1 / 36

Clinical Relevance of HLA Epitope Antigenicity and Immunogenicity

Clinical Relevance of HLA Epitope Antigenicity and Immunogenicity. Rene Duquesnoy University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. Matching: The Traditional Way. Count the number of A, B, DR antigen mismatches Why do so many zero-antigen mismatches fail? Why are many mismatches successful?

elga
Download Presentation

Clinical Relevance of HLA Epitope Antigenicity and Immunogenicity

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Clinical Relevance of HLA Epitope Antigenicity and Immunogenicity Rene Duquesnoy University of Pittsburgh Medical Center

  2. Matching: The Traditional Way • Count the number of A, B, DR antigen mismatches • Why do so many zero-antigen mismatches fail? • Why are many mismatches successful? • Determine unacceptable mismatches for highly sensitized patients • Why do see so many graft failures? • Why are many patients never transplanted? • Crossreactive antigen matching for platelet transfusions of refractory thrombocytopenic patients • Why are so many such transfusions unsuccessful? • Why do some non-crossreactive mismatches work so well?

  3. Important Consideration Differentiate between Antigenicity of epitopes (reactivity with antibodies) and Immunogenicity of epitopes (induction of specific antibodies)

  4. HLA Mismatch Immunogenicity • Mismatched HLA antigens have different epitope “loads” • HLA epitopes have different degrees of immunogenicity A better understanding of HLA immunogenicity will permit a permissible mismatch strategy for non-sensitized transplant patients

  5. KIDNEY ALLOGRAFT SURVIVAL AND HLA CLASS I MATCHING AT THE AMINO ACID TRIPLET LEVEL Duquesnoy, RJ , Takemoto S, de Lange P, Doxiadis IIN, Schreuder GMT , Persijn, G and Claas FJH: Transplantation 75:884-889, 2003

  6. Effect of HLA-A,B Triplet Mismatching on Graft Survival of Zero-HLA-DR Mismatched Kidneys in Eurotransplant Low epitope “load”

  7. HLAMatchmaker Predicts Antibody Formation to HLA Mismatches

  8. Volume 77(8)             27 April 2004             pp 1236-1239 THE NUMBER OF AMINO ACID TRIPLET DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PATIENT AND DONOR IS PREDICTIVE FOR THE ANTIBODY REACTIVITY AGAINST MISMATCHED HUMAN LEUKOCYTE ANTIGENS Dankers, Marlies K. A; Witvliet, Marian D; Roelen, Dave L; De Lange, Peter; Korfage, Nelleke; Persijn, Guido G.; Duquesnoy, René; Doxiadis, Ilias I. N; Claas, Frans H. J. Department of Immunohematology and Blood Transfusion, Leiden University Medical Center

  9. Volume 77(8)             27 April 2004             pp 1236-1239 THE NUMBER OF AMINO ACID TRIPLET DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PATIENT AND DONOR IS PREDICTIVE FOR THE ANTIBODY REACTIVITY AGAINST MISMATCHED HUMAN LEUKOCYTE ANTIGENS Dankers, Marlies K. A; Witvliet, Marian D; Roelen, Dave L; De Lange, Peter; Korfage, Nelleke; Persijn, Guido G.; Duquesnoy, René; Doxiadis, Ilias I. N; Claas, Frans H. J. Department of Immunohematology and Blood Transfusion, Leiden University Medical Center

  10. Class II Epitope Load and Immunogenicity Duquesnoy et al “Retransplant Candidates Have Donor-Specific Antibodies that React with Structurally Defined HLA-DR,DQ,DP Epitopes”. Transplant immunology, 18:352-360, 2008

  11. Anti-DRB1 and Anti-DRB3/4/5 Antibodies after Kidney Transplantation *p< 0.01

  12. Anti-DQ and anti-DRB1 Antibodies after Kidney Transplantation *p< 0.01

  13. The Epitope “Load” Determines the Immunogenicity of a Mismatched HLA Antigen

  14. How Important is DRB1 Matching in Kidney Transplantation?

  15. HLA Class II Matching • DRB1 is “standard” • DRB3/4/5 • Antibodies to DR51, DR52 and DR53 • DQB1 and DQA1 • Relevance of DQB matching in transplantation • Patients make antibodies to DQB and DQA epitopes • DPA1 and DPB1 • Relevance of DP matching • Anti-DP antibodies in transplantation

  16. A DR Antigen Mismatch Represents an Extra Epitope Load DRB1+ DRB3/4/5+ DQB+DQA+DPB+DPA

  17. Conventional Matching for a DR7,DR18 Patient Which is the “best” mismatch?

  18. Allele Based Compatibility for DR7,DR18 Patient All are common DR-DQ haplotypes

  19. Epitope-Based Compatibility for DR7,DR18 Patient All are common DR-DQ haplotypes Are DR8, DR9 and DR17 more “desirable” mismatches?

  20. Epitope-based HLA Class II Compatibility • Epitope compatibility information requires high-resolution DRB, DQ and DP types • It is possible to identify DR mismatches with relatively low epitope loads • Such mismatches may reduce anti-class II antibody responses and perhaps benefit transplant outcome ?

  21. HLA Mismatch Immunogenicity • Mismatched HLA antigens have different epitope loads • HLA epitopes have different degrees of immunogenicity

  22. Frequencies of antibodies to donor DQB eplet mismatches Duquesnoy et al Transplant immunology, 18:352-360, 2008

  23. Frequencies of antibodies to donor DQA eplet mismatches Duquesnoy et al Transplant immunology, 18:352-360, 2008

  24. Dominant Eplets Reacting with anti-HLA-DP Antibodies * 55DE is similar to the 57DE eplet on DR11 All 55DE-reactive sera reacted also with DR11 Duquesnoy et al Transplant immunology, 18:352-360, 2008

  25. The Antibody Response to an HLA Mismatch is Restricted to a Limited Number of Epitopes

  26. SERUM ANALYSIS AFTER TRANSPLANT NEPHRECTOMY REVEALS RESTRICTED ANTIBODY SPECIFICITY PATTERNS AGAINST STRUCTURALLY DEFINED HLA CLASS I MISMATCHES Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  27. Thirty Patients With Rejected Kidney Transplants Underwent Allograft Nephrectomy 100% 80% PRA 60% 40% 20% 0% Before Tx Pre-AlloNx. Post-AlloNx Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  28. Donor Epitopes:   A3: 62Qe,66rNv,70aQs,76Vd,80gTl,144tKr,149aAh,151aHe,163dT A31: 56R,62Qe,66rNv,74iD,76Vd,80gTl,193Av   B55: 131S   B63: 45Ma,66rNm,70aSa,74Y,131S Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  29. Donor Epitopes (serum-reactive epitopes are shown in underlined bold font) A3: 62Qe,66rNv,70aQs,76Vd,80gTl,144tKr,149aAh,151aHe,163dT A31: 56R,62Qe,66rNv,74iD,76Vd,80gTl,193Av B55: 131S B63: 45Ma,66rNm,70aSa,74Y,131S Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  30. Donor Epitopes (serum-reactive epitopes are shown in underlined bold font) A3: 62Qe,66rNv,70aQs,76Vd,80gTl,144tKr,149aAh,151aHe,163dT A31: 56R,62Qe,66rNv,74iD,76Vd,80gTl,193Av B55: 131S B63: 45Ma,66rNm,70aSa,74Y,131S Unacceptable epitopes identify unacceptable antigens e.g. 45Ma is present on B13, B46, B57,B62, B63. B75, B76, B76 Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  31. Donor Epitopes: B13: 41T,45Ma,76En,80rTa,82aLr,144tQl,163E 82aLr is expressed by all Bw4-associated HLA-B antigens +A23, A24, A25 and A32 144tQl is unique for HLA-B13 After six months: the anti-76En and anti-82aLr antibodies have disappeared, Only anti-144tQl antibodies are detected Adeyi et al. Transplant Immunology, 14: 53-62, 2005

  32. Relative Immunogenicity of Eplets How often do mismatched eplets induce specific antibodies? 14th International HLA Workshop Project Analysis of donor-specific antibodies in patients whose rejected kidney transplants had been removed

  33. Preliminary Results: Eplet Immunogenicity in 62 Cases Duquesnoy, RJ and Claas FHJ: Progress Report of 14th International Histocompatibility Workshop Project on the Structural Basis of HLA Compatibility, Tissue Antigens, 69 (Suppl. 1): 1-5, 2007

  34. 15th International Workshop Project on Epitope Immunogenicity • Analyze post-allograft nephrectomy sera for antibodies against donor class I and class II epitopes • Serum screening with single alleles (Luminex) and by CDC • So far, 40 laboratories worldwide will contribute informative cases • For more information go to http://www.15ihiws.org/project.php?n=13 To participate please contact Frans Claas or Rene Duquesnoy

  35. HLA Mismatch Immunogenicity • Mismatched HLA antigens have different epitope loads • HLA epitopes have different degrees of immunogenicity A better understanding of HLA immunogenicity will permit a permissible mismatch strategy for non-sensitized transplant patients

  36. New Website http://www.HLAMatchmaker.net • Introductory articles and tutorials • HLAMatchmaker related publications • From UPMC • From other institutions • Free downloads of all programs • Class I and class II matching • Antibody analysis • Other programs • Contacts and communications

More Related