100 likes | 209 Views
Network Demarcation in 802.1aj. Alan McGuire IEEE 802.1 Eilat Interim May 2008. Introduction. Annex K of 802.1aj contains some use cases and invites suggestions for more! Following slides suggest some other scenarios Provider to provider cases rather than enterprise to provider
E N D
Network Demarcation in 802.1aj Alan McGuire IEEE 802.1 Eilat Interim May 2008
Introduction • Annex K of 802.1aj contains some use cases and invites suggestions for more! • Following slides suggest some other scenarios • Provider to provider cases rather than enterprise to provider • Also current models do not consider End 2 End • Discuss • Are they allowed in the 802.1aj model? • Can they be managed? • Should any be included as Use Cases in annex K? • Use Cases • Multiple TPMRs, Multiple Domains • Use with PBB
Multiple TPMRs, Multiple Domains Domain A Domain B NNI NNI 802.1 Provider Bridge 802.1 Provider Bridge TPMR TPMR TPMR TPMR 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 User Link 802.3 User Link 802.3 Ext Link • Notes • Management of Domain A is separate from that of Domain B • Can TPMRs in Domain B be managed in this scenario? > need something between them • NNI is UNI in Enterprise-Provider examples
Multiple TPMRs, Multiple Domains Domain A Domain B NNI NNI 802.1 Provider Bridge 802.1 Provider Bridge TPMR TPMR TPMR TPMR 802.3 User Link 802.3 User Link 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 Ext Link • Notes • Management of Domain A is separate from that of Domain B • Can TPMRs in Domain B be managed in this scenario? > need something else
Multiple TPMRs, Multiple Domains Domain A Domain B NNI NNI 802.1 Provider Bridge 802.1 Provider Bridge TPMR TPMR TPMR TPMR 802.1ah encaps 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 Ext Link 802.3 User Link 802.3 User Link 802.3 Ext Link • Notes • Management of Domain A is separate from that of Domain B • Can TPMRs in Domain B be managed in this scenario? • NNI is UNI in Enterprise-Provider examples
Options to consider-I User Link User SP1 SP2 User UNI UNI ENNI Extension Links Extension Links Would seem to be ok since -user link should prevent E-W OAM issues - SNMP issues
Options to consider-II Ext Link User Link User Link User SP1 SP2 User UNI UNI ENNI Extension Links Extension Links Would seem to present problems since Ext Link will likely: -not present SPx access to SPy TPMRs for E-W OAM beyond pt of connectivity -not prevent SPx access via SNMP stack to SPy TPMRs
Options to consider-III User Link User OP1 User SPA SPA’ UNI UNI ENNI ENNI Extension Links Extension Links Extension Links A=A’ Or AA’ Same as option I however limitation with A=A’ No access from SPa(1) to SPa(2) between 1 and 2
Options to consider-IV Ext Link User Link User Link User OP1 User SPA SPA’ UNI UNI ENNI ENNI Extension Links Extension Links Extension Links A=A’ Or AA’ Same issues as II
Options to consider-V OAM OP1 SPA SPA ENNI ENNI mgmt mgmt Extension Links Extension Links Extension Links Can this be achieved via hierarchy?