120 likes | 232 Views
Why should we want to screen ?. Survival ( years ). Goldstraw et al. J Thorac Oncol 2007. Why should we want to screen ?. Localised. Stage shift !. Regional spread. Distant spread. When diagnosis is based on symptoms. When diagnosis is based on screening.
E N D
Whyshouldwewanttoscreen? Survival (years) Goldstraw et al. J ThoracOncol 2007
Whyshouldwewanttoscreen? Localised Stage shift ! Regional spread Distantspread Whendiagnosisisbased on symptoms Whendiagnosisisbased on screening
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) • Inclusioncriteria • Age 55-74 years • Smoking history ≥30PY, activeorstoppedlessthan 15 yearsago • Exclusioncriteria • History of lungcancer • Other priorcancer in past 5 years • Chest CT lessthan 18 monthsago • Unexplainedweightloss (>15lb in pastyear) • Metallic implantsordevices in chestor back • Home oxygensupplementation • Pneumoniatreatedwithantibiotics in past 12 weeks Aberle et al. N Engl J Med 2011
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) • 53’454 subjectsrandomisedtoone of twogroups: • Low dose CT • Chest X-ray • 3 screening roundsatannualintervals • Non-calcifiednodules ≥4mm in CT oranysize in X-raywerereferredfordiagnosticwork-up • Primary outcome: lungcancerrelatedmortality Aberle et al. N Engl J Med 2011
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) Aberle et al. N Engl J Med 2011
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) Aberle et al. N Engl J Med 2011
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) Kovalchik et al. N Engl J Med 2013
National lungscreeningtrial (NLST) Kovalchik et al. N Engl J Med 2013
Lung cancer screening trials Boiselle, JAMA 2013
Screening recommendations Boiselle, JAMA 2013
Open issues • Isone positive trialenoughevidence? • Was thereoverdiagnosis in the NSLT? • Will otherpopulationsatriskoflungcancerbenefitfrom CT screening? • Screening of a large, at-riskpopulationpossible? • Howmanyscreeningrounds? • Costeffectiveness? • «sideeffects» ofscreening (i.e.radiationexposure)
Conclusions • Lung cancer is a lethal disease associated with substantial medical and economic burden. • NLST: lung cancer screening may reduce mortality considerably. • Possible advantage of LDCT screening has to be balanced against the potential of inducing harm. • Many issues are not yet resolved: i.e. overdiagnosis, number of screening rounds, study population, cost-efficacy. • Further evidenceandinformationisneeded, beforelungcancerscreeningcanberecommended in Switzerland.