270 likes | 466 Views
Oxygen and wine. Wes Ward April 2013. Oxygen and wine. Make. Break. I mpacts depend on: Period of addition Oxygen amount pH SO2 Temperature Etc…. Micro-organism growth. Aroma profile evolution. B rowning. Color stability. Organoleptic defaults. Reduction of astringency.
E N D
Oxygen and wine Wes Ward April 2013
Oxygen and wine Make Break • Impacts depend on: • Period of addition • Oxygenamount • pH • SO2 • Temperature • Etc… Micro-organismgrowth Aroma profile evolution Browning Colorstability Organoleptic defaults Reduction of astringency
Measurement application domain Why measuring? Assessing winemaking steps Controling at different oxygen amounts (macro/micro/nano) Assessing consistency Must Preparation Maturation (barrel aging, micro-oxygenation) Bottling (TPO) & Bottle Aging (OTR) Degree of Oxygen Exposure
Objectives Mapping the process and defining strategies source Oenomeca Process Mapping HACCP
Electrochemical methods • Generated current is proportional • to O2 partial pressure or to mass • of O2 transformed during electrolysis • Circulation in the cell • Destructive method • Need of inert gas • Portable • Very Accurate • 1 point calibration • HS measurement possible
Luminescence Methods • Immersion • Stirring in the tank • Non-destructive • Non-invasive depending on device and brand • Very Accurate • No calibration • Portable
YSI - Probe • Method – Electro-chemistry • Evasive • Somewhat Portable • Can measure both Dissolved O2 Only • Detection Limit of .001 ppm (1ppb) • Detection Limit - 0–20ppm • Accuracy +/- .01ppm • No cross sensitivity to C02 or SO2 • Food Certified • Primary Industry – Water
Oxybaby • Method – amperometry– probe only • Invasive – probe only • Portable • Cannot measure Dissolved O2 • Can measure Headspace O2 only • No In-line measurement • Detection Limit of .1% O2 • Detection Limit – 0-100% O2 • Accuracy .10% • No cross sensitivity to C02 or SO2 • Headspace only with Bag-in-Box applications • Not food certified, probe only • Primary Industry – Food Packaging
Orbisphere • Method – Electro-chemistry – no dipping probe • Invasive • Portable, but usually fixed (lab application) • Can measure Dissolved O2 • Extremely difficult to measure headspace O2 • In-line only • Detection Limit of .001 ppm (1ppb) • Detection Limit – 0-20ppm • Accuracy <= 1% of reading • No cross sensitivity to C02 or SO2 • Ability to measure Bag-in-Box applications • Not food certified, it is a destructive test • Primary Industry - Beverage
Hach Ultra LDO • Method – Luminescence – dipping probe only • Invasive • Portable • Can measure Dissolved O2 – No HS • In-line not possible • Detection Limit of .001 ppm (1ppb) • Detection Limit – 0-20ppm • Accuracy <= .2ppm • Low sensitivity to C02 or SO2 • Not able to measure with Bag-in-Box applications • Not food certified, it is a destructive test • Primary Industry – Waste Water
Oxysense • Method - Luminescence – sensor spots, Non-invasive • Not truly portable • Can measure Dissolved O2 & Headspace O2 • Can measure In-line • Detection Limit of .015 ppm (15ppb) • Detection Limit – 0-15ppm • Accuracy <= 5% of reading • Cross sensitive to C02 or SO2 • Light interferences • Bag-in-Box applications possible • Not food certified • Primary Industry – Food Packaging
Ocean Optics – Neofox • Method – Luminescence – sensor spots & dipping probe • Non-Invasive • Portable, but requires a PC to read • Can measure Dissolved O2 & Headspace O2 • In-line ability • Detection Limit of .04 ppm (40ppb) • Detection Limit – 0-40ppm • Accuracy <= 5% of reading • Cross sensitivity to C02 or SO2 is unknown • Sensors susceptible to ethanol • Bag-in-Box applications possible • Not food certified • Primary Industry – Waste Water
NomaSense • Method – Luminescence (sensor spots & dipping probe) • Non-destructive & Non – Invasive • Very Portable • Can measure both Dissolved O2 & Head Space O2 • Can measure in-line • Detection Limit of .001 ppm (1ppb) • Detection Limit - 0–40ppm • Accuracy <= .01ppm • No cross sensitivity to C02 or SO2 • Ability to measure Bag-in-Box applications • Food Certified • CIP possible • Primary Industry – Wine • Fully validated for wine applications
Validation procedure • Certified gases (GEC) ranging • from 0 to 21% O2 • Experimentalset-up for both • Head space and dissolvedoxygen • Procedure MA-F-AS1-06-PROVAL • recommended by the OIV • Linearity, repeatability, reproducibility • LOD, LOQ, selectivity and accuracy
Elements of validation • All technologies are very accurate • NomaSense showing the best performances • Broader range of application for NomaSense m-GC Orbisphere NomaSense
Available tools Sight Glass Dipping Probe Analyzer Side Glass Sensors Transparent BIB taps
Different measurement approaches Sight Glass Dipping Probe Sensors
Measuring in a bottle Headspace How much oxygen is in the bottle? Dissolved
Bottling Consistency O2 difference of 0.90 ppm O2 42
Inerting before Filling • Inerting before filling can reduce up to 0.5 ppm Without Inerting With inerting
Head Space Management for Inner Seals No Vacuum Pick-up = 3ppm Vacuum: Pick-up= 1.4 ppm Vacuum + CO2 Pick-up = 0.2 ppm HSO in hPa
The New NomaSense O2 analyzer • 2nd Generation NomaSense • Overall reduction in size & weight • More intuitive user interface • New calibration management through bar code reading • New sensor management via new file structure • Compatible with existing sensors and accessories • The only TPO meter on the market • No need to run separate calculations in excel files