics--Examples Source: Organizing for Social Change, by Midwest Academy
Focused on the Decision-Maker or Secondary Target • Puts power behind a specific demand • Meets your organizational goals as well as your issuegoals • Outside the experience of the target—something they do not expect • Your organization members are comfortable doingthe tactic Criteria for Tactics
Petitions – online or on paper • Letterwriting—send in half to the target, bring the rest with you to present him/her with a big stack of letters • Media Events • TurnoutEvents—the groups that get people coming out are the ones that get attention • 7 calls = 1 “yes” • Get the message to people in at least 3 ways • Face-to-Face Meetings • Come with specific demand • Have 1 back up demand Tactics
Bring 15-25 people • Usually better to meet with elected officials than appointed ones • Geographic & political considerations • DON’T recruit people you don’t really know! • One spokesperson, but introduce everyone and their connection to the issue or to the official • Have a specific demand and a fall back demand Visits with public officials
Attending an Official Hearing • Your OWN public hearing Hearings