1 / 7

UK Prosecution and Policing Guidelines: working with country authorities to mitigate injustice

UK Prosecution and Policing Guidelines: working with country authorities to mitigate injustice. Lisa Power, Terrence Higgins Trust July 2012, Washington. England & Wales Prosecutions for transmission of HIV since 2003 THT monitored cases from the start; national helpline

field
Download Presentation

UK Prosecution and Policing Guidelines: working with country authorities to mitigate injustice

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. UK Prosecution and Policing Guidelines: working with country authorities to mitigate injustice Lisa Power, Terrence Higgins Trust July 2012, Washington

  2. England & Wales • Prosecutions for transmission of HIV since 2003 • THT monitored cases from the start; national helpline • Collected notes on cases centrally; worked with other groups • Used findings to lobby for change

  3. What did we find? • Poor understanding of HIV, transmission, risks, etc. from legal authorities • High levels of confusion about what was an offence • Attempts to charge with wide range of offences e.g. assault, rape, grievous bodily harm • Use of HIV charges as proxy for other offences • Severe misuse of scientific evidence • Considerable waste of resources and time investigating hopeless complaints

  4. What did we do? • Worked with friendly police to document poor practice and get it acknowledged • Approached Crown Prosecution Service to get guidance based on this • Went back to police to get further guidance for them based on CPS rulings • Worked with authorities to check how guidance used

  5. What did we get? • Defined limits of what is prosecuted • Defined process of approval for prosecutions • Clarity on issues of law – evidence, public interest, witness care • Advice for people with HIV about the issue • Ongoing relationship for trouble shooting

  6. What did we learn? • You need good relationships to open doors • You can use human rights/equalities as a lever where these are respected • You can use precedent – other types of guidance • You need evidence of what’s wrong • You need to convince them change is in their interests • BUT – no system is perfect. We’re still arguing – but at least we’re talking.

  7. Thanks to: Yusef Azad of NAT – our co-conspirators Edwin Bernard for the global comparators GNP for taking the issue seriously www.tht.org.uk

More Related