1 / 9

PC 37.100.1 Common Requirements

PC 37.100.1 Common Requirements. Working Group Meeting May 9, 2004. Bill. Bergman Stan Billings Anne Bosma Ted Burse Pete Dwyer Leslie Falkingham Larry Farr Bill Long. Larry McCall Frank Muench Ed Peters Hugh Ross Mel Smith Dave Stone, Chair Alan Storms Chuck Wagner.

zachary-rivas
Download Presentation

PC 37.100.1 Common Requirements

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. PC 37.100.1Common Requirements Working Group Meeting May 9, 2004 IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  2. Bill. Bergman Stan Billings Anne Bosma Ted Burse Pete Dwyer Leslie Falkingham Larry Farr Bill Long Larry McCall Frank Muench Ed Peters Hugh Ross Mel Smith Dave Stone, Chair Alan Storms Chuck Wagner Working Group Members IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  3. Ballot Results July 26, 2004 March 28, 2005 • Number in Ballot Group: 154 154 • Affirmative 84 103 • Negative 38 21 • Abstention 4 7 Returns 126 82% 131 85% • Affirmative 84 69% 103 83% • Negative3831% 20 17% • 122 123 IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  4. Ballot Comment Summary ReceivedReview ResolvedOpen • Editorial: 284 57% 244 40 • General 5 1% 3 2 • Unclassified 15 3% 12 3 • Technical 19839% 73 125 • Total: 502 100% 332 170 IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  5. Guiding Principles for Std Include some tutorial material • Some concepts are new to the IEEE community. • More explanation would be beneficial • Place in main text, in footnotes, or in annex J IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  6. Guiding Principles for Std Minimum Req’ts Vs. “Stretch” Req’ts • Standard should reflect the “common” requirements? • In some cases a “Stretch” goal? -- Examples: • Solar radiation level 2.1.2.b) • Normal wind velocity 2.1.2.f) IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  7. Guiding Principles for Std Let’s not overload the ship with too much baggage on its maiden voyage. IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  8. 332 “Resolved” Comments • The spreadsheet was sent out to all members of the WG on May 1. • Chairman asked WG to Agree or comment on the “resolutions” of this group of comments so we can move on. IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

  9. 170 “Open” Comments • 45 topics were up for review • Most were reviewed, discuss and tentatively resolved at meeting • Some were remanded to the WG after some introduction IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY / SWITCHGEAR COMMITTEE

More Related