150 likes | 385 Views
Why Conduct a Survey?. Assess the control environmentOpportunity to significantly improve employee performance (up to 30%)Meets" vs. Exceeds" expectationsCommunication (A key internal control)Obtain feedbackConveys that management cares about how the place is being managedOpens up an upward
E N D
1. Employee Survey
NYSICA Meeting
May 26,2005
Mark B. Mitchell, MBA, CIA Why should you pay attention?
Because you are responsible for internal controls or assessing ICs
If a survey is conducted by someone else, say HR for example, you want input and results so you can assess the IC environment.
You may be asked to conduct a surveyWhy should you pay attention?
Because you are responsible for internal controls or assessing ICs
If a survey is conducted by someone else, say HR for example, you want input and results so you can assess the IC environment.
You may be asked to conduct a survey
2. Why Conduct a Survey? Assess the control environment
Opportunity to significantly improve employee performance (up to 30%)
“Meets” vs. “Exceeds” expectations
Communication (A key internal control)
Obtain feedback
Conveys that management cares about how the place is being managed
Opens up an upward dialog
Strengthens communication
Benefits:
Sends a signal to employees that you care.
Who should conduct? Function of Dynamics and Resources
Dynamics
HR
IC Officer
Internal Audit
Resources:
Internal
External:
GOER
Consultants
Benefits:
Sends a signal to employees that you care.
Who should conduct? Function of Dynamics and Resources
Dynamics
HR
IC Officer
Internal Audit
Resources:
Internal
External:
GOER
Consultants
3. Prerequisites Executive level sponsorship
Willing to hear the truth
Willingness to make improvements, based upon the results
Resources to collect and analyze the information
A statistical software package
Time and people to analyze the data Who should conduct? Function of Dynamics and Resources
Dynamics
HR
IC Officer
Internal Audit
Resources:
Internal
External:
GOER
ConsultantsWho should conduct? Function of Dynamics and Resources
Dynamics
HR
IC Officer
Internal Audit
Resources:
Internal
External:
GOER
Consultants
4. Purpose Provide an indication of the characteristics of my agency’s culture. Gauge:
The ethical climate
Employee moral
Employee perceptions of certain manage-ment practices
Provide input into the audit plan. Gauge the following five (of eight) internal control components
Internal Environment
Objective Setting
Event Identification
Risk Assessment
Risk Response
Control Activities
Information and Communication
Monitoring
5. Developing the Survey: Sources
Control Questionnaires
Public surveys
“Business Ethics and Compliance in the Sarbanes-Oxley Era: A Survey by Deloitte and Corporate Board Member Magazine”
NASACT Teleconference, Nov. 3, 2004
GOER handout, HR White papers
Business guides on employee morale (www.bguides.com)
6. Survey Reliability
Reliability calculation
Cronbach’s Alpha - > .80 is good
7. Survey Background 704 employees responded to the survey Response Rate 80% Of the 704 employees 528 (75%) Indicated their program area 633 (90%) Indicated who they report to 493 (70%) Indicated years employed at my agency