450 likes | 474 Views
Management of Abstinence. Bradley J. Phillips, MD. Substance Abuse. Alcohol Abuse 76 million people in the US MVC leading cause of death 50% of MVC involve alcohol 2/5 Americans involved 67% of home, fire, and job injuries Illicit Drug Abuse cocaine > 50% of trauma
E N D
Management of Abstinence Bradley J. Phillips, MD
Substance Abuse • Alcohol Abuse • 76 million people in the US • MVC leading cause of death • 50% of MVC involve alcohol • 2/5 Americans involved • 67% of home, fire, and job injuries • Illicit Drug Abuse • cocaine > 50% of trauma • cocaine > 80% of violent crime
Pitfalls of Intoxication • Increased incidence of diagnostic errors • desire to “treat and street” • assuming just a “repeater” • failure to recognize serious neurologic lesions • decreased pain perception
Acute/Chronic EtOH Effects on Physiology • Respiratory • “snoring” = partial airway obstruction • prone to aspirate • Cardiovascular • decreased compensatory response to hemorrhage • increased arrhythmias • increased cardiomyopathy
Acute/Chronic EtOH Effects on Physiology • Neurologic • Korsakoff’s syndrome • Wernicke’s syndrome • peripherial neuropathy • GI • cirrhosis • GI bleeds • varices • peptic ulcers
Acute/Chronic EtOH Effects on Physiology • Metabolism • alcohol ketoacidosis • hypoglycemia • Hematology • coagulopathies • anemia • poor resistance to infection
Illicit Drugs Effects on Physiology • Cocaine/amphetamines/hallucinogens • respiratory difficulty • tachycardia • hypertension • Narcotics/barbiturates/tranquilizers • hypoventilation • bradycardia • hypotension
Cocaine • Local anesthetic and sympathomimetic • Hyperdynamic cardiovascular response • CVA (hypertensive crisis) • Myocardial infarcts • Aortic dissection • Pulmonary edema/bronchospasm • Rhabdomyolysis • GI ischemia/perforations • Mental status (judgement, paranoia)
Opiates • Decreased mental status • Hypotension • Hypovolemia • Pulmonary congestion • Infectious (heroin)
Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 tremulous hallucinatory epileptic delirious Historical Withdrawal • Victor and Adams, 1953 • Ist comprehensive account • 4 “states” • occur separately or in combinations • mortality = 15% (delirium state)
“Modern” EtOH Withdrawal • Acute Withdrawal • hours to days • irritability, tremulous, tachycardia • Delirium tremens (DT’s) • usually > 48 hrs tremors tachycardia confusion hypertension delusions hyperreflexia hallucinations seizures
“Modern” Time Course Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
Symptoms drug craving restlessness irritability dec. pain tolerance nausea cramps anxiety myoclonus delirium Signs tachycardia sweating vomiting diarrhea hypertension fever seizure tachypnea Diagnosis
Evaluation • History • timing of last usage • amount • previous withdrawal/seizures • family member informant • Labs • EtOH/toxicology screen (blood/urine) • CBC/coags • electrolytes/bun/cr/mg/phos/LFT’s
Differential Dx • Hypoxia • Shock/hypovolemia • Head trauma • Sepsis • Hypoglycemia • Electrolyte abnormalities • Withdrawal
DT’s Complications • Significant co-morbidity • Cardiac collapse • CI 36% • O2 consumption 25% • Seizures • Renal failure • Mortality • 1 to 15%
Onset/Duration of Complications Duration (hrs.) Time to Onset (hrs.) Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
Shown beneficial benzodiazepines alpha-adrenergic agonist anti-seizures Propofol barbiturates neuroleptics clomethiazole No efficacy (humans) beta-adrenergic antagonist Ca-channel blockers ethyl alcohol magnesium thiamine Pharmacological Management
Benzodiazepines • Moskowitz et al, Alcohol Clin Exp Res, 1983 - 81 studies • Only proven efficacious drug • Drugs of choice • Safer than other drugs if taken in excess
Benzodiazepines • Pharmacological characteristics • CNS and peripherial interaction with GABA receptors • no particular one better at preventing withdrawal symptoms • ? longer-acting better at preventing seizures • no data on reducing delirium • duration of action dependent on lipophilicity, volume of distribution and half-life • hepatic metabolism only
Long-acting Chlordiazepoxide (Librium) active metabolites t1/2 = 1-8 days po/IV/IM avoid IM Diazepam (Valium) active metabolites t1/2 = 25-100 hrs po/IV/IM avoid IM Short-acting Lorazepam (Ativan) no active metabolites t1/2 = 10-20 hrs. slower onset of action po/IV/IM Midazolam (Versed) active metabolites t1/2 = < 12 hrs IV/IM Benzodiazepines
Benzodiazepines • Method of Dosing • scheduled vs. prn • Sellers et al, Clin Phar Ther, 1983 • valium 20 mg q 1-2 hrs prn • successful = 72% (valium) vs 56% (placebo) • 90% improved in 30 hrs. • Saitz et al, JAMA, 1994 • po Librium scheduled vs prn • scheduled = 68 hrs. vs prn = 9 hrs. • scheduled = 425 mg vs. prn = 100 mg
Benzodiazepines Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
Benzodiazepines • Adverse effects • respiratory depression • cardiovascular depression • iatrogenic withdrawal • metabolic acidosis • propylene glycol • carrier in diazepam IV • converted to lactic acid • also found in silver sulfadiazene, IV nitro, and etomidate
Barbiturates • Used by 10% of detoxification programs • No controlled studies for effectiveness • Advantages • low abuse potential • cheap • well-documented anti-seizure • Disadvantages • greater respiratory depression • cardiovascular depression • lower safety profile than benzodiazepines
Clonidine • Alpha1-adrenergic agonist • Controlling withdrawal symptoms/signs • superior to placebo • equivalent to carbazepine + neuroleptic • superior to clomethiazole • Controlling delirium/seizures • no adequate sized studies • Clonidine vs benzodiazepine • only one randomized study • no significant difference • seizure patients excluded
Neuroleptics • No controlled studies • Early studies less effective than benzos • Advantages • effective for psychosis • safe respiratory/cardiovascular profile • Disadvantages • increased seizures (thorazine,promazine) • extra-pyramidal side-effects
Carbamazepine • Used in Europe • Efficacious vs clomethiazole/placebo • Advantages • lower abuse potential • less CNS depression • Disadvantages • side-effects = N/V, vertigo, rash • 50% stop therapy secondary SE • IV not available in US
Propofol • Activates GABA-A receptor • Effectiveness • no controlled studies • ? benefit in refractory withdrawal • adjunct to primary therapy • Advantage • short-acting • easily titratable • Disadvantage • tolerance • cost
Alternative Agents • Beta-adrenergic antagonists • IV/po differential effectiveness • studies support effective for tremors • Advantages • ? may be effective for mild withdrawal • no addiction potential • Disadvantages • cardiovascular effects • cause hallucinations • no role for mod-severe withdrawal
Alternative Agents • Clomethiazole (Used in Europe) • effective as benzos and barbiturates • severe adverse effects • Ethyl alcohol • no trials on safety/efficacy • numerous adverse effects • Magnesium • no reduction in delirium/seizures • Thiamine • no reduction in delirium/seizures • prevention of Wernicke-Korsakoff
Recommendations • Benzodiazepines • ativan/valium prn • Clonidine • adjunctive agent • excellent control of hyperadrenergic state • po preferred over patch • Neuroleptics • excellent control of psychosis • possible side-effects (less likely with Haldol) • Propofol/barbiturates • 2nd line adjuncts
Recommendations • Dosing • Closely monitored setting • prn dosing • IV for acute withdrawal/inability to tolerate po • Untrained monitoring setting • fixed-scheduled po dosing
Outcomes • Increased mortality • Luna et al, J Trauma, 1984 • double mortality vs sober with similar injuries • Waller et al, JAMA, 1986 • 1.7 to 2.1x mortality vs. matched sober MVC • Tinkoff, Ann Surg, 1990 • 30-40% mortality in cirrhotic trauma • sepsis and MSOF • predictors - ascites, PT, bilirubin, laparotomy
Delay in Treatment Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
Length of Stay Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
Risk Factors Foy, Kay, Taylor. QJM, 1997
ICU Withdrawal Syndrome • Cammarano, Crit Care Med, 1998 • Retrospective study • Trauma/surgical ICU • 28 mechanically ventilated patients • > 7 day ICU stay
ICU Drug Potencies Cammarano et al, Crit Care Med, 1998
Non-withdrawal Withdrawal ICU Withdrawal vs Drug Cammarano et al, Crit Care Med, 1998
Non-withdrawal Withdrawal Duration Cammarano et al, Crit Care Med, 1998
Non-withdrawal Withdrawal Mean Doses Cammarano et al, Crit Care Med, 1998
ICU Withdrawal Syndrome • Results • 32 % acute withdrawal • opiates/benzodiazepines • ICU stay > 7 days • withdrawal group • higher daily doses of fentanyl and ativan • received neuromuscular blockade • received propofol • longer duration of agents
ICU Withdrawal Syndrome • Prevention • adequate monitoring of level of sedation • avoid neuromuscular blockade if possible • realization of predisposition • ARDS • younger patients • wean opiates/benzo in pts at risk • 5-10% / day • ? change to longer acting agent po • use bolus method over continuous