140 likes | 255 Views
Alliances and War. V&H, Chapter 1 (Levy). Introduction. Alliance : A formal agreement among a limited number of countries concerning the conditions under which they will or will not employ military force. COW Alliance Types. Defense pact Neutrality/Non-aggression pact Entente.
E N D
Alliances and War V&H, Chapter 1 (Levy)
Introduction Alliance: A formal agreement among a limited number of countries concerning the conditions under which they will or will not employ military force.
COW Alliance Types • Defense pact • Neutrality/Non-aggression pact • Entente
Alliance-War Relationship • Alliances make war less likely • Balance of Power theory • Deterrence • They reduce uncertainty
Alliance-War Relationship • Alliances make war more likely • They generate counter alliances and arms races • Audience costs • Permanent alliances reduce the number of potential coalitions against the aggressors
Empirical Findings • Alliances were associated with peace in the 19th century, but war in the 20th century • Alliances make the expansion of war more likely • Allies are not reliable during war (Sabrosky); allies are reliable during war (Leeds, Long, and Mitchell)
Jack Levy’s Study • He focuses on Great Powers (GP) from 1495-1975 • Interstate wars involving at least one GP (119 total, 64 with GP’s on both sides) • Question: are alliances necessary and/or sufficient conditions for war?
Number of Alliances Over Time Century 16th 17th 18th 19th 20th Total # of alliances 5 9 15 25 65 119 # of GP 4 5 14 14 40 47 alliances % GP alliances 80% 56% 93% 56% 15% 39%
Necessary Condition • Every war (Y) will be preceded by an alliance (X) • Some alliances (X) may not lead to war
Sufficient Condition • Every X (alliance) will be followed by Y (war) • Some wars may occur when there is no X (alliance)
Levy’s Conclusions • Most alliances were followed by war within 5 years (except the 19th century) • Thus alliance is a near sufficient condition for war in most centuries • However, most wars were not preceded by alliances • Alliances are not necessary conditions for war
Alliance Reliability • Do alliance partners come to each other’s aid in war? • Allies do what they promise 75% of the time (Leeds, Long, Mitchell)