200 likes | 219 Views
Cisgenesis, a New Tool for Plant Breeding, Should be Exempted from the Regulation on Genetically Modified Organisms. Dr. Victor Polanco C. Plant Biotechnology-Plant Breeding. Plant Biotechnology. “in vitro” Techniques Micropropagation Plant Regeneration Genetic Modification.
E N D
Cisgenesis, a New Tool for Plant Breeding, Should be Exempted from the Regulation on Genetically Modified Organisms. Dr. Victor Polanco C.
Plant Biotechnology-Plant Breeding Plant Biotechnology • “in vitro” Techniques • Micropropagation • Plant Regeneration • Genetic Modification • Genomics Techniques • Genetic maps with molecular marker • Marker assisted selection • Sequencing of whole genomes • Isolation of particular genes Identification of genes • No-crossables species (Transgenes; Virus y bacteria) • Crops species of from crossables wild plant species (Cisgenes)
Genetic Modification Of Plant • Transgenesis • Strict regulationes in all world (as described in Europe in EU Directive 2001/18/EC); Based on introduction of transgenes. • Opposition of organic farmers • Negative public perception of genetic modification • Transgenes
Consumer Acceptance Of Genetically Modified Crops Attitude of consumers in USA; showed that the respondents would eat: i) vegetables with an extra gene from the same species (81%) ii) or from another vegetable species (61%) iii) while this was only 14% in case viral genes had been used. (Lusk and Sullivan, 2002). • EU-project entitled ‘Sustainable production of transgenic strawberry plants. Ethical consequences and potential effect on producers, environment and consumers’ (2003). 720 consumers in Norway, Denmark and the UK. .
New Developments in Transformation Technology Consumer-Friendly Genetically Modified Organisms Wageningen University, The Netherland Dr. Henk Schouten • Cisgenesis Health promoting apple (MdMYB10). See www.cisgenesis.com
Definition Cisgenesis is a genetic modification with one or more alleles from a sexually compatible donor plant. The inserted gene should • be under control of its native promoter. • contain its own introns and terminator. • So: one complete copy of genomic DNA. • No foreign genes, such as bacterial genes • Without selection genes coding for antibiotic and herbicide resistance. • Same genes as in classical breeding. • No linkage drag.
Classical Breeding-Cisgenesis Classical Breeding • No-linkage drag • No-transgenes • Simple step • Easy and fast
Cisgenesis Steps: • Isolate target gene (or allele) from donor plant • Bring this gene into a high quality cultivar (genetic modification) • Evaluate the cisgenic plants
Incorporation of Cisgenesis Technology to Chile-INIA • Project: DEVELOPMENT OF CISGENIC APPLES WITH RESISTANCE TO Venturia inaequalis: INCORPORATION OF CISGENESIS TECHNOLOGY TO CHILE (2008-2011). • Fund • Consorcio de la Fruta. • Wageningen University and Research Center. • CONICYT. • Object Genes Vf1 Vf2 y Vf4 PRIMA “Variedad resistente a venturia” Royal Gala Granny Smith Nueva Variedad Resistente a Venturia
Bring this gene into a high quality cultivar pMF1 Promotor Genes Vf Terminator “Clean Vector Systems”
Genetic Transformation of Apples (Granny Smith and Royal Gala)
Why cisgenesis? • Strong reduction of fungicides • In apple approx. 80 % of chemicals for crop protection against fungi • In wild apples many natural resistance genes present • Cisgenesis uses these natural genes for reduction of chemicals Cisgenesis utilizes natural resistance of plants
Why cisgenesis? • Gain of time • Introduction of a gene from a wild apple plant • through classical breeding: approx 50 years. • through cisgenesis: approx 5 years, if the gene is isolated • Fast introduction of multiple genes for durable resistance is feasible. Cisgenesis gains time
Why cisgenesis? • Specific • Only wanted alleles are introduced. No unwanted or unknown alleles (no linkage drag) • Original genetic make-up of the high quality cultivar is maintained. One or a few genes added. Important for self-incompatible plants, such as apple, pear, strawberry, banana, potato, and so on. Cisgenesis: intelligent breeding
Why cisgenesis? • At least as safe as classical breeding, Only well known genes added • No foreign or unwanted genes • Cisgenesis respects natural crossing borders in the creation • Consumers generally prefer cisgenesis to transgenesis Cisgenic plants are at least as safe as classically bred plants Cisgenesis is the result of listening to ethical arguments and preferences
Regulation Chile • Cisgenesis uses genetic modification as a tool. • Therefore regarded as GM in Regulation. • Resolution 1523/2001: Transgenic=Cisgenic.
Frequently Raised Issue by Opponents: • Unpredictable insertion site • Unknown expression level • Possible knockout of a functional gene • Solution: make a series of plants (events), and test them thoroughly. Discard plants with unwanted symptoms.
Conclusions • Why cisgenesis? • Natural genes from the crop species itself • Gain of time • Durable disease resistance for strong reduction of chemicals • High quality cultivar maintained • Gene flow to wild vegetations or crops no issue ???? • Preferred by consumers compared to transgenesis