1 / 12

An Evaluation of the Individual Training Account & Eligible Training Provider Demonstration

An Evaluation of the Individual Training Account & Eligible Training Provider Demonstration. Prepared by: Social Policy Research Associates Under Subcontract to: Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. Background The Demonstration Project. About the ITA/ETP Grantees

Download Presentation

An Evaluation of the Individual Training Account & Eligible Training Provider Demonstration

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. An Evaluation of the Individual Training Account & Eligible Training Provider Demonstration Preparedby: Social Policy Research Associates Under Subcontract to: Mathematica Policy Research, Inc.

  2. BackgroundThe Demonstration Project • About the ITA/ETP Grantees • 13 grantees (states and LWIAs) funded by USDOL for ITA/ETP system development • About the Evaluation • Two rounds of multi-day site visits to 28 local workforce areas in 13 states • Discussions with grant managers, line staff, administrators, vendors & ITA-holders • Final Report issued Dec 2004(http://www.doleta.gov/reports/searcheta/occ

  3. Policies Regarding ITAs:State/Local Emphasis on Training • Limited use of training at the start of WIA • Start-up issues and confusion about ITAs • Low demand for training in hot economy • Training levels have since rebounded, and ITAs are strongly embraced • Some local areas continue to see a strong role for contract and customized training

  4. Policies Regarding ITAs:Helping Customers Make Training Choices • Emphasis on customer choice predominates • Flexibility in how customers move through service levels • Case managers act as facilitators • Sites promote an “informed choice” model • Some assessment and/or field research on training occupations and vendors is nearly always required of ITA holders

  5. Policies Regarding ITAs:Limits on Customers’ Choices • Median cap on ITA amount is about $5,000 • Yet caps vary widely across local areas • Low of about $1,700 • High of $10,000 • Time limits are usually 1 or 2 years • Different ways of defining “demand occupations” • Reliance on formal lists • Local counselor discretion

  6. Developing the ETP ListRequirements & Procedures for Eligibility • Aggressive efforts to recruit vendors • Procedures to streamline application process • Having vendors submit to a state clearinghouse • Allowing for electronic submissions • Few requirements for initial eligibility, beyond state licensure • Substantial start-up and on-going costs

  7. Developing the ETP ListRequirements for Subsequent Eligibility • The start of subsequent eligibility was often deferred • Performance requirements for vendors for subsequent eligibility vary widely, in: • Number of measures to meet • Thresholds on the individual measures

  8. Developing the ETP ListDefinitions and Data Capture • Definitions of key terms vary markedly or are vaguely defined • e.g., what counts as a program, a completer, employment • Procedures for data capture also vary • Most states rely on centralized UI matching for measuring employment outcomes • Some also attempt matches with post-secondary enrollment files to measure program completion • But some states require vendors to self-report all items

  9. Quality of the Consumer Report System • Dramatic progress in developing CRS • CRS systems vary in sophistication & ease of use • Beyond basic searches on program type & vendor location, some allow searches on cost, whether ITA approved, accessibility, etc. • Beyond basic program/vendor info, some provide much more (e.g., class sizes, waiting periods, admission requirements, teaching method, etc.) • Performance data are usually very spotty • At least at the state level, there is usually ample choice • Public institutions generally constitute a minority of vendors but a majority of programs • Choice is often very limited in rural areas

  10. Vendor Reactions • Public institutions • Provide high-quality, low-cost training resource • Many balk at the ETP performance and reporting requirements, as ITAs constitute a tiny part of their business • Many perceive their mission broadly and eschew a narrow focus on employment outcomes • Proprietary schools • Generally embrace the ITA system; very market driven and some aggressively pursue ITAs as a source of new business • Are generally very focused on employment outcomes • Community-based organizations • Have often relied heavily on contract training • Are finding it hard to compete in an ITA system • Low capitalization puts them at high risk

  11. Summary and Conclusions • ITA Issues • Use of training has rebounded from initially low levels • ITAs are strongly embraced • Substantial local-area variability in ITA policies • A focus on customer choice and empowerment is very evident • An “informed choice” model predominates • Some local areas continue to see a strong role for contract and customized training

  12. Summary and Conclusions (concluded) • ETP Issues • Some vendors balk at ETP requirements, undermining customer choice • Eligibility and data requirements for vendors vary enormously • Consumer Report Systems • Dramatic progress in on-line systems • Performance data are spotty

More Related