1 / 21

The News Ombudsman today and tomorrow ONO annual conference Stockholm, May 29, 2008

Profile and activity of newspaper ombudsmen: an international overview. The News Ombudsman today and tomorrow ONO annual conference Stockholm, May 29, 2008. Cristina Elia European Journalism Observatory Università della Svizzera italiana, Lugano, Switzerland.

Mia_John
Download Presentation

The News Ombudsman today and tomorrow ONO annual conference Stockholm, May 29, 2008

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Profile and activity of newspaper ombudsmen:an international overview The News Ombudsman today and tomorrowONO annual conferenceStockholm, May 29, 2008 Cristina Elia European Journalism Observatory Università della Svizzera italiana, Lugano, Switzerland

  2. WHO: ombudsmen who have been appointed voluntarily by newspapers in the • European sphere • Anglo-Saxon sphere • Latin Sphere • WHEN: data collected May – June 2006 • WHY: to have introductory empirical data on the state of the art of the profession at an international level • LIMITS: questionnaire • COMPARISON WITH PAST STUDIES: Ettema & Glasser, Papirno, Nemeth • ADVANTAGES: provide the context, compare different realities, identify trends INTRODUCTION & INTERNATIONAL OVERVIEW

  3. Questionnaire response rate: 57% INTRODUCTION & INTERNATIONAL OVERVIEW

  4. Profile Similarities: • 9 ombudsmen out of 10 are former journalists • 9 ombudsmen out of 10 work for just one newspaper (exception: Switzerland) • There are differences in other variables: • Age: Europeans are noticeably older (year of birth, mean: 1940) • Gender: gender equality is reached only in the Anglo-Saxon sphere. Evolution of the Anglo-Saxon sphere in the last 20 years: 1985 2006 PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  5. % ofemployment Anglo-Saxon sphere European sphere Latin sphere PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  6. Visibility / communication with the public European sphere Columns Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere Latin & Anglo-Saxon spheres: good visibility European sphere: room for improvement (more than 20% do not write a column, lower frequency) PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  7. Visibility / communication with the public European sphere • meetings with community groups (visibility) Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  8. Visibility / communication with the public PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  9. New technologies Number of e-mails per day PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  10. Presence in the newsroom / communication with journalists PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  11. European sphere • Participation in newsroom meetings Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere PROFILE& COMMUNICATION

  12. Self-assessment and possible improvements • Authority European sphere Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere SELF-ASSESSMENT& IMPROVEMENTS

  13. Self-assessment and possibleimprovements • Independence European sphere Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere SELF-ASSESSMENT& IMPROVEMENTS

  14. Self-assessment and possible improvements • Visibility European sphere Anglo-Saxon sphere Latin sphere SELF-ASSESSMENT& IMPROVEMENTS

  15. Self-assessment and possibleimprovements Possible improvements (chosen from 20 possible changes) • Do more reader outreach • Set up a blog or chat to interact with readers • Make the position more visible in the community • Have power to order a correction • Get a secretary or assistant to help manage calls SELF-ASSESSMENT& IMPROVEMENTS

  16. Tosummarize • The ombudsman’s role of mediation is achieved in all the spheres. • We have seen an Anglo-Saxon sphere where ombudsmen not only perform a role of mediator, but also that of “coach” and promoter of public discussions on journalism issues. • Generally, Anglo-Saxons have more visibility and tend to exploit their channels of communication with readers and with the newsroom better. CONCLUSIONS & NEW TRENDS

  17. To summarize In the European sphere there is room for improvement (even if this depends on how they see their own role): • An essential would be to increase the % of employment; • Increase visibility (for 40% of them this is only sufficient) • Increase the frequency of contacts with readers (columns, meeting with groups of readers, and also using new technologies)  to perform their role of “public conscience” better • Increase the frequency of contacts with journalists (internal memos, newsroom meetings)  to perform also their coaching role CONCLUSIONS & NEW TRENDS

  18. Switzerland: • characteristics • 1981: Tribune de Genève, 1st European newspaper ombudsman? (Daniel Cornu) • last year 2 ombudsman were “lost” (24 Heures & Le Matin) because the Édipresse group decided to centralize and have 1 ombudsman for its many newspapers. STRONG & UNIQUE TREND: most newspaper ombudsmen now work for editorial groups, not for single newspapers. New trends in Central Europe CONCLUSIONS & NEW TRENDS

  19. Germany: new interest • 1 newspaper ombudsman (Main Post, since 2004) • Lately: many articles in professional reviews • April 2008: "IQ - Initiative Qualität im Journalismus" promoted a campaign entitled Seven good reasons for ombudsmen in the media New trends in Central Europe CONCLUSIONS & NEW TRENDS

  20. France 2006-2008 (in addition to the existing ones): • Paris-Normandie • France-Antilles group • L’Est républicain • L’Express • Le Parisien - Aujourd’hui en France • + creation of the Club des médiateurs de la presse française New trends in Central Europe CONCLUSIONS & NEW TRENDS

  21. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION & COOPERATION!

More Related