1 / 24

Enhancing CSO Influence on Policy

Enhancing CSO Influence on Policy. CIVICUS Workshop Glasgow, June 2006. Julius Court & Vanessa Weyrauch. Why this matters?. CSOs are important players in development … … but, acting alone, their impact is limited in scope, scale and sustainability.

Download Presentation

Enhancing CSO Influence on Policy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Enhancing CSO Influence on Policy CIVICUS Workshop Glasgow, June 2006 Julius Court & Vanessa Weyrauch

  2. Why this matters? • CSOs are important players in development … • … but, acting alone, their impact is limited in scope, scale and sustainability. • There is more potential for partnership. • Many development challenges remain. • CSOs increasingly involved in policy engagement. • The credibility and legitimacy of CSO involvement is questioned.

  3. Workshop Outline • Introduction • Case Study from Argentina • Discussion: CSOs and policy influence – challenges and opportunities. • CSOs and Policy Influence: Recent Evidence • Discussion: How to do it - experiences & lessons. • Close

  4. Self Introductions. • 1 minute!

  5. Influencing the Educational Budget: CIPPEC´s work in a Southern province in Argentina Vanesa Weyrauch Av. Callao 25, 1° • C1022AAA Buenos Aires, Argentina - Tel: (54 11) 4384-9009 • Fax: (54 11) 4371-1221 • info@cippec.org • www.cippec.org

  6. CIPPEC as organisation • CIPPEC as an organisation in evolution: hybrid between focus on research, advocacy, monitoring and implementation. • Initial institutional funding enabled the selection of the research topic and methodology. • Multidisciplinary team with clear and legitimised leadership. • Experience from the civil society standpoint: capacity building, monitoring and influence through alliances with CSOs. • Experience from the politics standpoint: advice and implementation with provincial governments.

  7. Research at CIPPEC • Project “The educational provinces”: a comparative analysis of the implementation of the Federal Education Law in the 24 jurisdictions. • Creation of an external international Advisory Council to ensure quality and reputation. • Selection of a differential focus (provincial level) and based on a milestone of the policy under study (10 years after implementation). • Participatory approach: engagement of all stakeholders. Consensus building to identify potential reforms.

  8. Research at CIPPEC • Intensive follow up of media coverage to assess prevailing discourses. • Detection and analysis of all related policy proposals. • Translation of findings into a clear and simple format (rankings, indexes, etc.) • Use of language of policymakers: get to understand them. Face to face interaction.

  9. The context • Argentina as a federal country: the double level of decision making processes. • Political rationality in the provinces: education perceived by policymakers as a weight and a problem. • Lack of social participation in the educational policies. • Different political settings derived from a federal system that required diverse intervention strategies.

  10. Influence strategies • Legitimisation: the risk of the “foreigner”: the comparative look and academic rigour as key endorsements. • Capacity building: two handbooks on how to influence the educational budget and the social investment in children. • Policy debate: active participation in the diverse stages of the discussion and sanction of the Education Financing Law.

  11. Influence strategies • Media campaign: dissemination of the provincial report through local media and partnership with a local CSO. • Combined and staged process: a window of opportunity with the change of a government accused of corruption and arrival of “fresh air”. • Complexity of the measure: TDF is the province with higher investment on education per student and lower budgetary effort for education (paradox of the coparticipation).

  12. Evidence: key data

  13. The impact • High impact in media, policymakers and educational sectors: awareness of the urgent need to adddress budgetary issues. • Hired by the new Minister of Education to provide advice. • Draft of a law for investment in education. Governor refuses to committ. Mingled actors and steps. • The initiative is welcome by part of the oposition in the provincial Congress (ARI). Unpredictable alliances: changes in power. • Sanction of a law to increase investment in education (reach 25% increase in 4 years).

  14. Some lessons… • Influencing public policies implies interrupting chaotic, complex, unpredictable processes. • The double thrust of interrupting and walking along the forces in the decision making processes. • Work with a double perspective: the comparison brought by a foreigner and alliances with organisations with local knowledge. • Dialogue with all stakeholders, find a niche in discourse. • Challenge: fulfilment of laws in unstable legal domains. • Secure long term funding: processes are long and unexpected opportunities arise.

  15. Any questions about the case?

  16. Discussion: CSO and Policy • Group work • What are the main enabling factors? • What are the main barriers?

  17. Linear model Too close for comfort, Edwards Impact & Effectiveness, Fowler ‘Context, evidence, links’, RAPID Policy narratives, Roe CSO legitimacy, L. David Brown Links and Learning, Gaventa ‘Room for manoeuvre’, Clay & Schaffer ‘Street level bureaucrats’, Lipsky Policy as experiments, Rondinelli Policy Streams & Windows, Kingdon Disjointed incrementalism, Lindquist Tipping point model, Gladwell Mercenaries, missionaries and revolutionaries, Malena ‘Non-Western?’, Lewis Global Civil Society, Salamon, Kaldor Types of Engagement, Coston Linear model of communication, Shannon ‘Space’ for thought & action, Howell Simple and surprising stories, Communication Theory Provide solutions, Marketing Theory I Find the right packaging, Marketing II Global Civil Society?, Keane Global Legitimacy, van Rooy Epistemic communities, Haas Policy entrepreneurs, Najam Advocacy coalitions, Keck & Sikkink Negotiation through networks, Sabattier Social capital, Coleman Accountability, OneWorld Trust Communication for social change, Rockefeller Foundation Wheels and webs, Chapman & Fisher CSOs & Policy: Literature www.odi.org.uk/rapid/lessons/theory

  18. CSOs, Evidence, Policy, Impact

  19. Main Barriers to Engagement CSOs • Capacity (62%) • Funding (57%) • Process kn (48%) (CSO evidence not seen as credible) Policy Processes • Not open (47%) • Corrupt • No capacity to use evidence

  20. Discussion: Support for CSOs • What more can CSOs do to influence policy processes? • What kind of support would help you influence policy more?

  21. Problems and Solutions

  22. Needs for Effective Policy Engagement • Training (59%) • Latest thinking (55%) • More research (52%)

  23. Specific Tools Overarching Tools - The RAPID Framework - Using the Framework - The Entrepreneurship Questionnaire Context Assessment Tools - Stakeholder Analysis - Forcefield Analysis - Writeshops - Policy Mapping - Political Context Mapping Communication Tools - Communications Strategy - SWOT analysis - Message Design - Making use of the media Research Tools - Case Studies - Episode Studies - Surveys - Bibliometric Analysis - Focus Group Discussion Policy Influence Tools - Influence Mapping & Power Mapping - Lobbying and Advocacy - Campaigning: A Simple Guide - Competency self-assessment

  24. Further Information Julius Court jcourt@odi.org.uk Vanessa Weyrauch vweyrauch@cippec.org www.odi.org.uk/rapid www.cippec.org

More Related