220 likes | 367 Views
Global trends in Voter Turnout. Joram Rukambe, Africa Programme Manager, International IDEA. Objectives of the Presentation. Highlight key trends in voter turnout and participation at the global level
E N D
Global trends in Voter Turnout Joram Rukambe, Africa Programme Manager, International IDEA
Objectives of the Presentation • Highlight key trends in voter turnout and participation at the global level • Presentation based on research done by International IDEA on voter turnout world wide: 1945-2001 • Key sources include IDEA database on voter turnout (2002); The Global Report on Voter Turnout (2002); and the regional follow-up for Western Europe (2004) – see www.idea.int
Introduction • The 20th and 21th centuries saw increased enfranchisement of voters across geographical, racial, socio-economic and gender divides • The 1970s – 1990s saw globalization of democracy - the ‘third wave of democracy’ • Independence & Democracy increased democratic countries from 27 % in 1970 to 62% in 2000 (Freedom House).
More avenues for political participation TODAY than EVER before • Direct Democracy • Citizen’s initiatives • Recalls • Referenda • Elections: • Supranational • National (federal/central) • State (provincial/regional) • Local/district/municipal/canton • Lobbying and media debates Civic and other community-based (traditional & religious) forums: (Khotla)
Reality check • 2004 saw more people voting than ever before in the history of mankind • US, Ukraine, Indonesia, Afghanistan, India, etc. • European Parliament • South Africa Botswana Namibia Mozambique
Regional trends in voter turnout: 1990 - 2001 • Eastern Europe • 72% • Western Europe • 78% • Oceania (Pacific and Australia) • 79% • North, Central, and Southern America, Caribbean • 65% • Africa • 64%
Regional trends cont. • Western Europe • Liechtenstein (17) 92% • Belgium (18) 92.5% • Oceana • Australia (22) 94% • New Zealand (19) 92% N-America and Caribbean Bahamas (6) 91% Canada (18) 73% • Africa • Burundi (1) 91% • Angola (1) 91% • Mauritius (7) 82% • South Africa, Malawi, Namibia, Mozambique
Correlation between democratic consolidation and voter turnout?
Slow and steady decline in voter turnout since the 1980s • Voter apathy is across all regions: older and newer, and smaller and larger democracies.
Voter Apathy is more pronounced among: • Young voters • High-income voters • Diaspora voters • Increased access to information and education among women has reduced the ‘gender gap’ in voting since 1980
Factors influencing electoral participation Socio-political factors Institutional/systemic factors Mechanical/Procedural factors Other factors
Socio-political Factors • Bad governance: scandals, lack of transparency and accountability • Voter distrust of political and electoral processes: ‘elections will always be stolen’ • Literacy rate • Gerrymander • Lack of viable alternative to the incumbent: ‘when elections are over before they start’ • Social exclusion and political disenfranchisement: women, non-nationals, young voters, absentee voters
Systemic Factors • Electoral system: PR yield higher voter turnout compared to FPTP, unless in close-result constituencies • Voting age constraint: lowering to 16? • Allowing non-national to vote, especially in local elections? • Compulsory vs. voluntary registration and voting: pros and cons
Systemic Factors • Party-systems: multiparty systems tend to encourage high turnout, especially if each vote counts and is not be ‘wasted’ • Election dates: holiday season - Dec 26th!rainy season?
Mechanical factors • Access to voter registration and voting: time and distance • Access to information and education on democracy, elections, and voting • Several day voting [Mozambique, Namibia] • Declaring voting day a public holiday, or voting during the weekend • Voter fatigue. ‘Yoked elections? • Easy access to registration and voting for PLDs: Braille & wheelchair-friendly venues
Mechanical factors • Automation of key electoral processes (making it easy): • Voter registration [state initiated & continuous] • Voting • Counting • Access to election dispute resolution mechanisms, including alternative dispute resolution mechanisms (party liaison structures)
Other Factors which affect electoral participation • EMB independence and competence: • How members are appointed and operate • Staff skills and competence • EMB financial and operational autonomy • EMB stakeholder management capacity • Public trust and confidence in political and electoral processes • The EMB must work hard to make this possible – ‘making the impossible possible’
Conclusion • The process of increasing voter turnout requires a two-prong approach: • Systemic reform: electoral systems and election procedures • Introduction of vigorous and sustained civic and voter education campaigns to lure voters back to the polls • Stakeholder participation (multi-sectoral collaboration) is critical for the success of this two-prong intervention • -End-