1 / 24

Final Valuation Catalog & Mail order houses industry Matt Lynch

Final Valuation Catalog & Mail order houses industry Matt Lynch. Presentation Outline. Brief Overview of Company Segment Growth Acquisitions Forecast Assumptions and Results Buy/Sell/Hold Recommendation Quick Summary of Carl Icahn Battle. eBay. 3 Business Segments Marketplace

zuzana
Download Presentation

Final Valuation Catalog & Mail order houses industry Matt Lynch

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Final Valuation Catalog & Mail order houses industry Matt Lynch

  2. Presentation Outline Brief Overview of Company Segment Growth Acquisitions Forecast Assumptions and Results Buy/Sell/Hold Recommendation Quick Summary of Carl Icahn Battle

  3. eBay • 3 Business Segments • Marketplace • eBay.com • StubHub.com and other small websites • Payments • PayPal • Bill Me Later • Marketing, Classifieds, Advertising Services • eBay Enterprises

  4. How does eBay grow? • Total Net Revenue Growth of 14% • Marketplaces • 12% revenue growth • Increase in GMV: total value of all successfully closed items between users in Marketplace trading platforms • Payments • 19% revenue growth • Increase in TPV: dollar vol. of payments successfully completed on networks • Enterprises • 3% revenue growth – increase in Merchandise Sales (technologies) • Newest segment – highly seasonality

  5. Acquisition of GSI Commerce • Closed deal on June 17, 2011 for $2.4b in cash & debt • Seen as a way to challenge Amazon • Problem: Divested large chunks of GSI • Financials near impossible to adequately combine • More realistic to use growth rates from 2012 to 2013 only • Aligned with many analysts’ predictions • Rebranded to eBay Enterprises

  6. How to handle other acquisitions? • Buying small tech companies is part of eBay’s business model • “We expect to continue to purchase assets & businesses” • Many are private = lack of F/S info • Majority financed by cash • Acquired Braintree in late 2013 for $713m • Price allocation still not complete • Summary: Most acquisitions do not effect F/S comparability/valuation

  7. Forecast Assumptions • Sales Growth • Latest conference call projected 12%-16% over the next 4 years • Valueline projects 14.5% over the next 5 years • YahooFinance projects 13.5% %growth over the next 5 years

  8. Forecast Assumption • Conclusion: • 2014-2018: 14% • 2019: 12% • 2020: 10% • 2021: 7.5% • 2022: 5.5% • 2023: 5.5% • Thereafter: 5% • Compared to S&P 500, analysts project much higher growth rates for the industry and eBay

  9. Other Assumptions • Expenses • Kept most expenses as a % of Revenue • % of Revenue has been pretty consistent over the years • Balance Sheet Items • Used % of revenue from previous two years to estimate future

  10. Steps to Forecast • Calculate future growth rates • Forecast each line item for Balance Sheet and Income Statement • Calculate Enterprise Profit Margin and Enterprise Asset Turnover Forecasts • Use Common Size Analysis (% of Sales) • Calculate Enterprise Value using 3 models • Adjust for Date • Make Recommendation

  11. Forecasting I/S

  12. Calculate EPM Forecasted EPM initially decreased but recovered as steady state approached

  13. Calculate EATO

  14. 3 Valuation Models Sales Growth after 2023 = 5% WACC = 10.1% from Bloomberg

  15. DCF

  16. REI

  17. AGR

  18. Adjusting Date of Value Estimate Estimated Value using 12/31/13 Balance Sheet Date Adjust to Today (4/23/14): V(4/23/14) = V(12/31/13)*(1+r(ent))(113/365) V(4/23/14) = 58,363*(1+.101)(113/365) V(4/23/14) = $60,128 Mid-Year Adjustment: $60,128 * (1+.101)(0.5) =$63,091

  19. Comparison to the Market Value Enterprise Value Price per Share Market Cap: $71,180M Less NFAs: $(9,552) Enterprise Value: $62,257 My Valuation: $63,091 Undervalued by $834m My Valuation: $63,091 Plus NFAs: $9,552 Equity Value: $72,643 Shares Outstanding: 1,294m Calculated Price per Share: $56.14 Opening Price Today: $55.47

  20. Recommendation Hold “Patient investor may find more attractive entry point in coming years” - Valueline

  21. Quick Quick Summary of Carl Icahn • In February, Icahn started writing letters demanding PayPal and eBay split • Openly attacked management’s competence • Said potential of PayPal is being restricted • Which means a loss of $ for shareholders • Failed attempts to gain Board members

  22. Quick Quick Summary of Carl Icahn eBay held strong on its position Icahn backed down on position 2 weeks ago, reached truce on proxy fight Did it effect eBay’s value? Is Icahn right? Is the fight really over? How would a split affect eBay?

  23. Thank you! Questions?

More Related