E N D
1. 8/7/2012 Detecting & Preventing Fraud in Accounts Payable Robert H. Sells
Broniec Associates
2. 8/7/2012 Fraud is the fastest growing crime segment in America Our task is to harden the target by using every tool and every skill and every expert at our disposal.
3. 8/7/2012 Our goal has to be to prevent fraud in each of our accounts payable departments. Hiring
Training
Auditing
Securing
Observing
Managing
4. 8/7/2012 Case Studies The Charlotte Observer
$2 Million - 7 Yrs.
Collusion
22-year employee
WebMD
$65,000
1 instance (attempted)
Caught by Accounts Payable !
5. 8/7/2012 Clues, Rules Broken, & Lessons Learned in The Charlotte Observer case Johnson ordered, received, &
approved payment of goods
Budget variances ignored - $50,000/mo. over 7 yrs.!
6. 8/7/2012 Clues, Rules Broken, & Lessons Learned in The Charlotte Observer case Rising costs not suspected business was good
Poor inventory controls Lots of receipts, no product
7. 8/7/2012
8. 8/7/2012
9. 8/7/2012 What went wrong? Systems
People
Procedures
Discipline
Masking
Collusion
Management
10. 8/7/2012 How much control is enough? Too much? Your department has to operate efficiently
People are not the enemy
Be firm, fair, and friendly
Why not the best?
11. 8/7/2012 Who else can help? Your bank
Your internal auditors
Your IT department
Your associates
Your systems & procedures
Your check printer
Your external Audit Professionals
12. 8/7/2012 Your Bank Positive Pay
One of the MOST effective fraud deterrents
Whatever it costs, get it!
13. 8/7/2012 Your Internal Auditors Consistent
Thorough
Observant
14. 8/7/2012 Your IT Department IT is there to serve Users not the other way around
Request ad hoc reports and use them
You are in charge of A/P not them
15. 8/7/2012 Your Associates Respect Intuition
Listen to your associates
Talk to your associates
16. 8/7/2012 Your Systems & Procedures Review the settings of your system periodically
Guard your vendor master
Review your checks Every time !
Mix high tech with high touch
17. 8/7/2012 Your check printer Be aware of & use the latest innovations
Have an external expert review your systems, procedures, and check stock
Question everything
18. 8/7/2012 Your External Audit Professionals Let the experts review your operation
Statistical analysis
Dr. Frank Benford & Benfords Law
Dr. Mark Nigrini
The Frank Factor
19. 8/7/2012